What's new
IconEra

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Forums  ›  Gaming
Discussion 
Have you worked in a major corporation before? I ask this not with the intent to condescend.

Speaking as someome who's worked in the tech industry in corporate america for most of their career, the sort of widespread directional shift from Sony studios towards live service games virtually never happens without influence from leadership.

Uh yes,

have you?

All respect, but there’s a high motive to chase profitable things. Do you think Bluepoint management doesn’t care about chasing big money?

Sony has historically given lots of creative flexibility. You think they are forcing naughty dog to make intergalactic rather than a safe and proven IP like TLOU or Uncharted?
 
Have you worked in a major corporation before? I ask this not with the intent to condescend.

Speaking as someome who's worked in the tech industry in corporate america for most of their career, the sort of widespread directional shift from Sony studios towards live service games virtually never happens without influence from leadership.

I think they have a fixed budget pool for single player stuff and a fixed budget pool for GaaS stuff. Naturally competition over the former is far higher in an organization like PlayStation with a lot of “traditional” game studios, especially with studios like SMS, Insomniac and ND who burn through 200-300m per game.

So it’s not as black and white as Sony putting a gun to their head and telling them to make GaaS or Bluepoint being totally free to just do whatever they want. It’s somewhere in between. From previous Schreider reports we know that they were a lot more lax with green lighting GaaS games than traditional games and as a result many studios pivoted to pitching GaaS.
 
Have you worked in a major corporation before? I ask this not with the intent to condescend.

Speaking as someome who's worked in the tech industry in corporate america for most of their career, the sort of widespread directional shift from Sony studios towards live service games virtually never happens without influence from leadership.
Yeah I think the old ways are mostly done.

Maybe might leave a few directors and studios to work on what they want, but no way Bluepoint decided by themselves to make a GOW MP game on their own
 
Uh yes,

have you?

All respect, but there’s a high motive to chase profitable things. Do you think Bluepoint management doesn’t care about chasing big money?

Sony has historically given lots of creative flexibility. You think they are forcing naughty dog to make intergalactic rather than a safe and proven IP like TLOU or Uncharted?
I think they allow some studios to work on what they want and directors. Theres a difference between Naughty Dog and Pixies for example or Bluepoint.

I dont think theres no way that Bluepoint decied to work on a MP by themselves. They need permission. Especially after being made to help with Ragnarok, I just dont see it

Either way, maybe Sony should start managing better what some studios are doing
 
I think they allow some studios to work on what they want and directors. Theres a difference between Naughty Dog and Pixies for example or Bluepoint.

I dont think theres no way that Bluepoint decied to work on a MP by themselves. They need permission. Especially after being made to help with Ragnarok, I just dont see it

Either way, maybe Sony should start managing better what some studios are doing

I think it’s not completely unimaginable that Bluepoint wanted to do something other than just remaking games and that they knew a GaaS project would be far more likely to get approved than a single player game.

Now the real question is what did they do the entire last year after the GaaS game got cancelled. Did they go back to pitching other risky projects or did they pitch remakes and Sony said no? In case it’s the latter I agree Sony fucked it up.
 
Recent Sony game studio acquisitions
  • 2021: Nixxes
  • 2021: Firesprite (layoffs in 2024)
  • 2021: Bluepoint (closed in 2026)
  • 2021: Housemarque (new game soon)
  • 2022: Valkyrie Entertainment
  • 2022: Haven Studios
  • 2022: Bungie (layoffs in 2024; new game soon)
  • 2022: Neon Koi (closed in 2024)
  • 2023: Firewalk (closed in 2024)
I think the "funniest" bit about this list is that Ryan/Hulst clearly picked up Bluepoint due to their area of expertise, as stated in the press release at the time of the acquisition, but then give them something beyond that scope only for it to lead to their demise. Yet, you chose to pick up Nixxes for exactly the same reason albeit a different skill-set and leave them alone to continue with that line of familiar work for them to still remain around town (although I think they need to be next on the list along with Haven).

The other thing too is that the "prints money" hoopla that was being spread around for the last few months has effectively been debunked because if they were truly "printing" money then why are we seemingly getting more studio closures and project cancellations than truly exclusive 1st party games during the PS5 generation. Simply put, it didn't move the needle but you were gaslighted into thinking it did.
 
I think it’s not completely unimaginable that Bluepoint wanted to do something other than just remaking games and that they knew a GaaS project would be far more likely to get approved than a single player game.

Now the real question is what did they do the entire last year after the GaaS game got cancelled. Did they go back to pitching other risky projects or did they pitch remakes and Sony said no? In case it’s the latter I agree Sony fucked it up.
The way I see the scenario is, Bluepoint agreed to be acquired because they had ambitions to become a premier Sony 1st party studio, they had all the technical chops. They get bought and then are voluntold that the projects they pitch that are in their wheelhouse are insufficient and wouldn't be enough RoI for Sony leadership, and to try again. Then Gavin Moore bounces (he is the creative director and long time basically studio head). Now he's off building another game dev team with himself as the CEO.
 
