Is Several Graphical Modes Something That Harm More Than Help Console Users?

rofif

...owns a 3080...why?
24 Jun 2022
2,075
2,595
A resolution mode doesn't mean the graphics go to shit, a few things are dialed back but the mode focuses on the highest IQ possible.

You're the one making no sense, tons of games have these very modes..
it's still a trade off.
i don't want trade offs on console
 

Alabtrosmyster

Veteran
26 Jun 2022
3,399
2,944
I dont want trade offs on console.
I don’t want to feel like this one mode is for suckers and other is for players
Well, I don't care how you feel about it.

There is a tradeoff, it does not matter if you get decide what you like or someone else (at the studio, they will probably whatever is more popular in that case).

So having two or three profiles makes sense, consider the default whatever the creators intended.

Also, on PS5 you get to choose in advance if you prefer "performance" or "quality".
 

rofif

...owns a 3080...why?
24 Jun 2022
2,075
2,595
Well, I don't care how you feel about it.

There is a tradeoff, it does not matter if you get decide what you like or someone else (at the studio, they will probably whatever is more popular in that case).

So having two or three profiles makes sense, consider the default whatever the creators intended.

Also, on PS5 you get to choose in advance if you prefer "performance" or "quality".
When I played a game on ps4... let's say uncharted 4.
I just played it. I had no comparison to how much better it can look or how much better it can run.
Now you have this comparison and you know that no matter which of three modes you pick, you will miss on some experience of other two modes.
It's psychology. You don't loose what you don't see....

And as for ps5 games, the choice is different game per game. I might l prefer quality modes but it very much depends on the game and DF analysis
 

DynamiteCop

Banned
2 Jul 2022
1,107
1,024
it's still a trade off.
i don't want trade offs on console

When I played a game on ps4... let's say uncharted 4.
I just played it. I had no comparison to how much better it can look or how much better it can run.
Now you have this comparison and you know that no matter which of three modes you pick, you will miss on some experience of other two modes.
It's psychology. You don't loose what you don't see....

And as for ps5 games, the choice is different game per game. I might l prefer quality modes but it very much depends on the game and DF analysis


This is hilarious coming from the guy who hates on PC left and right yet fails to realize PC is best suited for him because it's the only platform capable of no trade offs.

Lmao
 

Gh0stnTheBashShell

Active member
30 Jun 2022
185
165


This is hilarious coming from the guy who hates on PC left and right yet fails to realize PC is best suited for him because it's the only platform capable of no trade offs.

Lmao

Rofif is one confusing ass dude IMO.

Honestly how do you buy a 3080, complain about it endlessly and say it's not worth it. Then he says before he plays any game he goes to the PC gaming wiki... Like wut? Bro I game on Linux and never used the wiki 🤣
 

rofif

...owns a 3080...why?
24 Jun 2022
2,075
2,595


This is hilarious coming from the guy who hates on PC left and right yet fails to realize PC is best suited for him because it's the only platform capable of no trade offs.

Lmao

That’s why I have a pc.
What Baines you think I don’t realise or use that :p

It’s not about not having trade offs. There will always be some.
It’s about being exposed to it
 

Alabtrosmyster

Veteran
26 Jun 2022
3,399
2,944
That’s why I have a pc.
What Baines you think I don’t realise or use that :p

It’s not about not having trade offs. There will always be some.
It’s about being exposed to it
I agree, but I also believe that the developers tend to choose "graphics" over responsiveness too often... So having a performance mode, alongside the bullshot mode, makes sense for those who want it.
 

rofif

...owns a 3080...why?
24 Jun 2022
2,075
2,595
I agree, but I also believe that the developers tend to choose "graphics" over responsiveness too often... So having a performance mode, alongside the bullshot mode, makes sense for those who want it.
nobody want's just bullshot mode that is the thing.
I want to play a good looking game.
Not to look at good looking game and then play a game that is not looking like that.
All they have to do is take care and d some proper optimalization and not botch 30fps lock like demons souls
 

Alabtrosmyster

Veteran
26 Jun 2022
3,399
2,944
All they have to do is take care and d some proper optimalization and not botch 30fps lock like demons souls
30fps is broken by default, these modes only ever existed in games that the consoles could not run at full refresh (that was 60 until recently).

