I disagree with what you said. Sequels are supposed to feel like the prequels. That's the whole point of having an sequel.I actually share your opinion on this one.
From the sampling of PC ports Playstation released this generation, there are actually a lot of new IP and sequel pairings.
LoU2 feels a lot like LoU1, Ragnarok feels a lot like GoW. I'm not saying you need to push boundaries with every sequel, but Sony's followups often feel like they're playing it pretty safe.
It's one of the reasons I get burned out on Playstation Studios open worlds, because they can feel (though not to the same extent) as formuliac as a Ubisoft game.
The real criticism of all their games was the story. I largely felt the same way about the stories as well: disappointed.
With GOW Ragnarok, it felt like something big was supposed to happen after the first game, but then nothing really happened in the sequel. It felt like it was building up to something, but it ended up being nothing. To some degree, we ended up with the same conflict between Atreus and Kratos as in the first game.
I didn't like Spider-Man's story either. Horizon's story also felt lackluster. ITs the story. People didn't click with it. I blame feminism ( or atleast starting to). Just too many women writers. It feels like their writing conflict with characters and to extent the whole game as well.
All of the games added new things gameplay-wise in their sequels. However, all of the sequels played it safe story wise. I can't quite explain it, but they just didn't click with me the way their prequels did. I stopped buying modern triple AAA games after Spiderman 2.


