What's new
IconEra

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Forums  ›  Gaming
Analysis 
around 160 million people shared between both systems.

Why are you sharing them?

Anyway, around 315 million shared their predecessors.

Double that.


Something can be considerably less successful than its predecessor and STILL be successful.

Hence why you say the SNES was LESS SUCCESSFUL than the NES. Because if you called it a failure you'd get publically lynched. Same thing for N64, GBA, Gamecube, etc.

The PS3 and 3DS were failures.

Go check how much money Sony lost on the PS3.

most-profitable-generation-to-date-1717025772665.jpg


Here you go.
 
Why chase for something that has no guarantee of actually sticking?
Example: SIE trading their bread and butter single player games for live service games
Sony's move was way more greedy and hectic, it was Sony rushing to get into a market that was already full of competition from other GAAS games. Nintendo's move is the opposite, it's filling a gap in the HW market to capture the 30% cut in ball and gun gamers, GAAS, to get all AAA games day 1 without any compromises, all that stuff is worth many billions.

Sony spent 3,6 billion on Bungie, hundreds of millions on Concord, Marathon, who knows how much on everything in total.
For Nintendo to make Switch 3 and a powerful home console there's R&D, marketing, games etc, around 1,5-3 billion, years of development.
Now 2-3 billion isn't nothing and it's not completely risk-free because nothing is but you can't deny the logic.
Overall it entrenches Nintendo's position in gaming so they offer something for everybody.
 
Why are you sharing them?

Anyway, around 315 million shared their predecessors.

Double that.




The PS3 and 3DS were failures.

Go check how much money Sony lost on the PS3.

most-profitable-generation-to-date-1717025772665.jpg


Here you go.
Microsoft also lost a lot of money on the Xbox 360 as well. Sony also lost money on the PSP thanks to piracy. They're still successful consoles.
3DS was also a success. You don't call an 80 million selling device a failure unless you're grasping at straws.

If you want to keep shifting goalposts to rip on objectively successful devices in order to win a minor point go ahead. Says a lot when you can't even attack any of the other points I made cause you know they're objectively true.
 
I never understood this logic because PS5 Pro exists, so why does Nintendo making a powerful console usurp that?

If Switch 3 for whatever reason reaches parity with PlayStation then they will be directly compared to Sony’s first party IP. The fact they escape this has been a luxury for them.
 
Microsoft also lost a lot of money on the Xbox 360 as well. Sony also lost money on the PSP thanks to piracy. They're still successful consoles.
3DS was also a success. You don't call an 80 million selling device a failure unless you're grasping at straws.

More like you are grasping at straws calling them a success.

most-profitable-generation-to-date-1717025772665.jpg
 
Xbox 360 was only considered a success because it sold well and gave Sony competition. Internally it was not a financial success for Microsoft, but it did elevate their brand power, pretty much have them a solid cult following, so it was a success.

3DS was not a success for Nintendo, however it did keep them afloat long enough to buy time for the Switch.
 
When Nintendo went head to head against Sony, they got their asses handed twice.

They tried again with the Wii U to cater to hardcore gamers and told everyone how it was more powerful than the PS3. Reggies whole shtick at the time was "Wii hear U!"

Flopped even harder than the GC.

Nintendo should just stick to what always worked for them, the handheld market.
 
Last edited:
They tried again with the Wii U to cater to hardcore gamers and told everyone how it was more powerful than the PS3.
What, no… The Wii U was very outdated on release - potentially more so than Wii. It has a weaker CPU than 360, which released late 2005…

Particular games might have performed slightly better than on PS3 and 360 (I think NFS was such an example), but it was only because those consoles were really long in the tooth at that point. A mid-range gaming PC at the time ran circles around Wii U. It didn’t feel the least bit modern.

Maybe Reggie mentioned that some game looked better on Wii U than on PS3, but I think you’re way overstating how big a part this was of Nintendo’s marketing.

Switch 2 probably has the most up-to-date hardware of any machine Nintendo’s released since Gamecube. Compared to PS5 it’s weak of course, but compared to other handhelds it’s holding its own.
 
Last edited:
Again, you're ignoring they won with Wii, Switch, 3DS killed Vita. Almost guaranteed to win gen 10 too.

