According to Windows Central, Arc Raiders plays much better than Marathon:
In contrast, Marathon has been criticized for lacking originality and presenting a more generic look, making it harder to stand out in the extraction shooter genre.
- Accessibility and Visual Style: ARC Raiders offers a more accessible experience with a retro 80s sci-fi aesthetic, contrasting with Marathon's darker, more generic style.
- Varied Gameplay: It blends PvE (fighting AI-controlled ARC machines) and PvP combat, encouraging dynamic strategies and unpredictable encounters.
- Fluid Movement: The game's movement system is praised for being smooth and fun, allowing sprinting, sliding, and using ziplines, which adds excitement to exploration.
- Creative Weapons: While some weapons lack impact, their unique variety and design make combat feel fresh and distinct.
- Story and Setting: Set in a post-apocalyptic future, players explore Earth's surface for resources while facing robotic threats and rival scavengers, creating an engaging narrative backdrop. Marathon nearly has no backstory