What's new
IconEra

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Forums  ›  Gaming
Nintendo 
This game is everything why I hate remakes and why I hate FF7 Retrilogy

Ruining absolute art for new decisions that make absolutely no sense
 
Maybe a hot take: Wind Waker doesn't need a remake.
While I kind of agree it seems Ocarina was partly made so Nintendo could use it as a training wheels exercise for younger developers and to see how they approach making video games, Wind Waker remake can be made with the same excuse.
 
Maybe a hot take: Wind Waker doesn't need a remake.
This, the cartoon style made the visual timeless, a 4k60fps remaster will be as good as any remake.

Ocarina of Time graphics were old and simple enough to be reimagined, just like FF7. Cant say the same with the iconic style of WW, you cant change that.
 
As a FF7 fan (a person who got into FF and PlayStation because of 7), I'm happy Square did what they did and didn't just make a 1:1 remake. I never played the original OOT so I don't have any frame of reference and this game will be fresh for me, but the way Square-Enix did FF7 Remake is peak for me and I wouldn't have wanted it any other way.

Getting out of Midgar on the bike chase, suddenly being confronted with a crazy Sephiroth boss fight that wasn't there before - getting teleported to some other dimension for a 1v1 where the camera shots precisely line up with the camera shots before Cloud Omnislashes his ass at the end of the OG game, only for Sephiroth to fully parry all that shit this time around was peak and mind blowing. And then you get an ending reel where somehow Zack survives his execution at the end of Crisis Core? I get chills just typing it out lol.

And that's not even talking about how they revolutionized the combat and made an all-timer battle system that should be the template for FF games moving forward.
I think there is two faces of what they reimagined. I also like the additions to the main moments like the ones you described, and to me the remake trilogy combat is the ultimate FF experience. But sometimes I think they do too much, making the visit to smaller villages too important, with new NPCs, additional storylines and stuff. It might be crazy, that I'm complaining that my steak is too juicy, that there is too much content and details LOL, but a lot of the brand new characters such as Chadley, some village leaders, like Cissnei in Gongaga (which I feel a bit conflicted bc I like her from Crisis Core but the story kept dragging when it was way faster in the OG...)

I guess that to me the pacing is the problem sometimes, in older games due to graphics or whatever you could excuse brief interactions and silly cutscenes, but this would look weird with the super realistic models of FF7 now. I have a weird position between imersion and arcade, so to me the old pacing is usually better. So knowing that this game won't feature that many new characters, chapters and so on basically sells me that I'll like it the same way.

Idk if it made any sense

america guy GIF
 
This game makes me understand Wind Waker a lot more. It shares a lot of its DNA with Ocarina 64, but with a very deliberate attempt at stylizing its visuals.

If remakes were the norm back then I believe they just would’ve remade OoT. A lot of 64 games are fantastic but suffer under the weight of Nintendo’s decision to stick with cartridges. So a lot of their IP during that gen are just straight up ugly looking. I think that’s why their most “remake culture” remakes in their company’s history are Star Fox and Ocarina.
 
This game is everything why I hate remakes and why I hate FF7 Retrilogy

Ruining absolute art for new decisions that make absolutely no sense

The old versions of these games are still readily available. How can they ruin anything with these remakes? This is not a case of George Lucas going in and messing with Star Wars films after they were released and having those changes included on every future print of the movie.

I think there is two faces of what they reimagined. I also like the additions to the main moments like the ones you described, and to me the remake trilogy combat is the ultimate FF experience. But sometimes I think they do too much, making the visit to smaller villages too important, with new NPCs, additional storylines and stuff. It might be crazy, that I'm complaining that my steak is too juicy, that there is too much content and details LOL, but a lot of the brand new characters such as Chadley, some village leaders, like Cissnei in Gongaga (which I feel a bit conflicted bc I like her from Crisis Core but the story kept dragging when it was way faster in the OG...)

