What's new
IconEra

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Forums  ›  Gaming
Playstation 
BTW

John for DF really enjoyed Wolverine

The more I think about it, the more this game feels like a big budget realization of mid-tier PS2 brawlers.

It provides similar fun to something like OZ, Eve of Extinction, Berserk (DC and PS2 games), Castlevania Curse of Darkness, Bujingai, Blood Will Tell and perhaps even The Bouncer.

Heck, The Bouncer is a pretty good comparison. It's obviously way way more interactive and the levels are much larger but it has that flow - big combat -> cutscene.

I think people are being a bit too hard on the combat system, though. We've been spoiled by top tier combat but this is very much more in the brawler category - less depth and more focused reacting to things while knowing when to push. I would put it in a similar place as the PS2 era of God of War, really. Those games were also not especially complex compared to the DMCs of the world.

I think it is as good or better than X-Men Origins: Wolverine - very similar in many ways but a lot more polished and visceral.

This is a good post. I agree.

I specifically tend to not agree with Skill Up - like 50% of the time were polar opposite on things but I still love those videos. I only take issue this time due to omitting information which I don't think he did intentionally but just went with default settings without seeing what could be changed. Reviewing the default experience is fine.

Man, I don't know what to say, but I didn't even find normal to be 'easy'. Like, it's not a tough game, but you have to engage with it and your life bar drains rather quickly. If you're not parrying, dodging and reacting, you die.

I spend most of my free time playing difficult games, both modern and retro, as that's what I love the most...this isn't one of those but I also think it isn't 'easy' either. It's not a game you can just button mash your way through and the boss fights are quite engaging, I thought.

Now, if you set it to easier modes, then there's no thought behind it, but on normal and up, I think it's a middle of the road sorta challenge that feels good. The commentary around it really has me very curious to see what others think now. I feel like I'm not really here to defend the game, rather, I'm concerned that I enjoyed it when everyone seems to dislike it, for the most part. It's a 'am I so out of touch' kinda moment I suppose. It's not gonna be on my GOTY list or anything but I've had fun with this. I don't like to engage with giant open world games all that often these days so this sort of length and driving focus is appealing and fun for me personally.

Not to say I can't enjoy a good open world - like I actually loved Crimson Desert despite the jank because it's doing unusual things that captivated me. Wolverine is not doing anything novel, it's just a fun action game. It frustrates me but all I can do is stick by my opinions here.
 
Is that available on a website?
Still no, I'm working on it adding features, optimizing and fixing bugs (regarding stores it now already has PS Store, XBox, Google Play and Apple App Store but want to add Nintendo and Steam, and regarding sections it has that 'game info' section, plus one that I'm completing now to check the rankings of each country and want to add another to make comparisions of groups of games in a single page).

In the rankings I allow to filter per 'platform' to make a 'sub-ranking' showing only the games available to some of these things (in XBox includes as 'platforms' the handheld or cloud):
image.png
 

Lmao, these reviews really got you guys shook. For a game you haven't even played yet. I can't believe people are digging through SkillUp's old reviews to find ways to discredit his Wolverine review. With a review from a game he "sorta" recommends of all things.

Guess what, first of all Mafia The Old Country is a fucking AA game that was sold for $50. It shouldn't be held to the same standards as a AAA game backed by the dominant console platform with a budget of $300m+ and a price tag of $70.

Secondly, people's tastes can change. Nioh 2 is one of my favorite games of all time but Wo Long, RotR and then Nioh 3 have cooled me off those games. Even though one could likewise make up dumb arguments and dig up shit I said I loved about Nioh 2 and point out how Nioh 3 also has those things. After all, it literally copy/pastes most of Nioh 2's enemies, bosses and move sets and just tosses them in an open world setting with some extra bosses and mechanics. But Nioh 2 released 6 years ago and like I said, there have been 3 games with the exact same skeleton released in between Nioh 2 and 3.

Lastly, here's a shocker: maybe a Mafia story set in early 1900s Sicily is just more appealing than another superhero story that we've not only had tons of in video games but also in other media formats?

Interesting. The Old Country is one of the worst games I played in recent times. Incredibly boring. Driver for a few minutes to a destination (dead "open" world), go through a few corridors of cover based shootouts and then watch a cutscene.

Oh and every boss fight is a knife fight. All look and play the same.

Mafia TOC plays like absolute dogshit. I wouldn't even classify it as tech demo gameplay. But the story itself was pretty good for video game standards imho, and it's a setting you do not see in every other game. It's an enjoyable 7/10. When it comes to SkillUp, he only recommends or does not recommend and does not assign a score. For all we know he'd give both of these games a 7/10 but won't recommend Wolverine, because there are better superhero games out there and this one has a price tag of $70 and will maintain that price for much longer while Mafia TOC has no real "this is the same but better" game out there, and was $50 and dropped down to $35 in no time.

That Mafia Old Country is a doozy, you can tell the guy is an absolute dim wit because he praises its writing which is painfully generic and the characters are not interesting, which means he’s simply allured by a style not the actual meat and potatoes.

The skill up guy also loves Ubi slop, loved Avatar which is piss poor, eats all the assassins creed for breakfast, and then says TLOU 2 isn’t well written and Wolverine this and that.

