What's new
IconEra

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Forums  ›  Gaming
Discussion 
I mean, GTA numbers are bloated by the american and european market too, so is it impressive?
More impressive than cyberpunk because
1) Steam and GOG sell games at a lower regional price in China. And cyberpunk was additional discounted here via giftcodes before release. I pre-ordered it for $35 on GOG back in 2020.
2) GTA6 achieved this number with a much smaller installation base and much higher prices.
 
Are you just making stuff now. Like where do you even get this stuff from that PS fans review bombed OOT.
Its literally from the same source as the user above got the GTA being review bombed by Nintendo fans, ask him not me. Dunno why you decided to quote me instead lol
 
I think 94 meta and 8.9 user. I think 30fps when 60fps is doable will have its dent, especially that they're using RT and it's running on Xbox Series S. Also the steep price and how gutted the standard version should have another problem with "honest" reviewers which are the minority.
 
I think 94 meta and 8.9 user. I think 30fps when 60fps is doable will have its dent, especially that they're using RT and it's running on Xbox Series S. Also the steep price and how gutted the standard version should have another problem with "honest" reviewers which are the minority.

Reviewers are not going to dock points for 30 FPS. They haven't done so for other 30 FPS games in the past. They don't even do so for games with unstable framerates and wonky performance. If FromSoftware's games get a pass, so will GTA. I also don't think anyone is going to review this game on a Series S.

It's going to be the highest rated game of all time - purely based on hype and vibes.

Going to be extremely hard, it's going to have 100+ reviews and you only need a few contrarian opinions or outlets ragebaiting people with lower reviews to drive the review score down. To get the highest rated game of all time title it has to beat games from the 90s and early 2000s with only 20ish reviews from outlets who had no incentive to give a lower score than they thought the game deserved.
 
Reviewers are not going to dock points for 30 FPS. They haven't done so for other 30 FPS games in the past. They don't even do so for games with unstable framerates and wonky performance. If FromSoftware's games get a pass, so will GTA. I also don't think anyone is going to review this game on a Series S.



Going to be extremely hard, it's going to have 100+ reviews and you only need a few contrarian opinions or outlets ragebaiting people with lower reviews to drive the review score down. To get the highest rated game of all time title it has to beat games from the 90s and early 2000s with only 20ish reviews from outlets who had no incentive to give a lower score than they thought the game deserved.
If an average game like E-Day can score so highly, I have no doubt this will do exceptionally well. However I did double check the best rated games of all time. Zelda is 99. I suspect NOTHING will top that!

GTA6 will probably get 96-97.

The vast majority of review outlets are fucking trash anyway.

I find Skillup is my preferred channel for games.
 
If an average game like E-Day can score so highly, I have no doubt this will do exceptionally well. However I did double check the best rated games of all time. Zelda is 99. I suspect NOTHING will top that!

GTA6 will probably get 96-97.

The vast majority of review outlets are fucking trash anyway.

I find Skillup is my preferred channel for games.
It will get 9 from IGN, 10 is reserved for the best game of the decade, Mixtape.
 
If an average game like E-Day can score so highly, I have no doubt this will do exceptionally well. However I did double check the best rated games of all time. Zelda is 99. I suspect NOTHING will top that!

GTA6 will probably get 96-97.

The vast majority of review outlets are fucking trash anyway.

I find Skillup is my preferred channel for games.

It's a lot easier to get into the (high) 80s than it is to get near 100 as a near-10/10 experience. That being said, I think 95-97 is realistic. I can't imagine this game scoring below a 95. Their last two games got a 97 but a lot has changed since then. There hasn't been a 97 MC score game this generation. Although to be fair nothing this generation has been (objectively) better than RDR2 was in my opinion so that's kinda of realistic.

I was right like always


Lmao, you are already damage controlling. A guy who claims he was blacklisted (with no proof) supposedly because he didn't give GTA5 a high enough review score? I can't find any record of him having reviewed GTA5, GTA4 or any GTA game for that matter.

There's only a record of a Patrick O'Rourke on Opencritic who has reviewed 7 games, all from 2014-2015 (at least a year after GTA5 came out), for the Financial Post. An outlet that has a review for GTA5 that gives it an 8.5/10 but not by that writer.

Shacknews gave GTA5 an 8/10 and still got a review code for RDR2. You're just grasping at straws because you're already malding this game is going to beat OOT's MC score and take the GOTY award. The same shit you did last year with E33 and DK Bananza.
 
I can't find any record of him having reviewed GTA5, GTA4 or any GTA game for that matter.
He linked his own review. I read it. It probably got banned because he says "GTA 5 isn't a bad game" which is really just code hey the game actually is bad every single time.
 
He linked his own review. I read it. It probably got banned because he says "GTA 5 isn't a bad game" which is really just code hey the game actually is bad every single time.

I just checked it and maybe I'm comparing it to modern reviews but it's a poorly-written review with no coherence to it at all, he's just randomly jumping all over the place and complaining the game is not what he wanted it to be rather than critically examining what it tries to do.

Anyway, he's entitled to his opinion. The majority of reviewers disagreed. And arguing that because they allegedly blacklisted him 13 years ago (again, we have no proof for this) everyone is just going to shower this game in 9s and 10s because they're worried about maintaining access so they can review GTA7 in 2040 or whatever is just extreme cope. Shall I also bring up the Slate review for OOT so I can pretend it somehow means anything and/or represents widely-held views of the game?
 
Back
Top