They weren't even competing for the same market anymore with those devices. None of these devices other than the Wii were a home console and Wii was clearly targeted at a completely different audience than Xbox/PS were. Anyone who was around during that time knows. I've seen my aunts who never gamed in their life and never have done so since get a Wii to play Wii Sports and Fitness.

Literally what are you talking about.
They're not giving up on the hybrid advantage or giving up on their biggest strengths. But they are making a huge R&D building that will be finished like 2029 or something. It's easier for Nintendo to scale up than it is for Sony to scale down. To scale down you need multiple AA franchises that actually sell, to scale up you just need third party support and some AAA IPs that can sell consoles.
Their biggest IPs will be bigger, a lot of their IPs will remain "similar." A company like Game Freak for example just does what they want.

Dude how do you think they can maintain hybrid and also somehow compete with PS6 on hardware power? Switch 2 just launched last year and it's competing with PS4 at best, a 13-year-old console. If somehow a technological breakthrough happens that makes this possible, you think Sony wouldn't utilize the same technological breakthrough to push the performance of their home console even further ahead? Not to mention that with portables it's not so much a problem of that they can't put higher power hardware in them - it's that it becomes way more expensive to do so than it would've been for a stationary device and that it massively impacts battery life and form factor/weight.

And why would Sony scale down to try and compete with Nintendo on an equal playing field? That makes absolutely zero sense. Sony's advantage is that they are the dominant home console and the default in most people's eyes. "Scaling down" to go fight on Nintendo's terms is utterly retarded. Especially because we can see that the market Nintendo is controlling is generating less revenue than the one Sony is controlling, even though Nintendo has that market all to itself while Sony still has to cede a small part of it to Xbox and compete more directly with PC in a sense.

Also, if you argue their first party games will remain similar then what's the point of putting all this hardware power in the device and pumping up the price? First party games represent like 65-70% of all sales on their platform so if it's not going to utilize this extra power it's a waste of resources.

You mean like when the boss that said COD skipping Switch was a mistake? You're absolutely delusional if you think companies will make the same mistake twice, especially with the AI crisis. And flipping a few switches is just compared to actually natively porting a game vs upgrading a game for the same platform.

Lol you keep saying this but in reality the market publishers would unlock by supporting Switch is not nearly as big as you think it is. It's good for Japanese pubs because Nintendo is the dominant system in Japan. For western pubs it's more of a case-by-case basis. Many people in the west who owns Switches also own another device on which those games would be available and where they'll likely prefer to buy it instead (you can even see this in Japan with the sales of RE9 or Onimusha on PS5 vs Switch 2 for example).

And as we have argued plenty of times before - third parties have a backlog of dozens of games that they never put on Switch 1 due to how underpowered it was dating back to the PS4 gen that they can just port instead of trying to make new games work on Switch 2. Just look at how they ported Shadow of Mordor/War to Switch 2 last week.

If it was so easy to just "flip" a Switch to make games take advantage of new hardware power on a console then how come the vast majority of games never have said switch flipped?

You're totally missing the point as usual, this is about selling a Playstation killer so that's not just Nintendo fans lol.

I'm not missing the point. Your point is stupid, that's all. You are a fanboy obsessed with Nintendo somehow getting their revenge on PlayStation one day for getting pushed out of the traditional home console market. Something Nintendo itself obviously has absolutely zero interest in. Nintendo is happy they have a market all to their own where they set the pace and even the rumored PS6 handheld is going to do little to dislodge them from that position. Why the fuck would they rejoin PlayStation and Microsoft in a race to the bottom?

Especially as we can see more and more sentiments of how people don't care nearly as much about graphics anymore. Nintendo's advantages look much healthier in the long term than PlayStation's current advantages, the logical thing for Nintendo would be to just ride it out and it'll likely fall in place either way. Instead of burning through their cash trying to compete directly with PlayStation again (who have far more resources at their disposal) and possibly putting the company on the brink because the gaming business are an existential business for both companies.

That came at a cost: Nintendo effectively sacrificed a separate handheld business that once sold tens of millions of units alongside its home consoles. Switch sales aren’t simply evidence that Nintendo suddenly expanded its market.

What cost? After the Wii U the handheld market was pretty much all they had. This was no Wii + DS situation they were in anymore.

