What's new
IconEra

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Forums  ›  Gaming
Discussion 
Skyrim came out in 2011 and won in 2011, what are you even talking about?
Yeah that's my point. That's when the 3DS remake came out. Ocarina of Time was always a home console game, 3DS remake was a handheld remake. Nobody argued ever that GOTY shouldn't win but now when Ocarina is mogging then suddenly remakes is a problem.
It's funny people are so vocal about it when it's AI slop and indies that truly doesn't deserve any kind of awards.
 
Yeah that's my point. That's when the 3DS remake came out. Ocarina of Time was always a home console game, 3DS remake was a handheld remake. Nobody argued ever that GOTY shouldn't win but now when Ocarina is mogging then suddenly remakes is a problem.
It's funny people are so vocal about it when it's AI slop and indies that truly doesn't deserve any kind of awards.
2011, the year we were blessed with Dark Souls(better than Oot), Skyrim, Batman AC, and Uncharted 3. No shit a 3DS game wasn't even in the conversation, and quite frankly, neither should the new remake.

Idk why I am even wasting time for you, OoT is a less than 0% of taking GOTY so this conversation is useless.
 
So? Skyrim won GOTY back then so now Ocarina doesn't deserve to win against all the lesser games this year?

If Skyrim beat it last time, GTA6 will wipe the floor with it this time lol.

And yes, if Bethesda drops a Skyrim remake next year I also don't think that should be winning or even nominated (that being said, Skyrim probably aged a lot more poorly, just look at the Halo 1 Remake).

When you remake old games or 2D games it costs just as much and it's just as risky as making new games.
What data does Square Enix have if they remake FF6 with a one game remake that it's gonna be a big hit? They don't. There's no data at all.
But if they were to do it and it's the best game of the year then obviously it should win if they do it in the future.

Just as risky as making new games? Man your statements get dumber day by day. The reason everyone is doing remakes is literally because they're less risky. You have the performance of the old game, you can make an estimate of how many people are going to show up at minimum. You already know how critics view the game. There's tons of pre-existing word of mouth out there that you don't have to earn a second time. You don't have to waste time on coming up with a concept, writing a scenario, etc. The list goes on.

Also, as @voke mentioned this isn't even the first remake of the game. So they already knew how many people showed up last time at a bare minimum.

They're cheaper/easier to make and less risky to put out. Unless you go for the reimagining route like RE2/FF7 Remake, but even then those titles will naturally have a minimum customer base purely off of nostalgia for the old title alone. In FF7 Remake's case the launch sales were so good that it probably broke even immediately before anyone could even really decide on whether it was good or not.

FF6 is old as fuck and nowhere near as popular as games like FF7 or OOT were. Note how these companies are remaking their greatest hits, not the cult classics that were under appreciated. There's a reason Nintendo remade OOT and didn't start with LTTP or whatever. But even if they were to remake it, it would naturally benefit from a lot of the factors I mentioned above.

And if Square remakes FF6 almost 1:1 and only modernizes the graphics and adds some QOL changes, I do not think it should be nominated for or win GOTY either.

Yeah that's my point. That's when the 3DS remake came out. Ocarina of Time was always a home console game, 3DS remake was a handheld remake. Nobody argued ever that GOTY shouldn't win but now when Ocarina is mogging then suddenly remakes is a problem.
It's funny people are so vocal about it when it's AI slop and indies that truly doesn't deserve any kind of awards.

Man stop acting like this debate is something new spurred on by Ocarina of Time "mogging". Like I said before, this debate kicked off years ago when RE4 was nominated. People were ok with FF7 Remake getting nominated in 2020 because of how different it was. And even then you probably had some people arguing against it. Also there wasn't a sea of 90+ games in 2020 like there were in 2023. But with the RE4 remake, the game so closely resembled the original which is already seen as one of the GOATs and won GOTY when it released. So that's when people started debating whether it's really fair or a good thing to nominate and award such games over fresh titles.
 
And yes, if Bethesda drops a Skyrim remake next year I also don't think that should be winning or even nominated
Skyrim felt a lot like GTA 5 or RDR2. Outdated at launch.

The reason everyone is doing remakes is literally because they're less risky.
Ain't the same as remaking old games. They're all been using early demakes and lousy ones at that to simply to make money.
Ocarina of Time is unlike any other remake ever made.

stop acting like this debate is something new spurred on by Ocarina of Time "mogging"
People say it literally. They say it's the best and should win and therefore shouldn't win. I've ironically never seen that happen before where people admit it should win so therefore it shouldn't. Truth is another open world game winning that does nothing innovative would be boring as fuck.
 
