This tweet includes numbers made out by VGChartz, which are fake and traditionally in case of Xbox they're bigger than the real ones.
What do you think will happen?
Will they do a firesale of studios and IP's?
Could one of the other companies pick some stuff up?
What could you see Nintendo, Sony or Valve benefitting from?
I think it depends, there are different scenarios:
- Best case for Xbox and their fans: MS sells the whole slate to somebody like Elon Musk. He debloats it firing many people that shouldn't be there as he did with Twitter and replaces a portion of them with capable and productive people. He focus on giving the fans of the IPs what they want in terms of game content and makes the games available everywhere removing any type of Xbox exclusivity. Xbox turns into a full multiplatform gaming ecosystem, but keeps a console hardware. For the first time, Xbox would become a profitable business.
- Most likely case: After a transitional period where MS licenses a few third party hardware manufacturers make Xbox licensed gaming PCs (some of them shaped as home consoles or portable consoles), they stop the Xbox "consoles" and transition to a multiplatform digital platform that after some years ends dying. Their gamedev studios -after some extra layoffs and closures- get moved to four pillar publishers, who start to work more independently and get sold separatedly: King, Activision, Bethesda, Blizzard.
MS would prefer to sell big chunks separatedly instead of shutting it down or to sell it as a whole. The thing is that there are a tiny amount of potential candidates who are in a good position to buy -at least right now due to being on a moment of needing profitability and being conservative regarding investments due to world economics uncertainity- let's say Blizzard, or King, or Bethesda or Activision. Maybe Tencent would buy Activision and King (including Minecraft) and maybe some other Chinese giant like Netease could buy Blizzard.
I don't see anybody wanting to buy Bethesda, because they could be very expensive to buy and run, and have a few interesting IPs (mainly Skyrim -more than Elder Scrolls-, Fallout and Doom) but most of their -some of them very expensive- projects don't seem to be profitable. It would be needed to highly debloat them, change the management and culture to ship games way faster and cheaper to start being profitable. Potential buyers wouldn't want to do this themselves, MS would need to do it before selling them. After being sanitized, Take 2 o Sony could be interested on them, particularly if they include here Coalition and Gears.
Regarding users, there's already an important overlap between PS and Xbox or between Xbox and PC, and less important between Xbox and Nintendo. So if the Xbox consoles dissapear the change wouldn't be notiicable.
Xbox consoles may have maybe 20-40M MAU being optimistic, let's say they end selling 35-40M consoles this generation. A majority of them also play on PS, Nintendo or PC. Regarding PS, let's say a quarter of them already have a PS, and another quarter would move to PS if Xbox consoles die. So PS would earn let's say maybe around 10M new users. Nintendo maybe half of that and PC maybe up to twice that.
So in amount of users, I think Valve would benefit more, followed by Sony and Nintendo would be in the last place. Regarding revenue growth percentage, the most benefited would be Sony followed by Nintendo and Steam would be in the last position.