I guess that to me the pacing is the problem sometimes, in older games due to graphics or whatever you could excuse brief interactions and silly cutscenes, but this would look weird with the super realistic models of FF7 now. I have a weird position between imersion and arcade, so to me the old pacing is usually better. So knowing that this game won't feature that many new characters, chapters and so on basically sells me that I'll like it the same way.

Idk if it made any sense

america guy GIF

I get your point, it does feel like they bloat the game and pad it out with a lot of stuff that wasn't there before. The game is going from like a 35h-long game to a game that's already clocking in around 100-120h after 2 parts. And in Rebirth, which covers a relatively small part of the story, the fact that it's stretched out so much can make it feel like the pacing is off. And not all of it is good, Chadley is a bad addition but shit like Queen's Blood is great. The reimagination of some stuff from the OG also didn't land perfectly (Barrett scenes with Dyne) but overall I think they've nailed a lot of things. I'm still happy it's not a 1:1 remake. So much could've went wrong by expanding the game this much and splitting it into 3 full-fledged games, but they've nailed way more things than they missed and it makes the project much more exciting and interesting. FF7 Remake basically restored my faith in Square-Enix after they lost me with FF12 onwards.



Viewing a 1998 game through the lens of 2013 is pretty stupid, but celebrating the shutdown of an outlet because of a single 13-year-old article that rustles your jimmies is even more retarded. None of what the article says is factually incorrect (the game, just like many media products of the time, does include gender stereotypes), but it just doesn't make sense to view a product of its time through that lens decades later. It's like those people who are now trying to criticize Friends almost 30 years after it aired. Like yeah, it doesn't pass the progressiveness test in today's age anymore but back then it was pretty progressive. Same goes for FF7 and how they portrayed Barrett. Yeah it's a blaxploitation stereotype character that wouldn't be made in today's day and age but back then just having a Black person as a beloved JRPG party member was already a big W.
 
How is your brain not just mush watching content like this? Do you even have a brain?
Cos youre one of those looney tones deranged wokies thats why

Leaked email shows how bioware unethical employment with these company through linkedin
 
Yes your one of those woke commies from resetera
You're a great example of why Americans are in desperate need of a third space. You probably only see real life people in a chipotle line and that's it. You don't even know how to respect someone who has a different lifestyle than you.

Your entire perspective of people is based off of bots and alt right algorithm. Which, probably to your surprise, not indicative of actual real life society at all. You're in a bubble where everyone is looney, except for you.
 
You're a great example of why Americans are in desperate need of a third space. You probably only see real life people in a chipotle line and that's it. You don't even know how to respect someone who has a different lifestyle than you.

Your entire perspective of people is based off of bots and alt right algorithm. Which, probably to your surprise, not indicative of actual real life society at all. You're in a bubble where everyone is looney, except for you.
Whatever

Your fucked up woke game concord, veilguard, gears e day failed

People are lining up for Zelda

Have a nice day
 
Whatever

Your fucked up woke game concord, veilguard, gears e day failed

People are lining up for Zelda

Have a nice day
No matter how much you rage about "woke" the end result will always be the same. You die a virgin.
 
Is that what you truly believe?
Oh I know for certain you're a recluse. you make that very clear in your posts that you're an insufferable (likely obese) dweeb.

The only thing you know how to contribute to the discussion of games is culture war. Fear mongering about women. Fear mongering about Trans. Just exposing yourself as a straight up lame. You can hide behind your chud trophies like Concord and Veilgaurd.. because at the end of the day that is 90% of this console generation to you. Laughing at games that flopped, how pathetic. I'll leave this console generation, with well over 100+ new experiences that I didn't let bots on the internet ruin for me.

You'll probably never interact with a trans person in your life, yet you post about them every single say like a complete psychopath. You're a pathetic excuse for a human being, and it's sad much of the internet has been hijacked by socially inept people such as yourself.
Online political radicalization can reshape someone's entire relationship with entertainment and popular culture for the worst, and you're a shining example.

Oh, and by the way, I don't like resetera, because many of them are exactly like you, just in the opposite direction. But equally as insufferable.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top