Skyrim felt a lot like GTA 5 or RDR2. Outdated at launch.

Holy shit, the takes just keep getting worse and worse. All three of these games have sold dozens of millions, or in GTA5's case hundreds of millions in the years since they launched. They were so outdated at launch that one of these games is still frequently in the top 20 annual sales charts and prints half a billion a year.

Ain't the same as remaking old games. They're all been using early demakes and lousy ones at that to simply to make money.
Ocarina of Time is unlike any other remake ever made.

Man stop it with these fucking stupid takes. The OOT Remake is no different from the RE4 Remake. It took 90% of what was there, shuffled some things around to keep it fresh for returning players and make it more suitable for modern sensitivities, and mostly just improved the control scheme while redoing the graphics. When you take a game that's already rated 90+ and don't mess around with it too much, you can reliably expect a 90+ MC score again with a remake. Zero risk involved.

The only remakes that are actually risky are the ones like FF7 Remake because they fundamentally alter what the game is and are taking creative risks in multiple ways. Massively increasing the scope also comes with a massive increase in budget and timeline. FF7 Remake got criticized partially for some of the things they added that weren't there before (side quests), which wouldn't have been there if they just did a 1:1 remake. Likewise, if Nintendo had expanded OOT greatly and added new zones or dungeons and those were viewed as lower quality, or if they messed around with the story to people's dislike, it could've also dragged the score and reception down. But they took no such risks.

People say it literally. They say it's the best and should win and therefore shouldn't win. I've ironically never seen that happen before where people admit it should win so therefore it shouldn't. Truth is another open world game winning that does nothing innovative would be boring as fuck.

Literally no one is saying this shit because GTA6 is dropping this year. No one unironically expects OOT to beat GTA6 unless there's something seriously wrong with GTA6, which would be unprecedented for Rockstar. This is a company that has a pretty much uninterrupted streak of putting out 95+ MC games since 2001 for their main releases.
 
All three of these games have sold dozens of millions, or in GTA5's case hundreds of millions in the years since they launched
So? There's lots of boring movies that made money. It's the same thing in gaming.

The OOT Remake is no different from the RE4 Remake
I still see plenty of who preferred the original and I never saw the crazy takes people have about Ocarina, which is partly because it's a Nintendo game obviously.

When you take a game that's already rated 90+ and don't mess around with it too much, you can reliably expect a 90+ MC score again with a remake. Zero risk involved.
There's plenty of IPs that aren't as strong as Zelda though. Zelda is a global seller and stronger than ever.

Literally no one is saying this shit because GTA6 is dropping this year.
Oh really. I've seen people say that over and over. It doesn't deserve to win because they feel it'd be unfair to Rockstar.
Like Rockstar deserves it all after they killed physical and charged $100 for a rental.
 
afbeelding.png

 
So? There's lots of boring movies that made money. It's the same thing in gaming.

It's funny how you bust a nut when you see a stack of physical OOT copies at a shop being sent out for shipment, or when it hits a 95+ on MC. But the moment a Rockstar game hits 95+ and sells more with a single game than the entire Zelda franchise combined, suddenly it means nothing about the quality of the game.

People are not starved for content in gaming. If GTA was truly boring, it wouldn't sell this much.

I still see plenty of who preferred the original and I never saw the crazy takes people have about Ocarina, which is partly because it's a Nintendo game obviously.

No, this is just your Nintendo fanboy bias locking you out of seeing such criticisms towards the OOT Remake. There are likewise people arguing that the OOT Remake has sanded off the "edges" of the original OOT too much, or that they liked the atmosphere in the original version better. If you think there's no one who prefers the original over the remake, unlike with RE4, you are wrong. And even if everyone thinks the remake is a 100% replacement that removes the need to ever touch the original again, it doesn't change the fact that fundamentally both games are a near 1:1 remake of a GOTY game from the past where a huge chunk of its rating is naturally going to be affected by that.

There's plenty of IPs that aren't as strong as Zelda though. Zelda is a global seller and stronger than ever.

What does that even have to do with what I wrote there? Also most of that popularity is a result of BOTW/TOTK blowing up the franchise. Those two games combined already account for more than 30% of the entire series' sales, a series that has been around since the 80s.

