What's new
IconEra

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Forums  ›  Gaming
Playstation 
It’s not going to sell very well IMO. At first I thought it would regardless, but I had a dinner with family last weekend, and both of my casual inlaws mentioned how bad it apparently was. Neither of them played it as a result. And one is a huge marvel guy.

The hate storm on the internet chopped the legs. It definitely hit the casuals.

The hate parades have hit critical mass…. I don’t think Wolverine deserved it but here we are. Hope insomniac can get back on their feet. They went from “carrying the PS5” to suddenly as hated as Naughty Dog.

They will repeat this for every game. This isnt new but they done a good job of it lol
They tried with TLOU2 and others
 
Comparing chart positions to Yotei doesn't really make any sense.

If you compare it all the games released in this packed month of new releases, then it's easily the best selling game, and will likely have even better legs too.

The only things that are higher in the charts are the usual crop of live service games.

It managed to sell well with a 77 meta and the most aggressive hater campaign I've seen in quite some time.
 
Only a pathetic creature with a chip on your shoulder like you would use this shit to gauge sales and success of a game.

My point still stands.

What position a game has held in the charts and for how long means fuck all when it comes to gauging actual sales.

A game could sell 2 million in its first week and go 1st in the charts then the next week sell nothing and drop out.

On the other hand you could get a game which sells 1 million in its first week and go 1st in the charts then sell 500k the next week and stay in the Top 10.

What has sold more?

I’m out arguing in favour or against Wolverine. We saw the same sales flop discourse when Yotei was released. We all know how that turned out.

Now Yotei is being used as a yardstick for success. Go figure.

Let’s wait for the sales figures to come out.

Lmao, it's so funny to see losers like you and James take comments about the sales performance of this game so personally. Yes sales position doesn't say much about sales numbers because it's all relative. However, we are comparing two relative data points to each other here so it's already a little less relative. The idea that Wolverine somehow faced steeper competition within these past 3 weeks than Ghost of Yotei did within 2 months of its launch is laughable.

Where were you when people were jerking off about Wolverine going up in positions in the sales charts between the reviews dropping and the game actually releasing? Didn't feel the need to lecture people about how it said nothing about the actual performance of the game? Didn't feel the need to tell people to "wait for sales figures to come out"?

It’s over 210M in revenue in a few weeks

But continue doom mongering

Physical games is dead and Wolverine will a doing fine

Lmao, surely Sony dropped $300m+ on this game so it could perform worse than GoW2018 did for $200m at most on an install base 80% the size.

Let's not do this whole back and forth again. Earlier this year you were also coping about Marathon and trying to spin its commercial performance into something positive or argue that it was doing "fine". We all saw how that turned out. It's obvious you have zero objectivity when it comes to gauging the performance of PlayStation games because you're a deranged fanboy.

Wolverine will make a profit when all is said and done but it's obvious this game isn't meeting any expectations.

Also physical games aren't dead, because contrary to your retarded theories Sony is not the arbiter of the existence of physical games. They'll continue well beyond 2028, just not on PlayStation.

They will repeat this for every game. This isnt new but they done a good job of it lol
They tried with TLOU2 and others

If Wolverine was a better game it wouldn't have worked. This is how Ghost of Yotei managed to weather the storm while this game seems to be buckling under it.

Comparing chart positions to Yotei doesn't really make any sense.

If you compare it all the games released in this packed month of new releases, then it's easily the best selling game, and will likely have even better legs too.

The only things that are higher in the charts are the usual crop of live service games.

It managed to sell well with a 77 meta and the most aggressive hater campaign I've seen in quite some time.

The legs are falling out already, what are you talking about? Just because it outperformed other titles released in this month doesn't mean its performance is praiseworthy. Since when did the barometer for success of a game become "did it win its launch month"? Every big game wins its launch month. A $300m Marvel AAA game made by a Sony first party outselling a new Onimusha, Ace Combat and Silent Hill, series which have never broken 10m in sales on any entry, is not something to be proud of.

People are comparing it to Yotei because it shows how Yotei held its positions for much longer, showing the game had some staying power. Yes maybe Yotei had less competing releases in the immediate weeks around it - but as you can see it held top 18 for far longer than Wolverine did despite titles like Battlefield 6, Arc Raiders and Black Ops 7 dropping in that window.
 
Wolverine
Screenshot_20261007-154849.webp


Yotei
Screenshot_20261007-154834.webp
 
200M inflation adjusted in 2018 is close to 300M today.

And games don’t stop selling after the first few weeks on the market….did you know that?

$200m inflation adjusted is higher than $200m but not "close to $300m". And it's not like the developers and actors were working on this game pro bono and suddenly got 6-years worth of salary the moment the game launched. A lot of that budget was paid before inflation. There's a reason Insomniac themselves were questioning whether the customers can actually see the fact that Spider-Man 2 cost that much more than the previous games. If they were like you they'd just cope it away by saying "it's inflation lol, so it's actually the same".

