What's new
IconEra

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Forums  ›  Gaming
Playstation 
I keep saying this, but most of the bad reviews were pushed by PC players, nobody can tell me otherwise.

PC players all over social media were nervous and panicking that this game would sell well, so they had to fabricate hate trains to hurt the credibility of Sony's best studios. Being butthurt over them stopping their free to pirate ports created a wave of bitter PC players which are clinging to any fake outrage.

PC players hope for nothing more than Wolverine to flop in sales because they still live in this delusion that Sony "needs" them.
can't hate a playstation game without being accused of being a PC/Xbox player.

"Everyone who disagrees with me owns an Xbox"
 
Both are trying to silence the other side. You have a lot of people who are dismissing any redeeming qualities this game has by devolving into dumb arguments about fart trails and wokeness, and you likewise have the other side dismissing any flaws the game has by virtue signaling how they're blasting off with the game.
Mostly from the positive discourse on Wolverine I've seen hasn't been about dismissing any flaws. But about nuances that reviewers neglected. Or correcting vids from bad faith actors playing the game on story mode. Rather people that felt lied to about certain aspects playing the game are speaking up and having fun with it that's a huge difference from the grifting space same coin but different side argument.
 
can't hate a playstation game without being accused of being a PC/Xbox player.

"Everyone who disagrees with me owns an Xbox"

In the mind of @Cherry420, PC gamers are a well organized and coordinated monolith whose sole goal is to intentionally trash and review bomb PlayStation games whilst simultaneously pirating said games “in the millions” and also getting bitter that Sony stopped PC ports.

Forget about touching grass; I’d just be happy if he/she touched carpet at this point.
 
Walter White GIF


For decades now my abject fear of Playstation intruded nearly every waking moment of my day.

As I fell asleep at nights, vivid images of smiling gamers laughing alongside their Playstations chased me into my dreams.

The very idea of yet another Playstation first party game being critically well received, and perhaps even more importantly the burning envy within me just grew to be too much.

So, I quit my job. Spent years honing my writing craft and making inroads into the gaming journalism landscape. While there were some good days, there were far more where I feared I would break, too weak to realize my ultimate ambitions. Yet... in those times of fragility, the intrusive thoughts would once again pervade my consciousness. A stranger enjoying a game on a platform I don't own!? The mere thought caused a fresh wave of nausia to wash over me, and I bloodied my fist against the wall to retain my sanity.

Finally, after years of perserverence, the time had finally arrived. Before me lay the glorious, yet unreleased Wolverine video game. A superior gaming experience normally impossible for one such as myself to enjoy. I wasted no time booting it up, eager to find its flaws... yet, none were to be found? The writing, the gameplay, the art direction? How could I find fault with the gaming equivalent of the Mona Lisa. In an act of desperation, I did the only thing I could. I made up some lie about the UI. Yet, even while this shook my confidence, I'd come too far in my crusade to turn my back on my goal.

With conviction, I entered in the dreadded 6/10 into the review, the lowest score ever awarded to a video game. I knew this would be the silver bullet. The proverbial "nail in the coffin" which would finally topple Playstation, granting me respite in my dreams. The plan would've worked. I would've gotten away with it too, and I'd be typing this amidst the ashes of Sony HQ which would presumably been destroyed during the aftermath of my powerful 6/10 review score. But you just had to pry. You had to dig where you shouldn't have. And now your relentless caution has put to waste a plan years in the making. I hope you're happy.
DarkLordOtaku you are a national treasure lmao
 
And I completely disagree with the notion that being positive at a game is in way bad. Fanboys are annoying, but whatever the fuck this hate parade that invades every game is far, far worse.

There is nothing wrong with being positive about a game. But when you are not actually being positive and just try to derail discussion by posting low effort shit like "I'm having a blast" and add nothing of value to the discussion, you're just a troll like any other. It's the positive equivalent of barging in and saying "I think this game is dogshit" and walking away with nothing to back up your argument.

