What's new
IconEra

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Forums  ›  Gaming
Playstation 
Insomniac is on thin ice. I say this with love.

Spider-Man 2 suffered from some very alarming issues, issues that now after Wolverine are a symptom of a larger problem.

Spider-Man 2 felt less polished than Spider-Man 1 did at launch, their push to tell two character stories at the same time created a tonal clash, there was no need to give Mary Jane missions since Miles was already a second character, and the last act of the game was a mess. There’s one thing that really should worry fans and that is who is the taste maker at Insomniac? Because that final Miles suit, the actress they picked for Jean Gray, Logan himself, and the overall art direction of the game was not exactly great. The game is also extremely linear and simple, too simple. Basically turning the brain off for the gameplay and the story.

They really really should look into Insomniac and put people in charge that are inspired by and inspiring others to do something with impact.
Spiderman 2 has issues because Sony demanded a deadline from them as well. Wolverine obviously needed a delay but I doubt Sony was willing to give them one and so that's why everything was probably scaled back and the game lacking a certain polish in some areas.

Sony either needs to allow Insomniac to staff up more or they are gonna have to give them the Naughty Dog treatment and allow them enough time to fully realIize their visions going forward.
 
What game doesn't, these days?

It hit like wildfire for Wolverine in particular because the game didn't live up to Insomniacs reputation. Every game gets grifted now. There is a multi million dollar industry on grifting video games. And theirs no stopping it really, even games that are good, get great reviews, get grifted if they don't sell 5 million copies immediately. Ridiculous, I know.

007 and Pragmata didn’t get any hate
 
Steve Harvey Judge GIF by ABC Network


This shows Ampere and Alinea were pretty much on the money.

Where you at @James Sawyer Ford and @Yurinka?

6m sales lmao, it's not even half of that.
In the context of a quarterly report whose period ended in September Lin Tao said exactly in the presentation: "Regarding first-party titles, cumulative sales of Marvel's Wolverine -released in September- exceeeded 2.4M units contributing to the improved results of the entire segment of the quarter."

Meaning, those "exceeded 2.4M" instead of refering to sales until now could include only its September (first couple weeks) sales, the quarterly period covered in the earnings report they are announcing in this presentation, despite in other document appears listed 2.4 as of today/yesterday (depending on timezone), 50 days after release (it could be refering to the report, instead of the sales period covered). On top of that, maybe that number isn't counting the bundled copies.

It's also worth mentioning that they sold 8.2M first party games this quarter, vs 6.3M the previous Q2 or 6.0M in Q1 of the current FY. So 2.4M of that 8.2M being from Wolverine could fit. There's the doubling YoY the Q2 sales of the Spider-Man titles, but at this point being old and being all three in PS+ it would be doubling a pretty low number.

A couple other possible causes of the exceptionally big delta could be the game having an exceptionally high percentage of game sales that were digital, or an exceptionally high percent of buyers of the digital version who made a review (maybe to support the game and show disagreement with the gaming media reviews some sort of 'reverse review bombing').


According to the Insomniac leak this game had a development budget of $305m, safe to say 2.4m sales at launch isn't what they're aiming for. Whether it's a commercial failure will depend on whether and how much the game continues to sell. According to the leak the game would need to sell at least 5m copies to break even, and it needs to sell 6m copies or Marvel is legally able to break up their licensing deal for X-Men (although that number also included PC sales, which aren't happening anymore so maybe they've negotiated this number down much like Xbox negotiated Indiana Jones from a multiplatform game back to an exclusive).
The "exceeded 2.4M mark" can be good or bad depending if it refers to the first week, first couple weeks, the first 50 days. And well, specially how it does perform in the long term.

The break even isn't calculated dividing the budget by its full price in USA. There are taxes, countries where it's sold cheaper and part of the copies sold to achieve the break even quite often are discounted. In this case being a licensed game there's also a part that goes to the licensor. So maybe this case they need to sell like 8M copies for the break even.

The deadline of selling at least 6M copies (counting PS5+PC) starting to count on the PS5 release stated that both Sony and Marvel could (not that will) drop the sequels without penalty. And well, we'll have to see if they will release the PC port or not.
 