All respect, but there’s a high motive to chase profitable things. Do you think Bluepoint management doesn’t care about chasing big money?
This is basically what I'm talking about. The ones anticipating which projects will be profitable, and greenlighting proposals are executive teams.

If Sony decides that GAAS is the most profitable strategy (which I'm not even arguing for one way or another), it directly impacts which projects get the greenlight. Maybe Bluepoint woke up one day and decided "Golly, the thing we want to make the most is a GoW live service game." I'm not saying that's an impossibility.

What I think is far more likely is that leaders at PlayStation made it clear to studio heads and project directors that GAAS was a part of their strategic vision for the company. Wanting to meet expectations, a bunch of studios started pitching their own takes on how to live up to leadership's vision.
 
Last edited:
This is basically what I'm talking about. The ones anticipating which projects will be profitable, and greenlighting proposals are executive teams.

If Sony decides that GAAS is the most profitable strategy (which I'm not even arguing for one way or another), it directly impacts which projects get the greenlight. Maybe Bluepoint woke up one day and decided "Golly, the thing we want to make the most is a GoW live service game." I'm not saying that's not an impossibility.

What I think is far more likely is that leaders at PlayStation made it clear to studio heads and project directors that GAAS was a part of their strategic vision for the company. Wanting to meet expectations, a bunch of studios started pitching their own takes on how to live up to leadership's vision.

My point is that Sony gives a lot of leeway in terms of creative freedom, and there's countless examples of that.

I honestly don't think Sony leadership rejected a bunch of single player proposals and mandated they only work on Live Service. Just doesn't fit with their way of operating.

Likely what happened is that Bluepoint had experience helping with God of War Ragnarok, and wanted to use their expertise to take a proven IP and spin a live service out of it because their executive team thought it was easy money. Developing a Live Service game with existing assets and not a significant amount of cinematics which is out of their area of expertise.

Bluepoint has always been in a weird position in that they make great remakes but they don't really have the resources for developing a AAA single player game and all that comes with it (high end cinematics, level/combat design, etc). They likely felt pressure that their studio would buckle under that weight for a SP game, but that a Live Service title was more manageable for their studio size especially since the template/foundation work was already done by Sony Santa Monica.

So no, I don't think Sony leadership had anything at all to do with mandating live service to these smaller studios. The studio leadership teams just saw an easy path to increasing their own profitability. It's no secret that all of Bluepoint's games are not big sellers.
 
I think you're beating Yurinka as the biggest corporate bootlicker for Sony ITT and that's saying something considering who your competition is 🤣

There's no "bootlicking" at all. The news is bad. There's no spinning that its bad. But it's also one that likely was justified, and I think a lot of blame for studio failures is really down to the studios themselves. Sony's failure is probably being too hands off.

Everyone acts like Bluepoint is some angel in all of this and Hermen was solely responsible and it's just nonsense. These studios get a lot of flexibility based on their pedigree and it seems like Bluepoint had a lot of problems after many of their leadership team left once being acquired. Bluepoint was likely too top-heavy in terms of talent with a few supermen that made their projects come together.
 
There's no "bootlicking" at all. The news is bad. There's no spinning that its bad. But it's also one that likely was justified, and I think a lot of blame for studio failures is really down to the studios themselves. Sony's failure is probably being too hands off.
This is fucking stupid, Demons Souls Remake was a 90 metacritic game, you know how hard that is? For me it held up against Elden Ring, a top 5 game of the generation. You don't just flush that type of talent down the drain the minute they can't find anything in the pipe.
 
I think it’s not completely unimaginable that Bluepoint wanted to do something other than just remaking games and that they knew a GaaS project would be far more likely to get approved than a single player game.

Now the real question is what did they do the entire last year after the GaaS game got cancelled. Did they go back to pitching other risky projects or did they pitch remakes and Sony said no? In case it’s the latter I agree Sony fucked it up.

Well it turns out that Bluepoint did not have any successful pitches and were still working on one, years after their GaaS got cancelled.

Probably plays into their closure. There was no confidence that Bluepoint had any sort of viable plan.
 
Fuck PlayStation. This dog shit company at this point. Where the “live service games won’t affect single players game people at? If you are reading this … fuck you too
 
This is fucking stupid, Demons Souls Remake was a 90 metacritic game, you know how hard that is? For me it held up against Elden Ring, a top 5 game of the generation. You don't just flush that type of talent down the drain the minute they can't find anything in the pipe.

Demons Souls is an excellent remake.

But just because a team made a good product in the past, doesn't mean it's the same studio that exists to make a new product going forward. Talent already left after the acquisition that was responsible for Demons Souls, so it's questionable how much actually remained.
 
Well it turns out that Bluepoint did not have any successful pitches and were still working on one, years after their GaaS got cancelled.

Probably plays into their closure. There was no confidence that Bluepoint had any sort of viable plan.
The plan was simple. Make remakes. They tried to make them do unnecessary shit
 
Back
Top