Again, as I wrote in a previous response, if you actually explain why you are enjoying the game - especially if you also have the self awareness to acknowledge that this is your personal opinion and that others might not have the same experience - and are not just purely writing your opinion to dismiss the negative opinions about the game, no one will mock you for being positive. But when you literally say something dumb like "I don't get the hate, I'm having a blast" to dismiss criticism of the game you're just a clown and get treated like one. By saying "I don't get the hate" they just show that they didn't even bother to engage with people's criticisms and failed to consider that not everyone is like them. Yes, some people hate on it for no good reason but there are tons of legit criticisms that can be thrown at this game. Especially when people do that shit when they're 2 hours deep in the game. It makes them the toxic positive spin on the people who dismiss the whole game based on a single review or because they bounced off of it within the tutorial/opening section.

Mostly from the positive discourse on Wolverine I've seen hasn't been about dismissing any flaws. But about nuances that reviewers neglected. Or correcting vids from bad faith actors playing the game on story mode. Rather people that felt lied to about certain aspects playing the game are speaking up and having fun with it that's a huge difference from the grifting space same coin but different side argument.

The "I'm having a blast" people that @voke is talking about that are being relentlessly mocked on Reddit are not like those people. They are not saying anything nuanced, they are just virtue signaling and trying to play tug of war with online haters. It's why you also have people making fun of the people who post shit like "I'm a dad who works 60 hours a week with only 4 hours of game time and I love X game", by memeing it with ever-increasing amount of kids, wives and work hours and ever-decreasing game time, because those people completely lack the self awareness that not everyone is like them and that it doesn't make the criticisms by people who are not in their shoes any less valid.

The people you are talking about, who are actually trying to be nuanced even if they lean positively, are not being mocked aside by maybe the most deranged haters. You can write "I don't think the handholding/scent trail issue is that bad - here's why" with an explanation. That's a world of difference from "I don't get the criticism". I can get other people's criticism without agreeing with it. After having played the game, I can say the scent trail doesn't really bother me at all. But I can understand why it bothers others.

The game has only been out for 3 days and takes on average 15-20h to complete. I think it's safe to say a lot of the people who feel the need to announce they're feeling positive about the game haven't even rolled credits yet and fail to understand that many of the reviewers might've felt like them too at the same amount of playtime before souring on the experience by the end.
 
8.5 for me so far (nearly finished the game)

This game is legitimately better than all the Sony openworld games imo. The combat is really good.

The metacritic score is fine, but the grifters and hatemob thinking it's a bad game are out of their mind.

The metacritic should be much higher, closer to mid to high 80s, if reviewers were honest and judged it on the same level as Capcom or 007 as recent examples.

People saying there is no double standard here are utterly insane. The amount of 6's from big outlets really did a disservice to this game. And somehow all these nitpicky, frankly extremely benign issues somehow come to the surface as an enormous blight against gaming. Fuck off, trash like Skill Up.
 
PC gamers are a well organized and coordinated monolith whose sole goal is to intentionally trash and review bomb PlayStation games whilst simultaneously pirating said games “in the millions” and also getting bitter that Sony stopped PC ports.
It's projection. Almost every single one of their posts here is a gigantic inferiority complex against PC, so PC players must have a massive inferiority complex against Playstation.

They've freaking deluded themself into thinking one of the most legendary and foundational console brands for 30+ years is a poor smol underdog getting bullied by big media and big PC gaming. Completely buck broken by reddit PCMR troll posts.
 
Last edited:
The metacritic should be much higher, closer to mid to high 80s, if reviewers were honest and judged it on the same level as Capcom or 007 as recent examples.

People saying there is no double standard here are utterly insane. The amount of 6's from big outlets really did a disservice to this game. And somehow all these nitpicky, frankly extremely benign issues somehow come to the surface as an enormous blight against gaming. Fuck off, trash like Skill Up.

Where's your outrage for the outlets that gave it a 9 or 10? You can't have your cake and eat it too. If you want to dismiss the substantially lower reviews you should dismiss the substantially higher reviews too.

Also this game is absolutely not a mid-to-high 80s game lol, pass me some of what you are smoking. Reviewers were honest and the Capcom games and 007 were just better games. And I say this as someone who personally thinks RE Requiem and Pragmata ARE overrated. I actually like Wolverine more than Pragmata, but the scores both have gotten are totally fair.

Hell, two can play that game. GOGconnected, one of the outlets that gave Wolverine a 10/10, gave 007 First Light 8.5/10. If they are supposed to be held to the same standards, then GOGconnected reviewed 007 with a double standard.
 
