What's new
IconEra

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Forums  ›  Gaming
Discussion 
Goldeneye supported two sticks by using a second controller.

The N64 stick is the most precise stick used in a consumer controller. They just needed lubricated.

Eyes What GIF
i
 
Sony made the dualshaock in 97 and made the sequel in 2000, a year before the shitbox even was a thing.
In 1997 Sony also released the Dual Analog Controller, months before releasing the DualShock. It basically was the same than the DualShock but without rumble, and was first shown in the PlayStation Expo 96–97 back in November 1996.

Regarding single analog controller, PlayStation 1 had Namco's NeGcon back in 1995, which was supported by many racing games of the time like Ridge Racer, Wipeout, Gran Turismo or Destruction Derby. Or way before it, in the 70s there were consoles like Prinztronic / Acetronic / Interton with a single analog controller, or in the early 80s Vectex or Atari 5200.

In the 80s when Sony started to publish their first videogames for the MSX they also released several controllers. One of them, the Sony JS-303T, featured a thumbstick with analog positions but a digital input. Sony also released a wireless controller back in 1984, the Sony JS-75.
 
They did that in the 80s.

Nintendo's controllers didn't have grips until the N64. NES/SNES controllers were just pads without grips, N64 had 3 grips and the GameCube one was the first one with 2 grips.

Unless you are talking about the NES Max controller, which would be funny because that's like arguing features on pro controllers are standard now. Also why would you argue people copied the N64 controller in terms of analog sticks considering that controller already had an analog stick too if you're counting it?

GCN actually only had 3 shoulder buttons, a major mistake that continues to haunt it to this day.

Yeah you are right. All in all I think it's clear that Nintendo kept experimenting every generation but in the end they just ended up settling on what Xbox already figured out almost 2 decades earlier, which they did by just taking what PS had already done and swapping the d-pad and left stick because it's more ergonomic.
 
All in all I think it's clear that Nintendo kept experimenting every generation but in the end they just ended up settling on what Xbox already figured out almost 2 decades earlier, which they did by just taking what PS had already done and swapping the d-pad and left stick because it's more ergonomic.
It's actually insane you believe this shit when Nintendo did everything earlier. If Nintendo wanted to copy the PS controller, and they've tried similar designs later, then they would just do it. But they didn't. Neither did they copy the Xbox controller because they didn't do that either.
 
It's actually insane you believe this shit when Nintendo did everything earlier. If Nintendo wanted to copy the PS controller, and they've tried similar designs later, then they would just do it. But they didn't. Neither did they copy the Xbox controller because they didn't do that either.

They literally copied the PS layout with the Wii controller (not the Wii mote obviously) minus 2 shoulder buttons and grips. Then they changed it again with the Wii U and in the end with the Switch they just said fuck it, copied the Xbox layout, and stuck with it. It's the only time they kept the same controller layout in two generations back to back.

It's so funny how you want to act like there was some sort of clear progression from the NES to the Switch controller. Nah dude, that's not how it went. With the PlayStation controller you can take the PS1 controller, compare it to the PS5 controller and see they just added some stuff. They've never removed things that were there on the PS1 controller, and the general design principle and form factor has remained the same all this time. With Nintendo there is logical progression from NES to SNES, then it goes completely off the hook with the N64, then it goes to a more conventional layout from there (in a post PS1 Dual Analog world) with the GameCube by removing a lot of the weird shit the N64 controller did but not quite yet, and then they spend another few generations trying to come up with their own bespoke layout until they finally just give up and copy the Xbox one.

"Nintendo did everything earlier my ass". PlayStation had built in rumble days before the N64 controller had rumble. It had dual analog sticks a generation before Nintendo did. It had 4 shoulder buttons and clickable analog sticks in its the 5th generation while it took Nintendo until the 8th generation. All features Nintendo has since adopted and stuck with.

