What's new
IconEra

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Forums  ›  Gaming
Xbox 
Screenshot_20261001-153031.webp


18 reviews total, and half of them are bottom-tier Xbox fan sites. Of course the score looks good because it’s literally an echo chamber circlejerk right now :LOL:
 
Not surprised by the scores. It should settle around mid 80’s once more reviews drop. But, Gears has always been a well reviewed franchise. Outside of Gears Judgment, which was made by People Can Fly, no main Gears game has ever scored below an 84 MC. Despite some it’s level design being outdated, Gears is a very fun shooter. That’s why it reviews well.
 
5wdioz.png


bu-bu- wolverine is so much better damn those xbots

Bu bu bu Gears is a true 9/10 for being a 6 hour linear campaign with a bad story, repetitive combat that’s virtually unchanged since 2006 and actually has less combat features

Same old song and dance fella, enjoy watching the paid off Microsoft media glaze and gloss over the flaws here while raking IG over the coals for physical media
 
View attachment 9393

18 reviews total, and half of them are bottom-tier Xbox fan sites. Of course the score looks good because it’s literally an echo chamber circlejerk right now :LOL:

Can’t trust gaming journalism in 2026 unfortunately

When one company does simplistic safe gameplay with industry tropes it’s “good” when the other does it, it “makes the gamer feel stupid”
 
Not surprised by the scores. It should settle around mid 80’s once more reviews drop. But, Gears has always been a well reviewed franchise. Outside of Gears Judgment, which was made by People Can Fly, no main Gears game has ever scored below an 84 MC. Despite some it’s level design being outdated, Gears is a very fun shooter. That’s why it reviews well.

“Fun shooter” and Wolverine is a “fun brawler”

Didn’t stop IG from getting hate from physical media
 
Bu bu bu Gears is a true 9/10 for being a 6 hour linear campaign with a bad story, repetitive combat that’s virtually unchanged since 2006 and actually has less combat features

Same old song and dance fella, enjoy watching the paid off Microsoft media glaze and gloss over the flaws here while raking IG over the coals for physical media
At least Gamespot kept that same energy. Unfortunately IGN had Ryan McCaffrey review it. He was never going to give it anything less than a 9.
 
Back
Top