He’s an idiot truly.

Lol, people getting allured by style rather than meat and potatoes is precisely the criticism a lot of people have towards Sony games. Where were you guys when SkillUp was strongly recommending Saros just a few months ago? I guess he was a dimwit back then as well and we should discard that review too?

Also wtf are you talking about him liking Ubi slop? He was shitting on AC Valhalla when most people were still coming hot off of AC Odyssey and loving the new formula of the series. He did not recommend any AC game that has been released since. For his Far Cry 6 review he mockingly titled it "you've already played Far Cry 6".

As for his TLOU2 review, that game was very divisive and he fell in the camp that did not like it. As did I. Everything he mentioned in that review is exactly how I felt about the game. And I have strongly disagreed with SkillUp's reviews in the past. I think his FF16 review is dumb, he went into that one with a preconceived notion of what he thinks FF should be and ended up complaining when it wasn't that. But I don't sit there and go and dig through his old reviews to find ways to discredit his FF16 review because it's just a fucking opinion and every bit as valid as mine.

We do criticise Sony when it is justified.

Buying Bungie was a massive mistake. A panic buy cause MS purchased AB. Sony fucked up.

Same goes for their whole live service push. A massive fuck up. Not only wasted money but even put their single player games output years behind schedule.

We criticised Sony for PC ports. Porting games to PC and giving gamers less reasons to buy a PlayStation. In return Sony made peanuts off those ports and all the negative bullshit from PC gamers.

On the other hand, Sony not making Destiny 3 is justified after wasting 3 billion on Bungie and hundreds of millions on Marathon and Destiny 2. Both their games are dead.

Same goes for Kojima and Physint. Kojima wasted hundreds of millions on DS and wants even more for Physint. The game most probably won’t even break even and Sony doesn’t even get exclusivity or own the IP either.

What’s your argument in return? They should waste more money on Destiny 3 and Physint cause they have wasted it on Concord and Marathon etc.

What sort of deluded logic is that?

It is you spreading FUD not us.

TL;DR: "We do criticize Sony when it's justified, except it was only justified in two specific cases, oh and also we will run a smear campaign against outlets and reviewers who dared to give a 7/10 to a Sony game we haven't even played ourselves yet".

My tastes are misaligned for a game that's scoring well and 80% of outlets felt was a good game? You don't see me over here calling Wolverine a potential gaming masterpiece and one of the best games of all time. It's deliberately a summer action movie equivalent. Those are fun, but it's not high cinema either. That said, it's also not a 5 or a 6 or a "do not recommend" from the outlets you keep harping on as being the true barometer of this game. Those takes are fucking nonsense.

omgbruh.wav

I hope I'll see the same energy from you when a bunch of no name outlets are showering the next Xbox game in 9/10s. Oh wait, you constantly cry about Hellblade 2's score even though that game also has 77% positive reviews (75+ score) on MC compared to Wolverine's 74%. I can write up a bunch of cope of why that game is actually not a 6/10 game either like e.g. GameSpot thinks, based on other outlets scoring it higher. If you actually read many of the 7/10 or 8/10 reviews on Wolverine you'd wonder why they even rate it that high based on the criticisms. The answer is obvious: the game's score is boosted up by its graphical spectacle and technical prowess - just like Hellblade 2. Which should be taken into account for the score, I'm not arguing against that. But it's perfectly normal that one person's 8/10 is another person's 6/10 and yet another person's 10/10. That's just how reviews work, stop being such a baby about it.

The guy is an engagement baiter just like people on twitter. He saw a big popular Marvel game coming out and sought out controversy and decided to go with the mob of haters. He's not consistent whatsoever with any of his takes.

More desperate cope. The guy has strongly recommended (his highest "score"): Spider-Man 2 (another game where he could've joined "the mob of haters"), Spider-Man Remastered, Guardians of the Galaxy and titled his Miles Morales review as "Spider-Man Miles Morales delivers".

If anything the guy LOOOOVES his Marvel games, especially the ones made by Insomniac/Sony, which makes this review even more damning. Because apparently they managed to miss with the #1 Insomniac Marvel game fan.
 
One thing I can't get my head around is how visually messy this game looks at points

Like some areas look okay and then some areas look like they were dropped in from a PS3 version of the game

I saw some Ratchet and Spiderman 2 gameplay as well in the last few days and honestly feels like Wolverine is a step down in many ways

Makes me think that Insomniac is either stretched too thin or have lost some talent
 
Hope we get a what went wrong article on this game

I expect a combination of the leaks, rebooting significant chunks of the game and then Marvel/Sony pressure to get the game done would've screwed things up significantly.

I don't rate Insomniac as highly as some but they seem to far off the mark of their usual 8.5 / 10 quality
 
Hope we get a what went wrong article on this game

I expect a combination of the leaks, rebooting significant chunks of the game and then Marvel/Sony pressure to get the game done would've screwed things up significantly.

I don't rate Insomniac as highly as some but they seem to far off the mark of their usual 8.5 / 10 quality
ita a 8 game so..
 

