What's new
IconEra

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Forums  ›  Gaming
Playstation 
The PlayStation tax that journalist inflict is real.

Where was the PlayStation tax on Marvel Tokon? Or Saros?

Oh wait, it doesn't exist and this game seemingly just ain't all that.

I've said it before, PlayStation is turning into blue Xbox in real time and the remaining fans are turning into blue Xbots at the same rate. Defending mediocre games by making up conspiracy about a brand-based review score tax.

They didn’t even give Concord that.

Because "they" don't give scores. An individual reviewer working for or commissioned by IGN does. The person who reviewed Concord just personally liked it more.

hilarious-hey.gif

You don't give a 6 to a big first party sony title if your worried about maintaining a working relationship.

Not like that should be a concern anyway as sony barely has a pulse on publications or individuals shitting on them, unless its something serious like breaking NDA.

IGN doesn't have to worry about getting review codes regardless of the scores they give. Some of these small outlets do though. The only reason publishers send review codes to those is to pad the scores. This is why in this day and age games that are just below 8/10 are seen as bad/mid, due to how inflated review scores have gotten and how scared reviewers are to actually use the whole 10 point scale. For most outlets the scale begins at a 6, rather than 1.

Oli Mac liked it and thought the combat was better than Spiderman



The guy who loves AI slop thought the combat was better? That bodes well. Also it's not like Spider-Man was a master class in combat design. Spider-Man combat works because it's only a smaller portion of what you do in the game and the true standout feature is exploring and swinging through NYC as Spider-Man.

As the release window drew nearer my interest of the game faded and now seeing the scores and watching Skillup's review, this is looking to be a flop for Insomniac. Will not buy.

Yup, the more they showed of this game the more my interest waned. Something felt off but I did not expect review outlets to actually score the game accordingly because usually just the "wow factor" of Sony's production values causes them to let a lot of things slide that other games would get docked for.

I think it's a bit unfair on insomniac. They carried playstation on the PS5 era. And what else can you do with wolverine in a video game? It's not that versatile of a character. Probably platinum games would have handled this kind of game better.

Ithink they thought about who was the most popular hero besides spiderman and then what videogame can we make out of this character.

I agree Insomniac is unfairly getting dragged. One mid game doesn't undo all the other stuff they put out in the last decade. That being said though, I'm pretty sure they chose Wolverine and weren't forced into it. And like you said, if you want to make Wolverine interesting you better go full Japanese-style character action which Insomniac obviously is incapable of (the combat in Spider-Man is also nothing special, even though it looks and feels good, but combat is only a smaller part of the greater picture with those games).

Yep

Everyone complaining that we don't have PS2 or PS3 era games anymore, and yet here one is and it's somehow getting marks against it for being that.

Yet somehow 007 First Light didn't get marks against it at all despite having the same flaws. It's just a worse playing Uncharted game with a Bond skin.

Omg man. Did PS2 and PS3 era M-rated games treat the player like a fucking braindead retard who needs to have GPS lines guiding them to OPTIONAL COLLECTIBLES?

When people say they want PS2 or PS3 era games they're not talking about the mid ones, they're talking about the best those generations had to offer. And they don't mean literally make a PS2-PS3 era game. They mean capture the feeling those games used to instill but with all the added benefits that modern game development allows for.

How the fuck can you sit there saying 007 is a worse Uncharted with a Bond skin? I mean first of all, the game scored lower than Uncharted games so this is clearly already accounted for in the review scores. But secondly, a large chunk of the game is actually based on Hitman gameplay which is a series created by the studio that made Bond.

The reason you are singling out 007 is because the travesty of Sony getting outdone in their own niche (cinematic third person action game) by a third party publisher this year. That must sting real bad for you.

This plays like a PS2/PS3 GoW game in so many respects, from the combat to the linear set piece design. I don't know what the fuck you're talking about at all, pal.

Just a tourist that doesn't have a clue about playstation. Go piss yourself off.

Man YOU are the tourist here if you think this looks like Greek God of War games. The Greek GoW games had sauce and player expression, this game doesn't even trust you to fucking find the way to the next objective by yourself IN A CORRIDOR.

This is a perfect example of what I mean when I say these PlayStation shills will retroactively shit on anything linked to PlayStation's history and culture to justify and defend the shit they are doing right now. Something an actual fan wouldn't do.

You're an idiotic shill and are just cherry picking idiotic shill reviews

The game has 80% of its reviews scoring higher than an 8

So looks like you're the outlier. Understandable, because you're an idiotic shill

And you are cherry picking high scores from no-name outlets because you refuse to believe the game is mid. Even though you were quick to jump in and shit on games revealed in the Nintendo Direct a day earlier based on one-to-two-minute-long trailers.

I mean the main complaints about the game are the fact it's too linear, and that it's got too much handholding.