And Switch 2 repeating the original Switch’s extraordinary sales is far from guaranteed. The market has changed. Smartphones, PC, free-to-play games, social media and countless other forms of entertainment are fighting for everyone’s time and money—not just PlayStation’s.

These things were already a factor when Switch 1 launched and it didn't affect it at all. The only thing that might make things harder for Switch 2 compared to Switch 1 is the lack of a Covid boost and the fact that Switch 2 is living through the hardware component crisis and prices get adjusted accordingly.

Sony's move was way more greedy and hectic, it was Sony rushing to get into a market that was already full of competition from other GAAS games. Nintendo's move is the opposite, it's filling a gap in the HW market to capture the 30% cut in ball and gun gamers, GAAS, to get all AAA games day 1 without any compromises, all that stuff is worth many billions.

Sony spent 3,6 billion on Bungie, hundreds of millions on Concord, Marathon, who knows how much on everything in total.
For Nintendo to make Switch 3 and a powerful home console there's R&D, marketing, games etc, around 1,5-3 billion, years of development.
Now 2-3 billion isn't nothing and it's not completely risk-free because nothing is but you can't deny the logic.
Overall it entrenches Nintendo's position in gaming so they offer something for everybody.

What are you talking about lmao? Gap in the hardware market? Dude that gap is already filled by PlayStation. Nintendo burning billions in an attempt to dislodge PlayStation gamers and make them switch to their platform to... play the same games they are already playing on PlayStation... is just as delusional as PlayStation burning billions in an attempt to get the Overwatch crowd to play their version of it instead.

Also it's not just about how much it'll cost them in R&D. If this attempt to return to the home console market to compete directly with PlayStation backfires, and there's a big chance it will, they are losing out on billions of revenue.

If Switch 3 for whatever reason reaches parity with PlayStation then they will be directly compared to Sony’s first party IP. The fact they escape this has been a luxury for them.

What? Nintendo's first party lineup is way more robust and popular. Like, the third-best selling Switch 1 exclusive (Super Smash Bros) outsold every single PlayStation exclusive ever created. And the gap between the third-best Switch 1 title and the second-best title is like 20m+ sales.
 
And why would Sony scale down to try and compete with Nintendo on an equal playing field?
In case more of their big games flop obviously.

Also, if you argue their first party games will remain similar then what's the point of putting all this hardware power in the device and pumping up the price? First party games represent like 65-70% of all sales on their platform so if it's not going to utilize this extra power it's a waste of resources.
For third parties and some first party games just don't benefit from more power like 2D games.
The biggest first party games like 3D Mario, 3D Zelda, Animal Crossing, Mario Kart, Splatoon, Smash, is where it gets much more interesting.
Not sure where Smash would land in the 2030s but 4K 60 FPS? 4K 120 FPS? Either way the biggest games gets a huge boost from power, it's as simple as that. Pokemon is the weird one because of Game Freak.

Nintendo's advantages look much healthier in the long term than PlayStation's current advantages, the logical thing for Nintendo would be to just ride it out and it'll likely fall in place either way.
That's what the thread is about though. AI crisis will ruin PS6 and Nintendo rides it out with Switch 2 and then makes Switch 3 and a powerful home console and reaps the rewards.

Gap in the hardware market? Dude that gap is already filled by PlayStation
Sony just came out and admitted that ND's next projects are very early stage and they're both TLOU projects.
They have an extremely weak line-up for PS6. Playstation is very weak right now. After TLOU 2 I don't even have faith in Naughty Dog anymore.

Also it's not just about how much it'll cost them in R&D. If this attempt to return to the home console market to compete directly with PlayStation backfires, and there's a big chance it will, they are losing out on billions of revenue.
Oh? How is it a big chance it will? The Last of Us 3 and Horizon 3 will be so good on the $1000+ console that it alters the very gaming landscape so Nintendo cancels the Switch 3 and home console?
 
In case more of their big games flop obviously.

Do you understand these two companies have completely different business models? Sony's own games make up less than 3% of their total revenue or whatever. Even if you narrow it down to just game sales they maybe make up 10-15% of total game sales. It doesn't really matter all that much if their games flop or succeed. It's why they had a megabomb like Concord and it didn't even register on their earnings result.