Trying to argue PlayStation didn't design the template for modern game controllers in the 5th gen is fucking stupid. The DualShock literally has 99% of the features modern game controllers have 30 years later. The same cannot be said about Nintendo's controllers until the Switch. And this is why the control schemes on classic Nintendo games translate awkardly to their modern controllers, which doesn't happen with PlayStation. If I play Legend of Dragoon on my PS5, all the button prompts exist on my current-day controller. When I play Mario 64 through NSO, it's telling me to use buttons that don't exist on a Switch.
 
They literally copied the PS layout with the Wii controller (not the Wii mote obviously) minus 2 shoulder buttons and grips. Then they changed it again with the Wii U and in the end with the Switch they just said fuck it, copied the Xbox layout, and stuck with it. It's the only time they kept the same controller layout in two generations back to back.
Nintendo doesn't need to copy anybody when they did everything first and that shit became industry standard. You can trace everything they did from their previous controllers to their modern ones.
images


The DualShock literally has 99% of the features modern game controllers have 30 years later.
Weird thing to say when no other controller bothers to copy it because it's easily the worst design because all Sony did was copy the SNES controller, add no joysticks which is why there's tons of PS1 games that use any joysticks at all and then never make any changes despite being inferior in design. The d-pad is where you'd want the left joystick to be.
I think with PS1 it was what it was, Nintendo released N64 and revolutionary controller design and Sony was stuck in a weird place. They already had a controller. But by the time PS2 was here Sony didn't have any excuses anymore. They should have made a better controller.
The only smart thing they did in my opinion are the face buttons.
sddefault.jpg
 
Nintendo doesn't need to copy anybody when they did everything first and that shit became industry standard. You can trace everything they did from their previous controllers to their modern ones.
images

Lmao, industry standard he says. When they only arrived at the "industry standard" layout 9 years ago following multiple generations of changing designs because they couldn't even come up with a standard for themselves, let alone the industry.

You are arguing because that because Nintendo included individual parts like an analog stick first they get to take credit for how others have used analog sticks, including dual analog sticks or the location of such analog sticks on the layout of the controller. It's stupid as fuck.

Anyone who has a remotely functioning brain can easily see how the PlayStation controller became the industry standard (d-pad + 4 face buttons, dual analog sticks, quadruple shoulder buttons, built-in vibration), and the only point of contention about it is whether the d-pad and left analog stick should swap locations (which is what Xbox did and Nintendo did).

Weird thing to say when no other controller bothers to copy it because it's easily the worst design because all Sony did was copy the SNES controller, add no joysticks which is why there's tons of PS1 games that use any joysticks at all and then never make any changes despite being inferior in design. The d-pad is where you'd want the left joystick to be.
I think with PS1 it was what it was, Nintendo released N64 and revolutionary controller design and Sony was stuck in a weird place. They already had a controller. But by the time PS2 was here Sony didn't have any excuses anymore. They should have made a better controller.
The only smart thing they did in my opinion are the face buttons.
sddefault.jpg

What a dumb ass take. Even though the original PS1 controller didn't include sticks, it still had 4 shoulder buttons compared to 2 on the SNES controller. And it had grips to hold it, it wasn't a pad like the SNES controller. But yeah obviously that wasn't much innovation. But then they added not one but 2 analog sticks long before the generation was over, and that completed the design that has been the industry standard ever since. And it had games designed around using that functionality before the 6th generation launched as well. There are PS1 games where you control the character with the left stick and the camera with the right stick.

Like I said, PS1 games translate 1:1 to modern controllers. N64 games don't.

Arguing "no one copied" it because the stick and d-pad should swap places is dumb as hell because Nintendo literally copied symmetrical analog sticks with the Wii. And then they did again with the Wii U except they went full retard and put the sticks on top on both sides. Besides, it is purely preference. I can use both styles with zero preference between either.

Also how can you post that picture and unironically try to argue Nintendo didn't copy Xbox's layout? No, they didn't just go back to the GameCube design because the GameCube has totally different face buttons, only has 3 shoulder buttons. And the Xbox controller always had symmetrical and equal-sized face buttons and quad shoulder buttons, which Nintendo also finally adopted with the Switch.
 