Oh really. I've seen people say that over and over. It doesn't deserve to win because they feel it'd be unfair to Rockstar.
Like Rockstar deserves it all after they killed physical and charged $100 for a rental.

Lmao, literally no one is saying this. You always come up with these bullshit anecdotes that no one can verify, because you don't know how to actually argue based on facts. People are not saying OOT doesn't deserve to win because of Rockstar, if it was any other company having the GOTY frontrunner game they would say the same. People are saying it doesn't deserve GOTY because 90% of the game is a GOTY game from 1998 that has received a fresh coat of paint and some QOL features. They'd say the same shit if in 2032 Elden Ring Remake releases or whatever that mostly just takes the game, updates the graphics and music and adds some quality of life features.

There may have been a case to award GOTY to OOT in a year where the next-best game is like barely scratching 90 on MC like in 2021 or 2019. But with GTA6 dropping, that's obviously not going to be the case.
 
But the moment a Rockstar game hits 95+ and sells more with a single game than the entire Zelda franchise combined, suddenly it means nothing about the quality of the game.
Only GTA 3 deserved the 10s it got because it popularized the open world genre but honestly they've just been making more of the same since then and haven't improved. I've seen all the excuses, "they've been busy milking GTA 5." etc. I think it's more that Rockstar doesn't experiment and nobody there is allowed to. So they just make the same slop all the time. Sales doesn't equal quality either

People are not starved for content in gaming. If GTA was truly boring, it wouldn't sell this much.
I think your problem is you don't understand people are afraid to try new things. Plenty of boring shit succeeds all the time and it's not limited to games.

What does that even have to do with what I wrote there? Also most of that popularity is a result of BOTW/TOTK blowing up the franchise.
Yeah Nintendo beat Rockstar in their own genre but Nintendo remaking the greatest game ever is suddenly "unfair" lol.

literally no one is saying this.
They're all saying it. It's honestly pathetic that people think that at all, Rockstar has milked GTA 5 forever so GTA 6 "deserves to win" like Rockstar is some small indie company. Give me a break.

People are saying it doesn't deserve GOTY because 90% of the game is a GOTY game from 1998 that has received a fresh coat of paint and some QOL features. They'd say the same shit if in 2032 Elden Ring Remake releases or whatever that mostly just takes the game, updates the graphics and music and adds some quality of life features.
Elden Ring ain't no Ocarina of Time, man. We'd be in the year 2050, the fuck you know what game deserves to win in the year 2050?

There may have been a case to award GOTY to OOT in a year where the next-best game is like barely scratching 90 on MC like in 2021 or 2019. But with GTA6 dropping, that's obviously not going to be the case.
Oh really. Cyberleek has shown the game looks boring as fuck though.
 
Only GTA 3 deserved the 10s it got because it popularized the open world genre but honestly they've just been making more of the same since then and haven't improved. I've seen all the excuses, "they've been busy milking GTA 5." etc. I think it's more that Rockstar doesn't experiment and nobody there is allowed to. So they just make the same slop all the time. Sales doesn't equal quality either

People who say Rockstar has been busy milking GTA5 are people who refuse to acknowledge RDR2 exists. Yes, there's a 13-year gap between GTA releases but let's not act like they released nothing in between. There have been 5 years between GTA5 and RDR2 and then 8 years between that game and now GTA6. That's really not that crazy, and just a few years slower than your average publisher between tentpole releases (because they're much more ambitious than those). There were 6 years between BOTW and TOTK as well, a game that was reusing a lot of assets - something which Rockstar couldn't do with this game. We're coming up on 10 years between 3D Mario releases.

Saying their games haven't improved since GTA3 is hilarious. Even between GTA3 and GTA SA they made huge improvements. GTA3 is borderline unplayable nowadays, GTA SA already plays a lot better but even that game hasn't aged very well. GTA5 plays like it could've been released last year.

And saying they haven't improved is extra funny considering the past two weeks you've spent glazing OOT. Saying it's the greatest game of all time. Which means Nintendo hasn't improved in 28 years rather than Rockstar's 25 years.

I think your problem is you don't understand people are afraid to try new things. Plenty of boring shit succeeds all the time and it's not limited to games.

Or maybe it's just really good, have you ever considered that? There's a reason people are "afraid to try" games other than GTA. It's because GTA has proven to deliver banger high quality experiences every single time. It's a blind buy.

Yeah Nintendo beat Rockstar in their own genre but Nintendo remaking the greatest game ever is suddenly "unfair" lol.

