The business model can change. Nintendo wasn't that different from Sony before the Wii, Sony just did their strategy better. They're not hard-locked into doing things this way, and they have 5 generations of Sony + 4 Generations of Xbox to learn and take lessons from.
Most people enjoy Nintendo because of their IP and not because of their gimmicks, portability, or lack of features.
It's not a stretch to assume a dedicated home console from them that's caught up in power thanks to Nvidia's collaboration would do very well since they'd have third party support.
It's just... why?
If The Switch series is already some of the most successful consoles of all time why get caught up in trying to enter the graphical rat race again for third parties?
Yes, as you said the last time they tried this was before the Wii and they lost pretty hard twice in a row.
I also disagree that most people enjoy Nintendo because of their IP and that the gimmicks and features don't matter. Of course IP is a big factor but the form factor, and in this case its portability is huge too. If most of their success was due to IP then the Wii U wouldn't have flopped that hard. Some of the biggest games on the Switch are straight up Wii U ports, and it's not like these games ran or looked much worse on the Wii U so it's not like there was a generational leap that made these titles shine more or whatever.
I think even if they were to make a home console that can somehow run games at the same level of fidelity as Sony consoles can, I think you guys would overestimate how many people would realistically switch platforms. 90% or more of what people play on PlayStation are multiplatform games, offering a device that runs those exact same games at the same level of fidelity/performance is not a selling point. It could only be one to a new audience that has no attachment to any platform in particular.
And like you said, why even bother? They already have a massive install base and no real competition in the portable/hyrbid space. Why muddy your product lineup and open yourself up to direct comparisons with a competitor you lost the home console battle to every single time?
GAAS, MTX, ball and gun gamers. People sitting on PS5 for an extended amount of time leaves Sony vulnerable and in a weaker position than ever. Nintendo's own IPs + power will win over the rest of the market.
GaaS and gun and ball gamers don't give a fuck about Nintendo IP lol.
I don't think so. That's the thing about DLSS and increased power over time, it wins those type of gamers over. Besides that's what a powerful home console is all about, if they're not won over completely yet that's what the home console does. Nintendo's IPs + power beats what PS will have in the 2030s.
These people do not care about anything other than their annual sports/shooter franchise. Nintendo IP is totally irrelevant for them. They're not going to swap platforms to get access to something they already have access to. This is why this strategy will never work. You might convince some of the hardcore gaming crowd but the gun and ball gamers, which make up a significant chunk of what gives Sony their leading market position, have absolutely no reason to swap at all.
What's delusion is thinking what happened to Xbox can't happen to PS. Besides you're just describing history.
Sony had to survive vs Xbox, they did.
Nintendo had to survive with 1st party, they did.
But Sony's new reality is: Survive vs Nintendo with third party support
1. What happened to Xbox happened in a day and age where consoles were a hard reset and people would evaluate which console to go with every generation. Those times are gone. Most people just buy the next version of whatever they have. It'd have to get to Xbox-levels bad for PlayStation to start bleeding like that. Xbox didn't just lose to PlayStation because of exclusives, they had worse third party support, had zero loyalty or brand awareness outside the anglosphere and so on. Thinking what PlayStation built over the last 30 years is as easy to topple as the 5-year 360 fluke is delusional.
2. There is no "Nintendo with third party support". Third party support on Nintendo is still leagues worse than it is on PlayStation and it will never get there as long as they stay focused on the hybrid model, which they will.