I don't have outrage for outlets that give it a 9 or a 10. I can see the game getting a 9 or a 10, it's personally a 9 for me. I can also see a few outlets maybe giving it a 7 if they are not a fan of the genre, settling in the mid to high 80s overall

The idea that it's a 6 is completely absurd
 
The idea that it's a 6 is completely absurd
what is a 6 to you? it's still quite above average. high 70s is a good place for this game to settle.
You should try to convince people that it's a high-scoring game rather than just get upset because other people (who've played the game) are sharing their opinion. Not every game you like is gonna be some critically acclaimed masterpiece in the eyes of the public
 
I don't have outrage for outlets that give it a 9 or a 10. I can see the game getting a 9 or a 10, it's personally a 9 for me. I can also see a few outlets maybe giving it a 7 if they are not a fan of the genre, settling in the mid to high 80s overall

The idea that it's a 6 is completely absurd

You can see someone giving it a 10 but not a 6? Lol. Basically your line of thinking is "my opinion is the only correct one and I don't mind people being even more positive but I somehow take issue with people who are more negative".

Giving this game a 9, let alone a 10 is equally absurd as giving it a 6 imho. I can understand someone giving this a 6 far more than someone giving it a 10 (literally a near flawless game). That being said these are all opinions and even though I would never in a 1000 years give this a 10/10, I can understand other people view things differently and their opinion is not worth less or more than mine. You should learn to do the same and just accept those 6/10s for what they are: someone else's opinion. And in the end that means the aggregate ends up between a 7 and 8.

what is a 6 to you? it's still quite above average. high 70s is a good place for this game to settle.
You should try to convince people that it's a high-scoring game rather than just get upset because other people (who've played the game) are sharing their opinion. Not every game you like is gonna be some critically acclaimed masterpiece in the eyes of the public

He can understand people giving this a 10/10 somehow. If this game is a 10/10 what does that make games like RDR2, GoW2018 or Ocarina of Time? A 14/10? Or are those better games and therefore this game shouldn't be anywhere near a 10/10?
 
A 10/10 doesn't mean you need to be RDR2. If that were the case, hardly anything would get 10/10 scores.

All it needs to do is be an exceptional title in the genre. And as far as superhero games go, it is exceptional. The combat is the best I've seen in the genre, the visual productions are also outstanding and completely sell the authentic Wolverine experience.
 
High 70s is fine if that's the standard for a game like this, then I can literally list tons of games that deserve to be that range this year that were instead given much higher scores.

Again, has it occurred to you that scores are opinions and you are holding outlier opinions when it's coming to all of these games?

A 10/10 doesn't mean you need to be RDR2. If that were the case, hardly anything would get 10/10 scores.

All it needs to do is be an exceptional title in the genre. And as far as superhero games go, it is exceptional. The combat is the best I've seen in the genre, the visual productions are also outstanding and completely sell the authentic Wolverine experience.

If a game like RDR2 and a game like Wolverine both get a 10/10, then 10/10 means fuck all. There is a massive gap in scope, ambition and quality between those games in favor of the former. Giving them the same score makes zero sense outside of, like I already explained, accounting for the fact that reviews are nothing more than people's opinions that don't have to make any sense objectively.

Even by your standards of it "just needing to be an exceptional title in the genre", I do not understand how anyone can classify Wolverine as such. It's nowhere near an exceptional action combat game, there are far better action combat games. And even among the Arkham free flow combat superhero games, this game has worse combat than all 3 Spider-Man games, where combat isn't even the focus of the game, and those games already had worse combat than the Batman Arkham games.

I've played every AAA superhero game release this gen (Miles Morales, GotG, Spider-Man 2, Suicide Squad, Midnight Suns, Wolverine) and this one is only better than Suicide Squad.
 
Again, has it occurred to you that scores are opinions and you are holding outlier opinions when it's coming to all of these games?

Nope. They are subject to the personal bias against Sony for no disc no buy, timing of the Kojima announcements, etc, etc. That negativity is going to bleed over into reviews

If a game like RDR2 and a game like Wolverine both get a 10/10, then 10/10 means fuck all.

RE9 also got 10s, does that mean a 10/10 means fuck all? Is RE9 RDR2? This argument is dumb. Everyone is going to have their personal threshold for what a 10 is and represents. Where it matters is in the aggregate.
 
Back
Top