That's pretty minor issues. 🤷‍♂️

Too much handholding is not a minor issue. This has been a constant and seemingly growing issue in Sony's AAA games. They always have to put a fucking backseat gaming companion into it that sometimes even spoils the puzzle solution before you even attempt it once. Or at the very least have the protag constantly talking to themselves to spoil puzzle solutions. I still remember in Horizon FW there's this one puzzle where you have to find a password to a door, and you can find some docs around it basically saying the password is a specific date. But the date is written out, so it's saying October instead of "10". And Aloy will literally yap out how the note refers to October and explain that it's "the 10th month of the year".

It just feels like they focus test the shit out of these games and design for the biggest retard in the room, and people are getting sick of it. We are living in a day and age where something like Elden Ring is a mainstream game with its cryptic and often nonsensical systems. They should trust their players more.

It's baffling that Astro Bot, a game designed to be accessible for children, trusts the player more than M-rated Wolverine.
I went to check the scores of the reviews included at MetaCritic:
100: 5 reviews
91-94: 2 reviews
90: 15 reviews
85-89: 18 reviews

81-84: 2 reviews
80: 32 reviews
75-79: 10 reviews
71-74: 1 review
70: 15 reviews
61-69: 1 review
60: 10 reviews
51-59: 0 reviews
50: 1 review (Giant Bomb)
not scored: 3 reviews

Seems that the low MC score is because MC weighted more few reviewers who gave it a 5 or 6 (Giant Bomb, IGN, Eurogamer, VGC, GameRadar and others).

The game is at a 79 on OpenCritic, which doesn't have weighted reviews.

Game sort of looks like if you took Uncharted and replaced its gunplay with lukewarm melee combat. I think making this a (relatively speaking) realistic and cinematic game was a complete misfire. It would be much easier to make Wolverine work as a flashy and over the top "character action game" like DMC or Ninja Gaiden. Probably should have been handed to a different studio as well, as that's not Insomniac's expertise.

Literally what I thought when they re-revealed the game in the State of Play. Uncharted with melee combat is the feeling I got from that, which would've been fine. But it seems like it's more like Uncharted with melee combat that doesn't have enough depth for the game's runtime that also treats the player like a total baby who needs to be handheld to an extreme degree.

A mid sony game is still much better than most xbox games :LOL:

But it's still a mid game. It being better than most Xbox games says more about Xbox than this game.

Let's be real, Wolverine is gonna hold up much better than rise, it's gameplay has way more going on, and a lot of people are obsessed with Xmen. But like rise, there's a good chance these lower reviewers tempers expectations and most people will just end up saying "hey it's actually pretty good".

There's also a good chance of people coming out and going "wow, they were right, this is really egregious levels of handholding and the combat is not nearly good enough to balance it out or make the game fun across its entire runtime".
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ico
IGN doesn't have to worry about getting review codes regardless of the scores they give. Some of these small outlets do though. The only reason publishers send review codes to those is to pad the scores. This is why in this day and age games that are just below 8/10 are seen as bad/mid, due to how inflated review scores have gotten and how scared reviewers are to actually use the whole 10 point scale. For most outlets the scale begins at a 6, rather than 1.

He was specifically talking about those like ign that have higher weighing. I'm sure smaller outlets do give favourable reviews, but that's the case with any game and I haven't seen widespread issues of Sony banning reviewers for just giving low scores.
 
He was specifically talking about those like ign that have higher weighing. I'm sure smaller outlets do give favourable reviews, but that's the case with any game and I haven't seen widespread issues of Sony banning reviewers for just giving low scores.

It's not so much Sony or anyone else actively blacklisting smaller outlets for bad reviews, it's that the people who are running those places are probably already barely making ends meet so they do not want to anger publishers who give them codes and therefore traffic by giving them harsh scores.

Either way Opencritic doesn't have weighted reviews and Wolverine is below 80 there too. The game just doesn't seem to be all that good, which can happen. No one has a flawless track record.
 
It's not so much Sony or anyone else actively blacklisting smaller outlets for bad reviews, it's that the people who are running those places are probably already barely making ends meet so they do not want to anger publishers who give them codes and therefore traffic by giving them harsh scores.

Either way Opencritic doesn't have weighted reviews and Wolverine is below 80 there too. The game just doesn't seem to be all that good, which can happen. No one has a flawless track record.
Of course one of the biggest wolverine haters is in here antagonizing people
 
Of course one of the biggest wolverine haters is in here antagonizing people

Biggest Wolverine hater? Wtf are you crying about you baby? I had the game preordered, even though the game was looking worse each time they showed more of it, just because Insomniac was on a good run. The game is just mid and a miss by most accounts. Which has seemingly turned into a personal 9/11 for losers like @James Sawyer Ford who think everything made Sony is awesome and everything made by others is dogshit.

