What's new
IconEra

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Forums  ›  Gaming
Playstation 
Nothing to see here! I'm sure it was just an oversight on his end. After all we've been calling out this nonsense since last week. But a select few here are insistent we are paranoid

My problem isn’t even with mediocre reviews, that can happen to any game any dev, it’s who’s behind the reviews trashing the game in a way that is clear rage bait. The skill up guy doesn’t fool anybody, and gene park come on. The ign guy gave mixtape a 10, there’s no gameplay there.
 


Are we at the point now where we're going to downplay reviews because of a poorly AI-translated summary? Since I lived in Turkey for a bit and know a fair bit of Turkish I decided to read his review. The guy is actually a massive Wolverine fan and says he bought his PS5 precisely for this game. To be fair a lot of the review is basically him lamenting about how this game doesn't come anywhere near his lofty expectations, but beyond that he echoes the feedback we've heard everywhere: combat is alright but way too much is gated behind a skill tree, the nightmare doors are a joke, the game is too aggressive in handholding players and he personally didn't like the performances (some of it might be due to him just not being on board with the story in general). And he praised the costumes.

Cause we can do it.

Can you prove they were unjustified?

‘Sony wasted money on other games so wasting more money on Kojima is fine’ doesn’t count.

Yes it was unjustified. First of all, that argument you preemptively call out does count. In fact, it's your argument which doesn't count: "Sony is just being financially responsible". Because they obviously haven't been and continue not to be when it comes to multiple games not being made by Kojima. The bottom line basically being that Sony is anything but financially responsible with which projects they choose to back.

Secondly, every single one of Kojima's games have been profitable bar maybe DS2 (which has only been out for a year and will become profitable at some point, unlike something like Marathon which Sony is still keeping in development) and MGS is actually a franchise that was frequently in the generational top sellers on the PlayStation consoles they released on, and as an IP has outsold pretty much every Sony IP except Gran Turismo and maybe God of War. The idea that a spiritual successor to MGS would sell closer to Death Stranding 2 than any of the MGS games makes no sense at all.

Your argument is basically built on the false premise that Sony would lose hundreds of millions on this game. They will not. They did not even lose that much on DS2. But they did lose that on shit like Concord and Marathon. And will lose that much and more on a bunch of live service games they still have in the pipeline and that they will green light again in the future.

Nobody on this site was okay with what happened to Bluepoint, stop lying @Yrassinad

Lmao, you sure about that?

It took less than an hour after his initial reaction (which was in line with the same reactions people had to Physint being handed over to Xbox) to switch to finding justification: https://icon-era.com/threads/bluepoint-shut-down.19444/post-484629

To saying Bluepoint had trivial output and weren't a big deal: https://icon-era.com/threads/bluepoint-shut-down.19444/post-484669

Man you are on a really bad streak of trying to call me out, by now you should know I have receipts. Stop embarrassing yourself bootlicker.

Nothing to see here! I'm sure it was just an oversight on his end. After all we've been calling out this nonsense since last week. But a select few here are insistent we are paranoid

Yes you are paranoid. Even in his rectification he says there are a small number of QTEs with a fail state. Obviously no one plays through a game intentionally failing every QTE. They probably failed one or two by accident, realized it didn't matter at all, tried a bunch more - realized it didn't matter with those either and then assumed they all work like that. Now it turns out there are a few exceptions to the rule, which he goes out of his way to rectify, and you want to believe this is some sort of proof of your retarded conspiracy theory lol?

My problem isn’t even with mediocre reviews, that can happen to any game any dev, it’s who’s behind the reviews trashing the game in a way that is clear rage bait. The skill up guy doesn’t fool anybody, and gene park come on. The ign guy gave mixtape a 10, there’s no gameplay there.

Cool cool, can we start talking about how SkillUp's review of Saros, a game he strongly recommended is also bullshit and rage bait? Or how Gene Park giving Death Stranding 2 a 10/10 is also rage bait and fake? Why point out the "IGN guy" gave Mixtape a 10/10 to discredit him instead of saying he also gave God of War Ragnarok a 10/10?