The idea that they would somehow voluntarily give up their competitive advantage not only in relation to Nintendo but also to PC (as being the alternative high-end platform with the most stable environment to play most of the industry's games with a lower cost of entry) just because of a few flops here and there makes absolutely zero sense. PlayStation won't scale down. Right now they're already a generation's worth of power ahead and the moment they put out the PS6 they'll be two generations ahead. Whether that will matter as we enter the valley of diminishing returns that most ordinary customers seemingly don't care for remains to be seen.

For third parties and some first party games just don't benefit from more power like 2D games.
The biggest first party games like 3D Mario, 3D Zelda, Animal Crossing, Mario Kart, Splatoon, Smash, is where it gets much more interesting.
Not sure where Smash would land in the 2030s but 4K 60 FPS? 4K 120 FPS? Either way the biggest games gets a huge boost from power, it's as simple as that. Pokemon is the weird one because of Game Freak.

They already got Mario Kart, Splatoon and Donkey Kong running at 60 fps with a good resolution. They don't need more hardware power. If the argument is that they need even more hardware power so they can crank up the fidelity and detail on these games even further, guess what, that will also increase development time and budgets of these games. And it won't necessarily increase sales. We've seen as much with PlayStation's first party lineup over the past years.

People play these Nintendo games for their gameplay and they always have stylized art styles that don't rely so much on raw hardware power.

That's what the thread is about though. AI crisis will ruin PS6 and Nintendo rides it out with Switch 2 and then makes Switch 3 and a powerful home console and reaps the rewards.

If the AI crisis is disastrous enough to kill PlayStation, there won't be any home console market left and there'd be zero reason for Nintendo to try and fill the gap for a market that has been wiped out. They could just continue their regular hardware upgrade cycle and no one would notice.

Sony just came out and admitted that ND's next projects are very early stage and they're both TLOU projects.
They have an extremely weak line-up for PS6. Playstation is very weak right now. After TLOU 2 I don't even have faith in Naughty Dog anymore.

Again, 90% of the games sold on PlayStation are multiplatform titles anyway. People primarily buy PlayStation to buy third party titles, not first party ones. They are not blue Nintendo. Naughty Dog hasn't even released Intergalactic yet. That might be a swan song title for the PS5 like TLOU2 was for PS4 and will naturally get a PS6 version with more bells and whistles. No one actually knows the lineup for PS6 and it's not going to matter much anyway because even if they had killer apps, the price (which is largely out of their control) is going to deter a lot of people.

Oh? How is it a big chance it will? The Last of Us 3 and Horizon 3 will be so good on the $1000+ console that it alters the very gaming landscape so Nintendo cancels the Switch 3 and home console?

No? There won't be a Nintendo home console again and Switch 3 won't be cancelled, it will just continue a natural upgrade cycle where it'll maybe be on par with PS5 power finally. Just like Switch 2 reached PS4-level power only last year. And as I wrote above, people buy PlayStation for third party titles. You're not going to undo 30-40 years of conditioning and brand recognition by offering people something they already have (third party games at high fidelity on a home console).
 
It doesn't really matter all that much if their games flop or succeed.
You've lost your mind, bro

They don't need more hardware power. If the argument is that they need even more hardware power so they can crank up the fidelity and detail on these games even further, guess what, that will also increase development time and budgets of these games.
Nintendo already basically does 1 game per generation and will use remakes to cut down on time so I wouldn't worry about that. Nintendo got plenty of games they can remake. It adds more work but it also simplies the future transition for next-gen.

And it won't necessarily increase sales. We've seen as much with PlayStation's first party lineup over the past years.
Oh, I bet it will.

If the AI crisis is disastrous enough to kill PlayStation, there won't be any home console market left and there'd be zero reason for Nintendo to try and fill the gap for a market that has been wiped out. They could just continue their regular hardware upgrade cycle and no one would notice.
Nintendo was here before Playstation and they'll be here when Playstation is gone. Besides I said ruin, not kill.
AI crisis will be extremely bad for Sony because the prices are gonna be so crazy people just buy Switch 2 instead and that creates a perfect opening for Nintendo making a powerful home console later which they will regardless if PS6 sells 10 million or 50 million.

And as I wrote above, people buy PlayStation for third party titles
the price (which is largely out of their control) is going to deter a lot of people.
I rest my case.
 
Back
Top