Their reviews didn't appear several hours after Xbox+Kojima announced the Physint thing, some time after the "PS will stop accepting new physical games in the future" announcement, etc. So there wasn't the recent "let's punish Sony / anti-PS" tax back then.
How many reviews did they have from major outlets giving it a 5 or 6 with excuses like saying it was too linear, short and repetitive? None.
What are you talking about man? These reviews were written and recorded long before the Physint news. Insinuating they docked points over meta drama on a game made by a developer some of them are personally friends with is insanity. Greg Miller gave the game a 5.5 and he’s literally bodyscanned and an Easter Egg in Spider-Man 2.
And why the fuck would they punish Wolverine over the Physint news but not Tokon over the physical disc drama news, which was an infinitely bigger story?
The game just isn’t all that, why are you guys so utterly in denial?
Yes, and OpenCritic included way less reviews than MC, particularly ones scoring above that 77/79 (like Screenhub, ElDesmarque Gamespew...). MC has more reviews, but also misses reviews listed at OC, particularly with scores above that 77/79.
We need a reviews aggregator that tracks and adds all the reviews automatically instead of manually and offers both a median of the scores and a weighted score that instead of considering the personal preference of the people who runs the reviews aggregator it consider how previously that reviewer and outlet scored higher or lower vs the median that developer, publisher, game genre and (in case of exclusives, even if temporal or console exclusives) platform.
I'm busy with many projects (including one that tracks the rankings and user reviews from the game stores), but may implement it some day.
Oh no the aggregate sites didn’t include the reviews from a bunch of fluff piece no name outlets. Which they probably don’t do on a ton of games for whatever the reason was to not include them in the aggregate for this one (probably something as simple as them not having applied to be included or their application having been rejected long before Wolverine came out). It’s not something targeted towards Wolverine.
And no we shouldn’t have aggregate sites scrape the internet for anything resembling a review and then including it. That will just result in grifters and fanboys making fake review sites with the entire purpose of padding scores or review bombing. The current system of outlets having to apply to be included is fine and how it should be. And adjusting review score weighting based on how much below or above they score above the median across all games is an insane idea. What if an outlet only reviewed 9/10 games so far but gave them 10/10s, should that mean that when they then give an 8/10 to a game the industry also is settling on 80 for that their score will instead be “weighted” down to 7/10 because they’re always 10 points above the median?
There’s nothing wrong with the way the system works. If you want PlayStation games to get higher scores they should just make better games. That seems to work fine for everyone else.
Suggesting the way aggregate scores should be changed just so a mediocre PlayStation game can be lifted from a high 70s to a low 80s game is crazy work.
Easy Allies has some good impressions.
Basically says it's an awesome PS3 style game - linear, with very awesome combat that doesn't get old and keeps progressing, and AAA production values and set pieces. They also mention that the combat has tons of variety and the people that just spam the same two moves can do that, but that you really should engage with everything it has to offer. They say if you like those kinds of games, like PS3 Uncharted of GoW, you will really enjoy this.
THEY ALSO rated it around an 8......and they said because they wanted more variety or scale to the game. They also said they judged it harsher because Spider-Man is that game with bigger scale and they put certain studios to a higher standard.
Again, fair enough. I think people are wildly overreacting to the reviews as if this is some kind of The Order. Days Gone may be a better comparison in the sense that that game got a lot of heat for doing familiar open world things in a familiar setting. To me it was excellent and one of the best PS exclusives despite only having like a 71 metacritic. I felt that game was also put on a higher standard for some reason because it was getting compared to other sony first party studios.
But yeah - clearly some studios do have different standards than others. This isn't shocking.
Lol, outlet is positive towards the game = good impressions.
Outlet is negative towards the game = they are ranking it unfairly and docking points over physical discs.
Days Gone was an ok open world game that was a buggy mess at launch, that’s why it scored low on release. And why the remaster has had slightly more favorable reviews.
Don’t you notice a pattern here? You think Days Gone and Wolverine are awesome. Meanwhile you’re shitting on stuff like Onimusha and 007 and preemptively shitting on stuff like Metroid Ravenous (a sequel to an 88 MC game). There’s no conspiracy or double standards. Your tastes are just completely misaligned with the average opinion on these games.