I finished the game and got the Platinum trophy on Friday. Played from start to finish on Best There Is difficulty (hardest one) and didn't touch any accessibility settings.
Final rating for me is a 7.5/10 - up .5 points from the 7 I was feeling during the opening hours.
I think the Metacritic aggregate score kind of nails it - it's a 7.5 that maybe leans a bit higher rather than lower but not an obvious 8/10 and definitely not anything higher than that unless you're an outlier. Likewise the 6/10 scores are on the harsher side, not completely understandable but maybe a bit too critical for my own tastes. That being said, some of the criticisms of the game have been overblown and it seems people have chosen this specific game to air their grievances with some of the formulaic design we've seen in multiple other games in recent years. I do not subscribe to the idea that this is targeted towards Sony, but more the idea that this game just doesn't have enough standout qualities to mask those issues like other games guilty of the same did.
Combat
The Spider-Man DNA for the combat in this game is obvious and can be spotted from a mile away, but obviously it's tweaked to be more suitable for Wolverine. That means no gadgets, no aerial combat, far less movement tech (no mid combat web swinging). Unlike Spider-Man, you are not controlling the battlefield as much as you are dealing with it. Rather than focus on building up combos and avoid getting hit, this game has a rage meter that builds up and allows you to do finishers once it reaches level 3 (or lower with specific mutations you can equip) and likewise functions as a second life if it has at least 1 segment filled.
It does result a little bit in a feast or famine combat system, where if your rage is not at least at 1 bar you feel very vulnerable on the highest difficulty setting. But likewise once you hit rage level 3 the combat is basically over because you can just spam execute enemies back to back. Technically you have to keep your rage high enough to stay in level 3, but this happens automatically as you spam executes. Why they added a "rage tier 3 decays slower" mutation is beyond me, it seems totally redundant even on higher difficulties.
At the start of the game the combat is very barebones and super repetitive. It goes from braindead fun in the first hour to just being braindead for the next few hours. Way too much of Wolverine's kit is gated behind level ups and unlockables. And the combat becomes boring and repetitive until you unlock some of the later abilities and mutations that speed it up. Although some of the unlockables also felt very underwhelming for how long they are gated off. In the later half of the game the combat is fun and has moments where you get into a flow state that feels really nice. But on the highest difficulty it also has some issues with enemies just swarming you and spamming attacks at the same time that all require a different counter - meaning there is never really a right one to pick which feels bad and unpolished.
Boss fights
I saw some reviews complain about these. The Sentinel fight shown in the previews is not just the worst boss in the game but just a bad boss in general. The other bosses are all pretty fun, sort of on Spider-Man 2 level I'd say. I personally preferred the bosses in this game from a gameplay perspective compared to Spider-Man's, but they are nowhere near the level of spectacle on display in Spider-Man.
Overall I would say they are decent/good, but none of them really stand out in particular. Even the
Sabretooth fight would've been pretty forgettable outside of the eye gouging segment, which was a cool twist that made use of Wolverine's unique abilities and reminded me a bit of the Magni and Modi storm segment in GoW2018, I wish the game had more of this kind of stuff.
Story
I'm not a particular X-Men or Marvel buff, most of my exposure to it is from X-Men films, Marvel games and Marvel movies. So I can't speak from that perspective. Overall I think the story is fine. It's not bad but it doesn't really hit any of the emotional beats that Spider-Man 2018 did. The game's story is pretty uninteresting until you get to the Japan section of the game, which is the same moment where the combat starts picking up. In general the story, like the combat, leaves a bad first impression, but redeems itself by the end. The conclusion of the story is hardly really a conclusion and mostly seems to just set up a sequel or X-Men game.
That said I enjoyed the Jean/Wolverine dynamics and the actors all delivered great performances.
Graphics
No complaints here, the game looks amazing and runs flawlessly. It never drops a frame, the resolution is high and crisp (no upscaling artifacts) and ray tracing is on even though in some areas the fact that it's reflecting a much lower quality version of the character looks a bit odd sometimes. Spider-Man had this too but in Spider-Man you never really end up all that close to these surfaces to notice it.
Exploration
I'll keep this short because there's barely any. Most collectibles are just slightly off the beaten path and are marked with massive sonar pulses or scent trails. You'll probably find 90% of the collectibles without even trying. Traversal in the game is also pretty standard fare. Unlike other games of this type, there is never any time you have to solve or figure something out yourself. The game is totally absent of puzzles, unlike Spider-Man or God of War games. Which makes sense for the character but it doesn't make the game any better.
The scent trails make sense story wise but due to the linearity of the game are almost always redundant. That being said, the handholding in this game is much less of an issue than it was during Horizon FW or GoW: Ragnarok.
Polish/bugs
This is a Sony first party game so it's generally pretty well polished for a AAA title on release. That being said I've definitely encountered a fair share of janky animations.
During the final conversation between Wolverine and Jean after killing Essex, one of her locks of hair was clipping into her face on the cutscene for me. It also feels obvious this game was originally designed to have a much larger scope and that sometimes results in feeling like you loaded into a pre-release build where the area still has to be populated with content and activities. There are also some game breaking bugs, for example
during the Sabretooth fight, I used the Helix claws projectile to hit him when he jumped away to leap onto the columns and it just knocked him out of the animation and made him go "out of bounds", where I could neither hit him nor could he hit me and I had to restart the checkpoint.
Summary/verdict
This game is a good "popcorn flick" equivalent of a video game. It doesn't have enough depth or gameplay variety to justify its runtime and price tag. And the opening hours are a bit of a slog. In my opinion it is not worth $70 for most people, but it's a title that's safe to pick up on a sale. I feel like this game almost functions like a "Miles Morales" to an X-Men game, but in the opposite release order.
It's nowhere near a must play and if you don't like AAA games and some of the formulaic design in them, this is an easy skip that's probably not even worth trying at a lower price point.
I wouldn't go as far as say this was a miss for Insomniac but it's clearly their weakest title out of everything they released since 2018. I hope the game does well enough that we maybe can see a second swing at it with the feedback taken into account, whether as a Wolverine standalone game or an X-Men game.