Last edited:
Yes because it probably brought in more console sales and some new users to the ecosystem.
Its not all about game sales.
Its no Spiderman but it will probably generate more interested again after Avengers

Good thing to note is that average spend per console on software is over $1000 over the entire lifecycle

So an extra 70k units sold in the month of September due to Wolverine (above baseline) could lead to 70 million in extra revenue

Sounds like Sony is backing off of the hyper focus on individual unit sales of its first party games which makes sense in the broader goal of them being there to support the platform.

I don’t really get the idea that each game has to be profitable on its own to be a success. That kind of thinking led to PC ports. Cutting off your nose to spite your face.

Sony should use a multifaceted KPI to judge success. Did it gain critical acclaim? Did it increase brand awareness and sell more PlayStations? Was it an IP that may be a stepping stone to sequel growth? Did it contribute to PS plus subs? Etc etc

As long as the business overall is healthy who cares if Saros or Wolverine lost a bit of money on unit sales alone

Obviously you can’t be reckless and have massive money pit bombs like Concord but not earning back full budget by itself shouldn’t be considered a failure as long as there are redeeming qualities to their release
 
Good thing to note is that average spend per console on software is over $1000 over the entire lifecycle

So an extra 70k units sold in the month of September due to Wolverine (above baseline) could lead to 70 million in extra revenue

Sounds like Sony is backing off of the hyper focus on individual unit sales of its first party games which makes sense in the broader goal of them being there to support the platform.

I don’t really get the idea that each game has to be profitable on its own to be a success. That kind of thinking led to PC ports. Cutting off your nose to spite your face.

Sony should use a multifaceted KPI to judge success. Did it gain critical acclaim? Did it increase brand awareness and sell more PlayStations? Was it an IP that may be a stepping stone to sequel growth? Did it contribute to PS plus subs? Etc etc

As long as the business overall is healthy who cares if Saros or Wolverine lost a bit of money on unit sales alone

Obviously you can’t be reckless and have massive money pit bombs like Concord but not earning back full budget by itself shouldn’t be considered a failure as long as there are redeeming qualities to their release

"Wolverine success is the friends we made during the jorney" AHH REPLY, just let it go man, mid game and mid sales, no need to put that much effort
 
Sony doesn’t seem concerned at all it seems.


Yep. if sony didn't like the sales numbers, they wouldn't have announced it like (like saros, tokon and marathon)

CFO Lin Tao: Strong performance attributed to "symbiotic combination" between platforms like PSN and Crunchyroll + "hit content driven by our strong IP and creative talent, such as Spider-Man, Wolverine and Ella Langley"

People seem to be completely making up sony's expectations about the game.
 
Last edited:
Wolverine flopped bc it didnt stand out as an action game and there was a lot of really SILLY handholding

there is NOTHING about woke making the game fail, in fact, Spider-Man 2 was WOKE ASF and sold like hotcakes
 
There’s no other way to spin it: that is simply abysmal. Wolverine is probably top 5 and maybe even top 3 most popular/recognized superhero in the world and for a hero with that insane level of name/brand recognition 2.4m copies in two months is dire. Spider-Man PS4 did that in like its first 2 days lol.
 
I've felt that Doctor Strange would have been up Insomniac's alley more given the portal tech and shifting levels that is in Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart. Mixed in the platforming and the balls to the wall cosmic level designs to make a Doctor Strange game.
 
As long as the business overall is healthy who cares if Saros or Wolverine lost a bit of money on unit sales alone

Obviously you can’t be reckless and have massive money pit bombs like Concord but not earning back full budget by itself shouldn’t be considered a failure as long as there are redeeming qualities to their release

Of course they have to keep money in check, but yeah. The amount of profit they make, they should be focusing on making more and more quality games, both big and small to expand their library.
Some games will lose some money, but if fans like it, and it reviews well, thats more important imo, especially the next gen and a half going forward. They have enoug money to not worry this next gen.

PS1,2,3 era was filled with beloved games that didnt always sell well. But looking at games that are coming back like Onimusha, nothing is off the table to succeed again.

Also for 3rd party exclusives. Invest in them again.

Why paying console exclusives for like FF7, Persona, Miyazaaki, and yes even Kojima is always better to have then not have. Strengthens the library
They need double there output at least, yes quality developers are hard to find, but there are 3rd party studios who do amazing
 
Back
Top