Current consoles are good enough to give us good looking games that run at normal speed.
 
  • they're_right_you_know
Reactions: Deleted member 51

rofif

...owns a 3080...why?
24 Jun 2022
2,075
2,595
30fps is broken by default, these modes only ever existed in games that the consoles could not run at full refresh (that was 60 until recently).

Current consoles are good enough to give us good looking games that run at normal speed.
It's not true.
30fps modes are just 16ms slower than 60fps mode.
Not 75ms slower like DF demonstrated. Bad vsynced 30fps can be terrible laggy and hard to play. But good 30fps with good motion blur, can be perfectly fine with a controller. Nothing broken about it.

check out the vid. It's interesting and shows how 30fps implementation can differ.
And if you say "f this, I don't care fr 30fps"... then be aware that this exact issue is just as well lowering input lag in 60fps games. These probably also could be faster
 

Alabtrosmyster

Veteran
26 Jun 2022
3,399
2,944
It's not true.
30fps modes are just 16ms slower than 60fps mode.
Not 75ms slower like DF demonstrated. Bad vsynced 30fps can be terrible laggy and hard to play. But good 30fps with good motion blur, can be perfectly fine with a controller. Nothing broken about it.

check out the vid. It's interesting and shows how 30fps implementation can differ.
And if you say "f this, I don't care fr 30fps"... then be aware that this exact issue is just as well lowering input lag in 60fps games. These probably also could be faster
no sh*t Johnny !

I mean, it feels broken, no matter how "well implemented" it may be.

I'll play the 30fps version if there is nothing else, but it still feels like a slideshow, you can somehow get used to it (the og TLoU often dropped in the mid 20s, like many games of this generation, we played them anyway).
 
  • brain
Reactions: Deleted member 51
D

Deleted member 13

Guest
I don't think this is harmful to consoles. In fact, they should have more modes like a PC does. That's how I use the Steam Deck anyway. I'm allowed to select what I want to see and/or what I want the game to run at performance-wise.
 
  • brain
Reactions: Deleted member 51

rofif

...owns a 3080...why?
24 Jun 2022
2,075
2,595
So tlou1 remake is example of weird modes since if you have 120hz tv, fidelity mode will default to terrible 40fps mode which is rarely 40….

The game is much sharper in fidelity mode on my c1 so for sure I am playing that. But I have a hard time deciding 30 vs 40fps modes. I am leaning towards 30fps mode so console 120hz set to off and vrr also off since it’s not doing anything at 30 right?
I tested 40fps mode with vrr and you can see gamma changing on oled. It’s unstable

And I even have hard time deciding if I like film grain here or not :p
 

Shmunter

Veteran
22 Jul 2022
3,048
3,533
So tlou1 remake is example of weird modes since if you have 120hz tv, fidelity mode will default to terrible 40fps mode which is rarely 40….

The game is much sharper in fidelity mode on my c1 so for sure I am playing that. But I have a hard time deciding 30 vs 40fps modes. I am leaning towards 30fps mode so console 120hz set to off and vrr also off since it’s not doing anything at 30 right?
I tested 40fps mode with vrr and you can see gamma changing on oled. It’s unstable

And I even have hard time deciding if I like film grain here or not :p
The VRR will work in the 30fps mode in this game as they are doing the frame doubling with anything below 60. Low frame rate compensation or whatever it’s called.

The changing gamma, well that’s a whole other story with VRR. Put 10 sets side by side, get 10 different behaviours.
 

rofif

...owns a 3080...why?
24 Jun 2022
2,075
2,595
The VRR will work in the 30fps mode in this game as they are doing the frame doubling with anything below 60. Low frame rate compensation or whatever it’s called.

The changing gamma, well that’s a whole other story with VRR. Put 10 sets side by side, get 10 different behaviours.
but to get 4k30, you need to switch to 60hz. I don't think I've ever seen lfc for 60hz.
Anyway... seems like trouble. I've disable 120hz output and disabled vrr. Simple 4k30 is ok.
But if LFC is working with 4k30, then this should produce quite a lot lower input lag
 
  • thinking_hard
Reactions: Deleted member 13