You guys are just mad because only a few weeks ago you were mocking me for daring to suggest Sony's games aren't as good as you guys like to believe they are (so good that people can't leave the platform behind) and now we have the living example of their flagship 2026 game not even breaking into the top 150 for 2026 on Opencritic and top 140 for 2026 on Metacritic.

I mean, it's not like this is an outlier opinion dude. Jorraptor is a guy that loves the traditional PS3 era action games we used to get and he loved the combat.



Man you are behaving so pathetic over these reviews lmao. You are literally looking for outlier opinions on the game to cope with the fact that it couldn't even break 80 on aggregate review sites, including the ones that don't do weighted reviews. This clip doesn't say that the combat is better than Spider-Man's, just that it's the highlight of the game. Which it better fucking be because no one is buying a Wolverine game for puzzles or platforming.

Meanwhile you are shitting on all the games Capcom released this year, shit on 007, shit on games Nintendo revealed. Don't dish out that kind of commentary if you can't take the hits in return, you fragile pussy.
 
Biggest Wolverine hater? Wtf are you crying about you baby? I had the game preordered, even though the game was looking worse each time they showed more of it, just because Insomniac was on a good run. The game is just mid and a miss by most accounts. Which has seemingly turned into a personal 9/11 for losers like @James Sawyer Ford who think everything made Sony is awesome and everything made by others is dogshit.

You guys are just mad because only a few weeks ago you were mocking me for daring to suggest Sony's games aren't as good as you guys like to believe they are (so good that people can't leave the platform behind) and now we have the living example of their flagship 2026 game not even breaking into the top 150 for 2026 on Opencritic and top 140 for 2026 on Metacritic.



Man you are behaving so pathetic over these reviews lmao. You are literally looking for outlier opinions on the game to cope with the fact that it couldn't even break 80 on aggregate review sites, including the ones that don't do weighted reviews. This clip doesn't say that the combat is better than Spider-Man's, just that it's the highlight of the game. Which it better fucking be because no one is buying a Wolverine game for puzzles or platforming.

Meanwhile you are shitting on all the games Capcom released this year, shit on 007, shit on games Nintendo revealed. Don't dish out that kind of commentary if you can't take the hits in return, you fragile pussy.
So you admit you are an avid hater!

Okay, that's all I needed to have confirmed
 
Biggest Wolverine hater? Wtf are you crying about you baby? I had the game preordered, even though the game was looking worse each time they showed more of it, just because Insomniac was on a good run. The game is just mid and a miss by most accounts. Which has seemingly turned into a personal 9/11 for losers like @James Sawyer Ford who think everything made Sony is awesome and everything made by others is dogshit.

You guys are just mad because only a few weeks ago you were mocking me for daring to suggest Sony's games aren't as good as you guys like to believe they are (so good that people can't leave the platform behind) and now we have the living example of their flagship 2026 game not even breaking into the top 150 for 2026 on Opencritic and top 140 for 2026 on Metacritic.



Man you are behaving so pathetic over these reviews lmao. You are literally looking for outlier opinions on the game to cope with the fact that it couldn't even break 80 on aggregate review sites, including the ones that don't do weighted reviews. This clip doesn't say that the combat is better than Spider-Man's, just that it's the highlight of the game. Which it better fucking be because no one is buying a Wolverine game for puzzles or platforming.

Meanwhile you are shitting on all the games Capcom released this year, shit on 007, shit on games Nintendo revealed. Don't dish out that kind of commentary if you can't take the hits in return, you fragile pussy.

You're pathetic.

I am not shitting on Capcom games this year or 007. I enjoyed them all (outside Onimusha of what I played).

I am just highlighting the double standard. Only Pragmata is arguably doing anything new, and even then it's just a twist on combat mechanics, the actual structure of the game is well trodden ground in an extremely linear structure just like 007 and just like RE9 for the most part outside of select areas.

How am I the one looking at outlier opinions? The vast majority of opinions score the game 8/10 or higher. The vast majority is with MY OPINION, not yours that is cherry picking the 6/10s to fit your narrative,
 
I can't take skill up seriously after his nonsensical TLOU2 takes.

Reviews are borderline uselss in terms of knowing whether you're gonna like a game, but good to see what improvements need to be done.

In sony's case - their strengths are technical excellence, polish and accessibility.

But they need to really take a look at improving their game design. Asobi and ND excel at it, but the rest not so much.

It's imo; one of the reasons their GAAS games failed. The gaas audience doesn't care about storytelling, polish, or performance.
They will play the jankiest shit imaginable as long as the systems are unique/interesting.
Very good post
 
The easiest way to handle this is to say we have taken your feedback and will make adjustments and will do better next time but no mighty insoymniac has to cope and justify shitty game design. They could have just said we will improve it
 
Back
Top