Clearly your problem is with the mediocre reviews and not the reviewers. For some people Mixtape will be a 10/10 and Wolverine a 6/10, and for some people Wolverine will be a 10/10 and Mixtape a 6/10. It's a review. It's entirely subjective. In Wolverine's case is not like it's a very divisive game where a lot of people set on very high scores but a lot of others on very low scores like they do on something like Death Stranding 1. The consensus is just that the game is mostly ok with a few outliers rating the game noticeably higher and a few rating it noticeably lower.

This does make me wonder why these expert reviewers who do nothing but play games don’t start games at high difficulty. Oh it’s the mode most will play, uh? Ok? You aren’t most people though.

Because they are reviewing the game for other people, not for themselves. Sometimes these high difficulty settings are very poorly tuned and/or meant for NG+ only so playing the whole game on them might actually result in them getting a completely warped view of the game. Give me God of War mode turns enemies into massive health sponges for example.

Either way, it's not like they put this game on normal and review everything else on hard. They play the other games they review on normal too and came away with more favorable views. While I'll say that if you think the game is piss easy you should crank the difficulty up, this is once again a game issue and not a reviewer issue. Normal/recommended difficulty should not be tuned to basically be "baby's first video game". That's what easy is for. But some games these days are so afraid to call out their players (hence the whole relabeling of "easy mode" to "story mode" in many games) that they try to stroke their egos by making normal mode the actual easy mode and hard mode what would traditionally be seen as the normal difficulty.



He can die if you purposefully steer him into obstacles like that guy is doing. But based on the other guy's video if you just let go of the controller he will naturally bounce around between obstacles in angles that you still avoid most of them and regenerate health faster than you take damage. That being said both of these clips are kinda useless without knowing which difficulty they're on.
 
Definitely, Wolverine has suffered the hate due to PlayStation's bad decisions, and this game has paid the price for it.

Yesterday I played for 3h and it's not as bad as they make it out to be; the game seems like an absolute beast to me, and I'm not even that big of a Marvel
 
Two hours in and I’m getting convinced already that a lot of people in the media went into this ready to hate.

It has been really cool, maybe it doesn’t develop into a 9/10 or a 10/10 sure, but it’s moving like a linear action brawler with incredible production values. I thought we were sick of open world slop? Because this so far is really far from a 6/10 you gotta be trolling.
 
Two hours in and I’m getting convinced already that a lot of people in the media went into this ready to hate.

It has been really cool, maybe it doesn’t develop into a 9/10 or a 10/10 sure, but it’s moving like a linear action brawler with incredible production values. I thought we were sick of open world slop? Because this so far is really far from a 6/10 you gotta be trolling.

The 6/10 scores are utterly laughable

At its worst, if you hate linear cinematic games, this is no lower than a 7

And if you love games like Uncharted or classic God of War? This is easily a solid 8.5

And if you prefer Wolverine as a character, and prefer the more violent and grounded combat, I can see people enjoying this more than Spiderman


With all the exaggerations, hyperbole, and lies about “fart gas” and QTEs, it does seem like this game is the victim of a smear campaign by jaded reviewers that wanted to hate on this from the start
 


Dude if you're collecting cope posts at least don't include one that says he's only played 15 minutes. It's so funny how we're supposed to discard reviews because the reviewer *checks notes* once gave a "sorta recommend" to Mafia The Old Country but we're somehow supposed to take a tweet from a random nobody who says he's 15 minutes in as confirmation that the game is good.

Two hours in and I’m getting convinced already that a lot of people in the media went into this ready to hate.

It has been really cool, maybe it doesn’t develop into a 9/10 or a 10/10 sure, but it’s moving like a linear action brawler with incredible production values. I thought we were sick of open world slop? Because this so far is really far from a 6/10 you gotta be trolling.

Could it be that your tastes and expectations are different? Man I also played Control which I thought was a piece of shit game and nowhere near an 8/10 (I'd not even give it a 5/10). But I'm not gonna come up with some kind of conspiracy about how the media went in to glaze that game and give it unfair praise. I realize I'm just the outlier when it comes to that game, which is totally fine.
 
Back
Top