What's new
IconEra

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Forums  ›  Gaming
Discussion 
Where are objective based shooters now?
Where's the games where you gotta find the red key to open the red door? See what I mean?

Goldeneye was a pioneer but to think it did it itself is lunacy
Who said it did anything by itself? Goldeneye was inspired by at least 3 different games which is why Goldeneye itself went on to inspire different games, including PC shooters, stealth genre etc.
"Rare named Sega's 1994 light gun shooter Virtua Cop, id Software's seminal 1993 first-person shooter Doom and the Nintendo 64 launch game Super Mario 64 as influences"

Thief
Taking inspiration from GoldenEye 007, the team added a difficulty system that changes mission objectives; Leonard said "it allowed the designers to create a very different experience at each level of difficulty, without changing the overall geometry and structure of a mission. This gave the game a high degree of replayability at a minimum development cost"

Half-Life
"GoldenEye 007 used state-based enemy AI and level setups that clearly showed NPC reactions to the player, inspiring Valve to refine how enemies and characters behaved in Half-Life"

So it's not console vs PC. Developers influence each other and steal each other's ideas all the time, this was especially true back when companies could develop games quickly. Like a game could come out last year and it changes the game that comes out the next year. Half-Life then went on and inspired a 1000 mods and games.
 
There's a difference between devs being inspired by it and saying it's the reason PlayStation and Xbox pursued console shooters lmao. The former didn't even do that until two generations later, after they really started taking off on Xbox, not the N64. And it's not like Goldeneye didn't have its own inspirations.



First of all, Rare is not a Nintendo studio and they just had a partnership with Nintendo in the 90s before Microsoft bought them. Again, it's funny how you deflect Pokemon's middling quality and issues and say it's because it's not made by Nintendo, but now you wanna give Nintendo the credit for Goldeneye and by extension all modern console shooters.



What do you mean it doesn't have a d-pad? It does. It's just four separate buttons instead of a single piece. Just like on the Switch joy cons.

Yes, the original PS1 controller didn't have any sticks but I think acting like they only had to add them because of N64 doesn't make sense. It was because gaming was increasingly moving towards 3D and controlling those games with a d-pad made less sense. If all they had to do was copy Nintendo they could've just gone for a single analog stick, it's not like they didn't do that later with the PSP. They deliberately chose two sticks instead, something that everyone including Nintendo then adopted later.

Also Sega put out a "3D controller" with a single analog stick like 2 weeks after the N64 released, before it would've been possible for the N64 controller to have proven anything about the need for an analog stick. Using sticks to control games had been done long before Nintendo did it with the N64, they were just the first to add a small stick to a regular controller pad.

Either way, even if you want to argue they copied the analog stick from Nintendo, it doesn't change the core argument. Which is that the design principles for controllers as PlayStation did them back in 1997 became the industry standard. None of Nintendo's designs from the N64 onwards were adopted by other platforms.
The D-pad is a pad, a single connected button with multiple sensors under it. The PS arrow buttons are functionally identical but are not a D-pad. You're right that Switch joy-cons don't have one either, solely so that they can be disconnected and act like SNES-style controllers on first party multiplayer games. The Pro controllers still have classic D-pads though. While there's probably 10 joy-xon pairs for every Pro you'll find a lot more Pro use among hardcore adult fans (of the type you'll find yourself arguing with here) because of how painfully small the joycon layout is. Don't believe me? Just google "hardcore adult Nintendo" and find out.
 
I still like that Megadrive D-pad better than most, myself.

Saturn for me. But I actually really like PS1-PS5 all too. Its a toss up between Saturn and Dual for me. Dreamcast looked the part, but it was a downgrade in D-pad and was missing 2 shoulder buttons, I love the look though.

I use to prefer saturn for 2d fighters, but last few years Ive preferred the PS controller, the older grip on the dpad.

I remember the days of trying combo’s on Tekken 2-5, or VF on the Saturn.
 
Saturn for me. But I actually really like PS1-PS5 all too. Its a toss up between Saturn and Dual for me. Dreamcast looked the part, but it was a downgrade in D-pad and was missing 2 shoulder buttons, I love the look though.

I use to prefer saturn for 2d fighters, but last few years Ive preferred the PS controller, the older grip on the dpad.

I remember the days of trying combo’s on Tekken 2-5, or VF on the Saturn.

I had that dodgy ass 1st edition Uk Saturn controllers. I cant remember exactly what it was but they just felt wrong to me somehow.
 
Sony’s d-pad’s were at their peak with the ps3 pad. PS5 one is a bit too meaty and stiff. It’s a bit different.

Actually ps3 pad was pretty decent for fighters. Sure the inputs are a bit more singular input style and you rely on command shortcuts a bit but I never liked the swivel style but I get why some like it.

Dual sense form factor and sticks are nice. Triggers and d-pad could be a bit more clicky and lighter. Don’t know how to describe it.
 
I had that dodgy ass 1st edition Uk Saturn controllers. I cant remember exactly what it was but they just felt wrong to me somehow.

Ah, I meant the Japanese one. Or model 2 in US/Europe. The first dpad really sucked. The 2nd one, was like a true sequel to Megadrive/ Genesis controller
 
Last edited:
Sony’s d-pad’s were at their peak with the ps3 pad. PS5 one is a bit too meaty and stiff. It’s a bit different.

Actually ps3 pad was pretty decent for fighters. Sure the inputs are a bit more singular input style and you rely on command shortcuts a bit but I never liked the swivel style but I get why some like it.

Dual sense form factor and sticks are nice. Triggers and d-pad could be a bit more clicky and lighter. Don’t know how to describe it.
Just to confirm, when you say "d pad" you're talking about the left stick, right?
 
Back
Top