What's new
IconEra

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Forums  ›  Gaming
Playstation 
Why are you preemptively assuming Gears E-Day will have all the same issues as Wolverine and therefore critics need to criticize it for all the same things? That being said, Gears 5 is only sitting 6 points higher on MC and the lower reviews likewise complain that the game didn't improve much upon the existing Gears formula. There's a high chance Gears E-Day will also land in the lower 80s MC range at best, meaning it's only going to be a few points ahead of Wolverine at most.

It's crazy how insecure people are behaving over these Wolverine reviews.



007 First Light is a linear game and it was praised and has a much higher score. Just like there is a vast quality gap between something like Elden Ring and Asssassin's Creed even though both are huge open world RPGs, the same can happen with linear games. I've only managed to play 3 hours of Wolverine so far but it's already gotten repetitive. There's just not much going on with the combat and that's really all the game has going for it. The handholding issues are definitely overblown though.
And I found 007 to be one of the most overrated games this gen. Incredibly boring shootouts, gadgets and "stealth". Press a button to talk to this guy, then press it to talk to that guy, then press it again to pick up a keycard and open a door. Problem solved.

Coming from Hitman, that just drops you into a sandbox and tells you to go screw yourself, 007 felt extremely boring. Hell, Nightfire on PS2 was a better Bond game because First Light lacked Bond moments and massive setpieces.

Your whole personality shifted to being a contrarian because Sony hurt your feelings. And I mean that with respect, not as an insult. I get it, I'm in the same boat with physical and will be waiting to see what happens next gen, as opposed to buying a PS console day one. But your turning into the same jaded person as thiccgirls.
 
And I found 007 to be one of the most overrated games this gen. Incredibly boring shootouts, gadgets and "stealth". Press a button to talk to this guy, then press it to talk to that guy, then press it again to pick up a keycard and open a door. Problem solved.

Coming from Hitman, that just drops you into a sandbox and tells you to go screw yourself, 007 felt extremely boring. Hell, Nightfire on PS2 was a better Bond game because First Light lacked Bond moments and massive setpieces.

Your whole personality shifted to being a contrarian because Sony hurt your feelings. And I mean that with respect, not as an insult. I get it, I'm in the same boat with physical and will be waiting to see what happens next gen, as opposed to buying a PS console day one. But your turning into the same jaded person as thiccgirls.

Fair enough, it's not going to be for everyone. That's why 007 also has reviews only giving it a 6/10 or a 7/10. But it seems the majority of people who played it rated it higher on average. Just like there are people giving Wolverine 9/10s but they are the minority. Personally for me I enjoyed 007 more than any of the other 2026 releases I've played until this point (although that'll likely change).

Also if you're comparing to a sandbox like Hitman, you're kinda doing the same as people who are comparing Wolverine to Spider-Man games - which some posters here also have taken issue with. But again, that is totally fine. It's absolutely understandable if someone went into that game as a fan of IOI's work, expected more like it and walked away disappointed for it being diet-Uncharted meets diet-Hitman.

As for my mindset, it hasn't shifted at all beyond me not being excited for the future of PlayStation as a platform anymore. I've said this multiple times before, but here was my top 5 games this gen so far before anything happened with the disc drama and while I was frequently accused of being a Sony shill on this forum: https://icon-era.com/threads/5-year...the-best-games-youve-played.17858/post-443599 Here's me likewise before all the drama listing out my top 20: https://icon-era.com/threads/topsters-game-favorites.19651/post-492465

As you can see there's not a single Sony title in my top 5 for this gen and not a single PS4 gen or after Sony title in my top 20. You can also find me in the 2025 GOTY nominations predictions thread arguing in favor of nominating some of that year's indies like Hades 2 over DS2/Ghost of Yotei which some posters argued should take priority over indies. I like PlayStation exclusives but they're not dominating my favorite games of all time list. I think all 3 Spider-Man games were great, they are easy 8.5/10 games for me. But Wolverine thus far is nowhere near that level of quality outside of the visuals and performances and I think a 7/10 is more than a fair score for it based on what I've played thus far.

You can also find me in the Marathon thread earlier this year arguing against some of the insane cope I was seeing (I do not hate the game, I played it for 150h+ and platinumed it). I just don't like delusional fanboys of any platform, especially if they are sliding into copium territory, which is why I've also clashed with plenty of PC and Nintendo fanboys here. That's not a mindset shift, and unlike thiccgirls I'm not trying to downplay everything Sony does like refusing to believe them having GTA6 marketing rights or them ending single player PC ports.

Same thing happened with marathon. People constantly asking to stop playing.
Basement dwelling weirdos, they need to get a life. Or maybe it is there life...

People watch streamers for entertainment. If they don't find the game the streamer is playing entertaining, they will complain, even though the streamer might enjoy that game themselves. They will also complain if the streamer doesn't play a certain game they want them to play. I don't know that specific streamer but for Marathon there was probably a huge influx of people watching those streamers for their Arc Raiders gameplay who had zero interest in watching Marathon.
 