I don't know about everyone but SkillUp at least specified, repeatedly, multiple times incase people were so dense they wouldn't get it the first time, that while trails are okay in open-world games they are bad in level-based games because they mean that the designers have failed to make an otherwise readable level. Same with the "yellow paint" stuff from a few years back.
 
One thing I can't get my head around is how visually messy this game looks at points

Like some areas look okay and then some areas look like they were dropped in from a PS3 version of the game

I saw some Ratchet and Spiderman 2 gameplay as well in the last few days and honestly feels like Wolverine is a step down in many ways

Makes me think that Insomniac is either stretched too thin or have lost some talent
They did lose talent. They had layoffs.
 
I don't know about everyone but SkillUp at least specified, repeatedly, multiple times incase people were so dense they wouldn't get it the first time, that while trails are okay in open-world games they are bad in level-based games because they mean that the designers have failed to make an otherwise readable level. Same with the "yellow paint" stuff from a few years back.
One wolverine's literal powers is animal like scent tracking. You aren't meant to "read the level design" you're literally meant to follow a target's scent. It's one of the instances of "yellow paint" actually making complete sense. It's ironically a case of ludonarrative harmony lol.

The whole complaint is pure nitpicking nonsense.
Par for the course from skillup of course.
 

Review Aggregator:

OpenCritic - 81 average - 77% recommended - 39 reviews

Wt4PnVc.png
​

Critic Reviews​

But Why Tho? - Matt Sowinski - 6 / 10



COGconnected - James Paley - 100 / 100



ComingSoon.net - Tyler Treese - 8 / 10



Console Creatures - Bobby Pashalidis - 8 / 10



Digital Chumps - Will Silberman - 9.1 / 10



Digitec Magazine - Domagoj Belancic - German - 4 / 5



DualShockers - Christian Bognar - 8.5 / 10



Echo Boomer - David Fialho - Portuguese - No Recommendation



Enternity.gr - Giannis Archontidis - Greek - 8 / 10



Eurogamer.pt - Bruno Galvão - Portuguese - 3 / 5



FOMOS - JONG-BONG, CHOI - Korean - 7.9 / 10



GAMINGbible - Richard Lee Breslin - 7 / 10



GameRant - Anthony Taormina - 8 / 10



Gameliner - Patrick Lamers - Dutch - 4.5 / 5



Gamer Social Club - Andrew Cooper - 9 / 10



GamersGlobal - Benjamin Braun - German - 9.5 / 10



GamingBolt - Rashid Sayed - 10 / 10



Geekinout.pt - Jorge Loureiro - Portuguese - 7 / 10



Giant Bomb - Shawn McDowell - 2.5 / 5



Glitched Africa - Marco Cocomello - 9 / 10



HCL.hr - Dominik Vadas - Unknown - 85 / 100



IGN Italy - Francesco Destri - Italian - 7 / 10



Loot Level Chill - Chris White - 9 / 10



MonsterVine - Spencer Legacy - 4.5 / 5



Nexus Hub - Sam Aberdeen - 8 / 10



One More Game - Ricki Buzon - 7.5 / 10



PPE.pl - Wojciech Gruszczyk - Polish - 8 / 10



PSX Brasil - Ivan Nikolai Barkow Castilho - Portuguese - 80 / 100



PlayStation Universe - John-Paul Jones - 9 / 10



Push Square - Liam Croft - 8 / 10



Saudi Gamer - عصام الشهوان - Arabic - 3.5 / 5



SavePoint Gaming - Jake Su - 7.5 / 10



Sirus Gaming - Lexuzze Tablante - 9 / 10



TheSixthAxis - Jim Hargreaves - 8 / 10



Too Much Gaming - Carlos Hernandez - 3.5 / 5



Uagna - Lorenzo Bologna - Italian - 8.5 / 10



Wccftech - Alessio Palumbo - 8.5 / 10



Worth Playing - Chris "Atom" DeAngelus - 8 / 10



Videos:


​

Skillups review for this game is an evisceration. He encapsulates EVERYTHING which is wrong with Sony games.

This is a linear single player game yet purple branches, blue fart gas, white paint/snow/clothes on the environment at EVERY opportunity. Furthermore, same old forced walking sections with endless boring dialogue, and a protagonist which never shuts up in game.

I had no idea this game was that bad.
 
Sending review keys to the entire YouTube bargain bin was a complete disaster on Insomniac's part. YouTubers have zero integrity, they just wait to see which way the internet wind blows before forming an opinion. By spraying codes at tiny channels with no credibility, Insomniac literally handed ammo to nobodies who knew that orchestrating a hit piece was their only ticket to viral engagement.
 
Sending review keys to the entire YouTube bargain bin was a complete disaster on Insomniac's part. YouTubers have zero integrity, they just wait to see which way the internet wind blows before forming an opinion. By spraying codes at tiny channels with no credibility, Insomniac literally handed ammo to nobodies who knew that orchestrating a hit piece was their only ticket to viral engagement.
By all means the game is mediocre

You dont have grifter to tell you that

Reviewer across the board tell you the same story

Trails that guide you everywhere

Simplistic combat

QTE that doesnt affect the outcome
 
Back
Top