Nintendo doesn't need to copy anybody when they did everything first and that shit became industry standard. You can trace everything they did from their previous controllers to their modern ones.
images
This has to be the worst designed controller of all time.

How the hell would you be able to aim and shoot in an FPS whilst retaining access to the face buttons?

It also looks ghastly.

Clearly a controller designed for extra terrestrials with 3 appendages.
 
This has to be the worst designed controller of all time.

How the hell would you be able to aim and shoot in an FPS whilst retaining access to the face buttons?

It also looks ghastly.

Clearly a controller designed for extra terrestrials with 3 appendages.

The idea is that you swap your grip depending on whether you play a 2d or 3d game. You would control the camera with those yellow buttons rather than the stick. There's a trigger on the back used for shooters.

Either way, it was a dogshit design and only some Nintendo kids who grew up with it have affection towards it. It even runs antithetical to Nintendo's design principles that things should be intuitive and make sense without prior knowledge. The fact that people with 20+ years of gaming experience can look at it and still get confused how tf you're supposed to hold and use it shows how poorly designed it was. Thank god it's the Sony controller design that triumphed and became the standard.
 
Anyone who has a remotely functioning brain can easily see how the PlayStation controller became the industry standard (d-pad + 4 face buttons, dual analog sticks, quadruple shoulder buttons, built-in vibration), and the only point of contention about it is whether the d-pad and left analog stick should swap locations (which is what Xbox did and Nintendo did).
If you really think so why doesn't any modern controller look like the PS controllers?
 
If you really think so why doesn't any modern controller look like the PS controllers?

Well, first of all, they do. The only difference is that the position of the d-pad and left stick are swapped. But the moving parts that are present on every modern controller were already there on the DualShock on the PS1. Two sticks, 4 shoulder buttons, a d-pad, 4 equal-sized face buttons laid out in a cross-shaped pattern.

Xbox copied those principles for the first Xbox, and just swapped the d-pad and stick because the logic was that your thumb naturally rests a bit higher when gripping the grips on a controller and since your left thumb would mostly be using the stick and not the d-pad anymore in an industry designed around 3d, they made the decision to swap those.

And the reason for that layout becoming more widespread than the PS layout is simple: PS3 took a hit in popularity while Xbox gained in popularity in the mid to late 2000s. And long before PC supported all kinds of controllers out of the box, the Xbox controller was the only one that worked without a hassle on PC on these games that would increasingly be coming over to PC after launching on consoles. So both millions of 360 gamers and PC gamers got used to the Xbox controllers. Now that PS controllers actually work out of the box on PC, they've started becoming a bit more popular for use on PC. PS controllers are more popular for fighting game players because they need the d-pad rather than the analog stick.

Either way, the irony is not lost on me that you are arguing Sony supposedly didn't set the design basics for modern controllers because most third parties choose to swap the d-pad and left stick, but will simultaneously argue Nintendo set the industry standards when they were busy creating weird ass contraptions like the N64 and GameCube controller that no one copied even halfway, while Sony already had 99% of what almost all modern controllers look like minus the offset sticks back in 1997.
 
the irony is not lost on me that you are arguing Sony supposedly didn't set the design basics for modern controllers
Because they didn't. N64 had a joystick and rumble and it was showcased so no shit Sony copied it but they stuck with the worst design because the PS1 controller was already done. The strange and dumb thing is they didn't change it by the time the PS2 controller arrived.
 
N64 base controller was far better than the original PS1 controller. Yeah, the wacky layout sucked, but it had an analog stick and the PS1 didn't. Go back and play games that pre-date the PS1 dual shock, like the original Tomb Raider, and try to justify using a D-pad in 3D space. You can't it was absolute shit.

PS1 and Saturn were far superior for fighting games than N64x Both 2d and 3d.

Dual analogue sticks and 2 shoulder buttons was something Sony did properly first. Both parts stood the test of time.

Both Nintendo and Microsoft use twin shoulder buttons and dual analogue sticks now despite trying there own things (gamecube, wii and Og xbox controller)
 
Back
Top