These type of linear games are definitely needed. I do think devs needs to figure out ways to get around invisible walls though. We have the hardware to allow it. But a lot of People want straight forward games now more than ever. Especially as the gaming audience continues to age up. Time is limited and every other week There's a new dad GaaS game coming out.

Stop fighting each other for consumer time and allow people to move on from game to game
 


What does this have to do with genre? There are plenty of melee action combat games that "respect the player's intelligence" just like there are braindead SRPGs that treat you with silk gloves. They're also not unrelated. These are two flagship games being released by two console platform holders in the same week. Seeing the differences in approach in terms of how much they trust the player is interesting to look at. That being said Nintendo has their own fair share of "baby's first game" style games.
 
This has been obvious to many since way before this forum was created.
Trying to convince others its not a thing lol

We will see how Gears Combat deals with repetitiveness, story and its "pacing" issues
Of course there are people with an ”anti-PlayStation agenda”. They’re called fanboys and they exist on all sides.

People on the internet also like to jump in and clown on whatever is popular to make fun of at the moment (not limited to gaming). But there isn’t some grand conspiracy in the industry to bring down PlayStation… Your perception is skewed by your echo chambers.

Metroid Prime 4 (rightfully) caught a lot of flak last year. This isn’t something that’s limited to PlayStation games.
 
Of course there are people with an ”anti-PlayStation agenda”. They’re called fanboys and they exist on all sides.

People on the internet also like to jump in and clown on whatever is popular to make fun of at the moment (not limited to gaming). But there isn’t some grand conspiracy in the industry to bring down PlayStation… Your perception is skewed by your echo chambers.

Metroid Prime 4 (rightfully) caught a lot of flak last year. This isn’t something that’s limited to PlayStation games.

People on this forum have unironically turned into the Xbox fanboys they used to mock just a year ago, except now they're doing it for PlayStation. They use the exact same talking points of review taxes against a specific company, the idea that the rival platform is paying off media outlets to smear them, the idea that only their platform gets negative articles, they'll repeat that any (bad) decision made by Sony will be copied by Nintendo/Xbox just like Xbox fanboys used to act like Sony will copy everything Xbox does and so on.
 
People on this forum have unironically turned into the Xbox fanboys they used to mock just a year ago, except now they're doing it for PlayStation. They use the exact same talking points of review taxes against a specific company, the idea that the rival platform is paying off media outlets to smear them, the idea that only their platform gets negative articles, they'll repeat that any (bad) decision made by Sony will be copied by Nintendo/Xbox just like Xbox fanboys used to act like Sony will copy everything Xbox does and so on.
Grown men getting upset because you don't like a company game or policy.
 
What does this have to do with genre? There are plenty of melee action combat games that "respect the player's intelligence" just like there are braindead SRPGs that treat you with silk gloves. They're also not unrelated. These are two flagship games being released by two console platform holders in the same week. Seeing the differences in approach in terms of how much they trust the player is interesting to look at. That being said Nintendo has their own fair share of "baby's first game" style games.
I have literally never seen a reviewer bend over backwards like this just to shoehorn a random attack on Sony. Imagine writing a review for Fire Emblem and somehow finding a way to cry about Wolverine and PlayStation. The sheer obsession is unbelievable. Unprovoked, irrelevant, and completely unprofessional. These critics aren't even trying to hide their bias anymore, using every single platform they have to run drive by hit pieces on Sony.
 
I have literally never seen a reviewer bend over backwards like this just to shoehorn a random attack on Sony. Imagine writing a review for Fire Emblem and somehow finding a way to cry about Wolverine and PlayStation. The sheer obsession is unbelievable. Unprovoked, irrelevant, and completely unprofessional. These critics aren't even trying to hide their bias anymore, using every single platform they have to run drive by hit pieces on Sony.

Yes, it's not like "Digitally Downloaded" is some sort of mainstream, well-respected outlet. It wouldn't be the first time some small fry outlet that's naturally going to have way looser editorial standards writes a review drawing things unrelated to the game into the review. Go look at how DayOne reviews Final Fantasy titles, where they shoehorn in stuff like "Xbox is the best place to play FF because it's the only console with all the titles".

Either way, a Fire Emblem review by definition cannot really function as a hit piece on Sony. The only people who are going to see this review and that line in particular are fanboys who are trying to poke holes in review outlets so they can try to damage control the review scores for Wolverine in this case. It's no different than when Xbox fanboys used to dig for stuff in reviews to defend their games after they had gotten lower-than-expected scores.
 
Can you guys lighten up and enjoy the memes at the very least?


No, they can’t. The shills already raked me over the coals for this a few days ago. Clowns like @Danja.

Apparently endless shitposts and memes dunking Xbox, Steam, or Nintendo is a-okay, but nobody can handle a little light-hearted humor at Sony’s expense. It’s cultish behavior.
 
Back
Top