Except Nintendo hasn't beaten Rockstar in their own genre. So far Rockstar's open world games are still sitting at higher ratings than Nintendo's. And they've sold far better as well. Funnily enough you want to claim Nintendo beat Rockstar with BOTW but their own developers were supposedly inspired by RDR2 when working on TOTK.

They're all saying it. It's honestly pathetic that people think that at all, Rockstar has milked GTA 5 forever so GTA 6 "deserves to win" like Rockstar is some small indie company. Give me a break.

No one is saying it, you are just coping because you are arguing OOT should get the award because you have this totally delusional view that Nintendo has somehow made a special remake that's unlike all the other remakes we've seen the last 10 years.

GTA6 deserves to win not because Rockstar is an indie underdog, it's the favorite here and OOT is the underdog anyway. People argue GTA6 deserves to win because it's actually a NEW GAME and not a previous GOTY game with a fresh coat of paint. What's so hard to grasp about that? Should we also just nominate The Godfather for the Oscars again and hand it awards over new movies that were released this year?

Elden Ring ain't no Ocarina of Time, man. We'd be in the year 2050, the fuck you know what game deserves to win in the year 2050?

Elden Ring is this generation's Ocarina of Time and I say that as someone who doesn't even like Elden Ring. How anyone can look at the endless horde of FromSoftware clone games and act like it hasn't inspired copycats like OOT did is beyond me. And yeah, Elden Ring Remake shouldn't win in 2050 or ever for that matter either.

Man OOT is a legendary game and functions as an inspiration for a lot of modern games still, but acting like it's leagues above what's available in this day and age is stupid as fuck, I'm sorry. It's an insult to this whole industry to insinuate that somehow in 1998 a game came out that no one has ever come close to since to the point that they could just rerelease it almost 30 years later and have it be considered the best game of the year again, in a year where another massively influential publisher is dropping the most-anticipated game of all time. Even back when it released a lot of people were debating whether FF7 or OOT was better. Somehow before 2000 its status as greatest of all time was up for discussion but now it suddenly no longer is? Lol.

Oh really. Cyberleek has shown the game looks boring as fuck though.

Lmao, you keep coping with these cyberleek leaks both here and on installbaseforum. As if they actually show what the game is like. Like I said, I can record out of context clips and make OOT Remake look boring as fuck too. You've seen nothing of the game.
 
Last edited:
Should we also just nominate The Godfather for the Oscars again and hand it awards over new movies that were released this year?
Ben-Hur is a remake, man, it won Oscars. If The Godfather got a perfect remake then you bet your ass it would win Oscars any given year.

It's an insult to this whole industry to insinuate that somehow in 1998 a game came out that no one has ever come close to since to the point that they could just rerelease it almost 30 years later and have it be considered the best game of the year again
gitgud
 
Ben-Hur is a remake, man, it won Oscars. If The Godfather got a perfect remake then you bet your ass it would win Oscars any given year.

Yeah because with a movie remake you actually have to remake the whole thing. The only thing that's already there for a movie remake is the basic plot. If they just reshot The Godfather shot for shot and scene for scene with new actors and new cameras, keeping the dialogue 90% the same, it wouldn't win an Oscar and people would call it a travesty.

There's also no such thing as a perfect remake.


Say that to Nintendo who apparently peaked in 1998? The uncomfortable reality is that if Ocarina of Time had released today as a new game and the original never existed, no one would be viewing it as the greatest game of all time. A good chunk of the praise for the game is rooted in the fact that it was made in 1998. For today's standards it's still surprisingly good but by no stretch of the imagination the best game of this generation or even of this year. Which is why having such games involved in GOTY award competitions is problematic, because people cannot view the game objectively and their views will be clouded by their experience with the original game. Even when a game is so substantially different that it might as well be an entirely new game, like FF7 Remake or RE2 Remake, it's never going to be completely free of its links to the original. But no one is going to praise GTA6 because of their feelings to GTA4 or whatever.
 
Remedy glazing strikes again, imagine nominating a 83 MC game for GOTY when there are so many 85+ and even close to 90 games to choose from. Other than that I have no issues with the nominees.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ico
Remedy glazing strikes again, imagine nominating a 83 MC game for GOTY when there are so many 85+ and even close to 90 games to choose from. Other than that I have no issues with the nominees.
Control Resonant getting a GotY nomination is wild to me.

There are dozens of games with higher metacritic scores which did far more to push the medium forward this year.
 
Back
Top