That's not my point.
Name a game that's not a Sony game that's better than TLOU.
For me? In the last decade? Destiny, Death Stranding and Gran Turismo Sport, Gran Turismo 7 for example.
Older generations... Super Mario 64, Zelda: Ocarine of Time, StarFox 64, Final Fantasy VI, Gran Turismo 5, Metal Gear Solid, Metal Gear Solid 4, Halo: Reach, Halo 3, etc.
TLOU is not in my TOP30... it is in TOP30 I believe.
You point about Elden Ring continue not making any sense.
Because the attitude "so which Sony game will be GOTY this year" fit Elden Ring perfectly and it is not from Sony fans.
PC / Xbox fans set Elden Ring as GOTY in March... and when Sony fans says there more games releasing like GoW:R they get made about it... do you know how crazy that is?
To be fair... if GoW:R is just a bit better than GoW (2018) it will be my GOTY over GT7.
It just that GoW (2018) is just so great.
In other side Elden Ring is not imo the best From software work... Sekiro probably is followed by Bloodborne and Demon's Souls (yeap most Xbox/PC fans will say it is Dark Souls but Dark Souls lose a lot of the atmosphere and character charisma that made what Demon's Souls is)... and to let here Demon's Souls PS5 port is just like Dark Souls lose a lot of what made Demon's Souls great... the original is superior to the new game.