But they are not the same game. You also claim the same buzzwords were used to praise E-day were used to criticize Wolverine. Can you cite your sources?
open Metacritic for both and word search buzzwords for the reviews for both
But they are not the same game. You also claim the same buzzwords were used to praise E-day were used to criticize Wolverine. Can you cite your sources?
Since Sharma is trying to shape media opinion by paying media outlets.Reviews would matter if they were consistent
They are not
Some companies get a different standard
Since Sharma is trying to shape media opinion by paying media outlets.
open Metacritic for both and word search buzzwords for the reviews for both
Eurogamer Germany
A campaign executed to perfection in terms of both technical aspects and gameplay. A brutal and intense war spectacle featuring the best Gears story to date.
GameOver.gr
Gears of War: E-Day proves, once again, that The Coalition was a top choice to handle this emblematic IP. This prequel expands the gameplay thanks to the clever addition of a dedicated jump button, elevating the moveset and tactical possibilities of the cover-based gameplay. The biggest triumph of E-Day, apart from its gorgeous visuals, is its meticulously crafted and numerous action set-pieces, each one offering thrilling battles. All in all, this new chapter proves that the franchise may be 20 years old, but it remains the pinnacle of third-person cover shooters.
SpazioGames
Gears of War: E-Day is a stunning AAA production and the triumphant return the series deserves. The Coalition blends two decades of experience with meaningful experimentation, delivering a polished campaign that works equally well for newcomers and longtime fans. Gorgeous visuals, impeccable technical execution, and refined gameplay make E-Day a standout release and one of 2026’s essential games.
Voxel
Gears of War: E-Day hits the mark by getting the basics right: embracing its identity as a Gears of War game and elevating the strengths inherent to the series. The game doesn't revolutionize the genre, but it delivers a fun gameplay experience featuring a cinematic narrative and local multiplayer support.
Console Creatures
Gears of War: E-Day feels like the first true Coalition Gears of War game. It's a shift away from Gears 4 and Gears 5, and it feels like the game the studio genuinely wanted to make, capturing what made the original trilogy special while finally pushing the series forward in its own way. They've taken the horror, brutality, brotherhood, and incredible gunplay that defined those games and used them as the foundation for something more modern. Expanded movement gives combat more freedom, while perks and modifications add another layer of experimentation, and the larger environments make Emergence Day feel like a genuine catastrophe happening around you. Gears of War: E-Day is incredible. Despite a handful of frustrations keeping it from perfection, it's one of the best games I've played this year.
VGC
Gears of War E-Day's campaign offers balls-to-the-wall action and rarely lets up, but that means the story takes more of a back seat than I'd like. It's good that time is given to the backstories of new protagonists Mags and Lucas, but given that the game is literally the playable Marcus and Dom backstory fans have been waiting decades to see, more time could have been spent on their relationship. In terms of pure gunplay, however, very little beats it this year.
![]()
Yes clearly, a different standard.
Since Sharma is trying to shape media opinion by paying media outlets.
A 6/10 game is not a 9/10. XboxSomethingName page giving 10/10 are not bias, for sure.
Remember the microsoft files got exposed, about embassors, they cheap and lie
It's the same as discord groups who join to trash a game, hard to believe, but it's true.
There is obvious a clear bias against Sony games. We can never trust reviewers. They're all bought and paid for!There it is. That sweet, sweet conspiracy theory.
There is obvious a clear bias against Sony games. We can never trust reviewers. They're all bought and paid for!
![]()
![]()
![]()
It’s obvious what happened. Halo going to PlayStation completely broke them, so all those salty Xbox fanboys tanked the game’s scores out of pure cope.![]()
Yes clearly, a different standard.
If any of these were Microsoft exclusives they’d be a 94 meta
And the cope continues. The way you stand for nothing while typing up a wall of text![]()
If the media is using the Gears E-Day and RE9 scale for what a 9/10 is, it is
Reviews would matter if they were consistent
They are not
Some companies get a different standard
If any of these were Microsoft exclusives they’d be a 94 meta
All Sony games deserve a score of 271,000 out of 10. Anything less is heresy!There it is. Right into my veins!
Conspiracy? The news about "Xbox CEO Asha Sharma Answers Support Tickets Herself" in every media outlet, yah sure, it's not paid propagandaThere it is. That sweet, sweet conspiracy theory.
His feeble brain and limited attention span cannot tolerate more than two sentences before short-circuiting.I'm the one coping? You are the deluded fanboys talking about Microsoft checks for reviews and anti-Sony bias in reviews over physical games lmao.
You guys turned into blue Xbots. I stand for viewing reviews what they are: opinions. I've never changed that point of view.
Also not surprised your caveman brain thinks a 1-2 sentence reply to a bunch of individual posts is a "wall of text".
RE9 was a noticeably better game than Wolverine. Not what I'd give a 9/10 personally, but that's my personal opinion and I can see why others would see it as a 9/10. Haven't played Gears E-Day and never will.
Wolverine is just a perfectly fine 7.5/10 game and got scored accordingly. There is no conspiracy. The only people who believe that are people who give games +20 points just for being made by Sony.
![]()
Man how do you spend your time arguing on a video game forum and not understand the basics of reviews?
They are subjective opinions by individuals, not by companies. These "companies" have a bunch of different reviewers writing them - who almost never share the same taste or opinions. Not to mention that even among individuals people's tastes or opinions can change according to context. Yeah, when the first Assassin's Creed games came out people loved it and thought it was novel, but a few years later everyone got sick of them due to how formulaic they had become.
We're only on page 3 and the salt is hitting good so far. Gonna be even funnier if they nominate this game for GOTY.
Clear evidence Microsoft is paying off outlets to be positive about them and negative about Sony.