What's new
IconEra

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Forums  ›  Gaming
Nintendo 
Amazing scores, and my copy also just arrived (the wonders of physical media) so I'll be playing this tonight.

It should have been higher. This is the greatest game of all time and critics describes it as a perfect remake and we got retards giving it an 8 or a 9. This is why critics are morons.

There is no objective greatest game of all time lol, reviews are always subjective as is what is considered the greatest game of all time. The only reason the OG is sitting at a 99 is because it has 22 reviews only. This one has 80+. 96 is just one point below BOTW.

It's just bullshit. IGN gave Mixtape a 10. The truth is critics are compromised.

Because reviews are subjective. The person who reviewed Mixtape is not the same one who reviewed this game. Also the person who reviewed this game is literally IGN's Nintendrone whose bio on the site is about how Zelda is his favorite franchise lol with a banner of link.

96 is a ludicrously high score. What are you even talking about dude. It’s one of the highest rated game of all time yet it needs to be higher? Like what.

It’s OoT. It already has its flowers as one of the greatest and important games of all time. Even that isn’t enough?

He deluded himself into thinking it's gonna get a 99 just because the OG game did. And because he probably wanted to brag that Nintendo had the highest rated game of the year but now GTA6 stands a real chance of matching or beating it.
 
They were way harsher back then. Back then critics had pride about never giving out 10/10s. Now we got IGN giving 10/10 to Mixtape but 9/10 to lower the score out of spite.

Way harsher back then? Of course not lmao. The bar for video games was much lower back then. If you go to top games of all time on Metacritic it's very heavily slanted towards games from the 90s and early 2000s because of how much easier it was to get 90+ scores. There's absolutely zero reason why NFL2K1 should be sitting at a 97. Nor Perfect Dark or Goldeneye or Tony Hawk's Pro Skater for that matter. Even though I love MGS games, MGS2 sitting at the same rating as Elden Ring (a game I don't even like) also makes no sense.

And usually when these games get a 1:1 remake/remaster their score drops considerably.

Also in the case of OOT specifically, there's an argument that its score is already inflated by Metacritic because they left out certain reviews that they normally included for games from back then: https://kotaku.com/did-you-know-gam...score-upsetting-its-top-rated-spot-2000721004
 
He deluded himself into thinking it's gonna get a 99 just because the OG game did. And because he probably wanted to brag that Nintendo had the highest rated game of the year but now GTA6 stands a real chance of matching or beating it.
96 with 80+ reviews is WAY more impressive than 99 with 20 reviews.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It's Zelda week, baby. I don't have time for your delusional takes


You're the one being delusional here if you genuinely think all these old PS1 and N64 absolutely deserve their 95+ scores. Not even that, you genuinely believe they actually had a harder time doing so.

96 with 80+ reviews is WAY more impressive than 99 with 20 reviews.

Exactly, he's just a crybaby because now he can't brag about "best game of all time" or "highest score of the year". But a 96 today is much more impressive than a 99 back then. Like I said, there's a fucking NFL game with a 97 lmao.

He's already preemptively damage controlling in the GTA6 review score predictions thread too because he knows there's a pretty decent chance GTA6 will get a 96-97.
 
I think the original Ocarina is overrated, particularly by the generation of Nintendo fans for who their first console was Nintendo 64 (so got more impressed by its games), or Ocarina was the first Zelda they played (back then many people like me considered it inferior to what at their time meant the orignal one in NES, Link's Awakening or A Link to the Past) or because Ocarina was their first 3D action adventure, having skipped previous titles like Tomb Raider, Mega Man Legends or (released shortly before Ocarina) Metal Gear Solid 1.

And on top of this, I think second Ocarina remake is also overrated by the Nintendo fans because it's Nintendo's only top seller for this Holiday season and Switch doesn't have GTA6 so they need to attrack attention with whatever they have, even if it's a re-remake.

Regarding the original Ocarina's Meta Critic score, it's so high because the Meta Critic staff cherrypicked only 20 scores for it. If they would include the many gaming paper magazines that back then were the gaming media, the score wouldn't have been that high. Not sure if they'll do it this time too, at least not including the typical retarded attention whore too low scores.
 
Last edited:
having skipped previous titles like Tomb Raider, Mega Man Legends or (released shortly before Ocarina) Metal Gear Solid 1
Your argument is highly illogical too because plenty of people owned both or simply played games with their friends. Obviously critics would play everything.
 
I think the original Ocarina is overrated, particularly by the generation of Nintendo fans for who their first console was Nintendo 64 (so got more impressed by its games), or Ocarina was the first Zelda they played (back then many people like me considered it inferior to what at their time meant the orignal one in NES, Link's Awakening or A Link to the Past) or because Ocarina was their first 3D action adventure, having skipped previous titles like Tomb Raider, Mega Man Legends or (released shortly before Ocarina) Metal Gear Solid 1.

And on top of this, I think second Ocarina remake is also overrated by the Nintendo fans because it's Nintendo's only top seller for this Holiday season and Switch doesn't have GTA6 so they need to attrack attention with whatever they have, even if it's a re-remake.

Regarding the original Ocarina's Meta Critic score, it's so high because the Meta Critic staff cherrypicked only 20 scores for it. If they would include the many gaming paper magazines that back then were the gaming media, the score wouldn't have been that high. Not sure if they'll do it this time too, at least not including the typical retarded attention whore too low scores.

Imo, Nah. I get it and except it for those who prefer it. But I played the originals and OOT just hit different. From the title screen it was just more epic and fleshed out.

For me, Better NPC's and village/town, music, Epona, night and day cycle, combat is better than the snes and nes versions, boss fights way more engaging. The ocarina songs itself had so much going for it too and secrets with it.

Snes one was great and it maybe did some puzzles and world secrets better, and even some NPC's but I really felt OOT did most things better, atmosphere and story telling imo.

Its like MGS vs MG. That 3D switch just made the atmosphere way different.

Its preference I guess

Now Super Mario vs Mario 64 is alot closer lol
 
Last edited:
Another game getting 10+ extra points added to it because it's the big Nintendo Exclusive.
Pretty much.

I also have a feeling the gaming media is gonna do everything in there power to make sure GTA6 doesn't get a higher score then this game.
 
Never own an N64. Looking forward to playing this.
Hopefully you will enjoy.

I recently went back to Tomb Raider collextion. And despite the controls, I really liked it. TR4 that is, i finished the originals back in the day
 
Back
Top