And yes obviously games don't stop selling after the first few weeks. But that doesn't matter. I was comparing it to GoW2018 which seemingly sold in its first weekend the same amount of sales that this game has taken 3+ weeks to reach. On a smaller budget, on a smaller install base, with a lesser known IP that also doesn't take a % cut on every unit sale of the game. And it's not like Wolverine is going to sell faster post launch than it did during launch with this word of mouth behind it.
 
$200m inflation adjusted is higher than $200m but not "close to $300m". And it's not like the developers and actors were working on this game pro bono and suddenly got 6-years worth of salary the moment the game launched. A lot of that budget was paid before inflation. There's a reason Insomniac themselves were questioning whether the customers can actually see the fact that Spider-Man 2 cost that much more than the previous games. If they were like you they'd just cope it away by saying "it's inflation lol, so it's actually the same".

And yes obviously games don't stop selling after the first few weeks. But that doesn't matter. I was comparing it to GoW2018 which seemingly sold in its first weekend the same amount of sales that this game has taken 3+ weeks to reach. On a smaller budget, on a smaller install base, with a lesser known IP that also doesn't take a % cut on every unit sale of the game. And it's not like Wolverine is going to sell faster post launch than it did during launch with this word of mouth behind it.

270M is close to 300M and we don’t have official budget data for any of these games

GoW2018 was a massive success, why is that the expected outcome? Sony has a range of acceptable outcomes. Not all of them are going to be the peak hits
 
270M is close to 300M and we don’t have official budget data for any of these games

GoW2018 was a massive success, why is that the expected outcome? Sony has a range of acceptable outcomes. Not all of them are going to be the peak hits
Bro just give it up. Wolverine is a critical failure and won't live up to sales expectations. It is what it is. No arguing will change that.

Insomniac will be okay. They have evergreen titles that brings them plenty of money. And look at the bright side, they are going to swing much harder in their next release.
 
Bro just give it up. Wolverine is a critical failure and won't live up to sales expectations. It is what it is. No arguing will change that.

Insomniac will be okay. They have evergreen titles that brings them plenty of money. And look at the bright side, they are going to swing much harder in their next release.

A critical failure doesn’t make it a commercial failure.

For all your talk of “bad discourse” you sure are presumptive on drawing conclusions here. And the game being a critical failure doesn’t mean the fans see it that way

The game has likely clawed back most of its budget already, with everything going forward being profit
 
A critical failure doesn’t make it a commercial failure.

For all your talk of “bad discourse” you sure are presumptive on drawing conclusions here. And the game being a critical failure doesn’t mean the fans see it that way

The game has likely clawed back most of its budget already, with everything going forward being profit
& maybe it has. I'm just telling you because nothing you say will change anybody's mind here.

I don't think acknowledging the truth is bad discourse. I think the endless trolling, and dooming is.
 
270M is close to 300M and we don’t have official budget data for any of these games

GoW2018 was a massive success, why is that the expected outcome? Sony has a range of acceptable outcomes. Not all of them are going to be the peak hits

Yeah except like I said it won't be $270m anyway because GoW was in development years before 2018 just like Wolverine was in development years before 2026. Taking their release years, and then taking their budgets and running it through an inflation calculator makes no sense because that's not how these budgets are spent and how inflation works. There was a lot of inflation in recent years. If you're going to use inflation as an argument, Wolverine's budget is likely a lot higher than $300m too when adjusted for inflation.

As for why GoW2018 would be the expected outcome? Because if it wasn't they wouldn't be dropping such a high budget on it? Why do you think Ghost of Yotei was made for a much lower budget than Spider-Man or one of Naughty Dog's games? Because the sales expectations are lower. The higher the budget on a game, the higher the expectations. If you wanna follow your "inflation means these games cost almost the same" logic, which is wrong, you'd assume that expectations are going to be comparable too. Especially considering this game is backed by an IP that's more popular than GoW was in 2018, is launching on a higher install base, is launching in a quarter that traditionally sees higher sales, is coming off the back of 3 mega popular Spider-Man games by the same studio, needs to sell even more copies because Marvel is taking a % cut on each copy sold etc.

I never said Wolverine falls outside of the range of acceptable outcomes. I'm saying the expectations are obviously going to be higher than what it has achieved so far.

A critical failure doesn’t make it a commercial failure.

For all your talk of “bad discourse” you sure are presumptive on drawing conclusions here. And the game being a critical failure doesn’t mean the fans see it that way

The game has likely clawed back most of its budget already, with everything going forward being profit

No one on this board is saying the game is a commercial failure. This is your own insecurity projecting. Not meeting expectations =/= commercial failure. I have repeatedly said the game will be profitable and sell enough to not end the Marvel contract.

And yeah, a fan of something is always going to be positive. This is such an illogical metric to use. The game wasn't only played by fans, and wasn't designed to only appeal to fans. It was designed to create fans and it doesn't look like it did a very good job at it because the word of mouth isn't very good and the game seems to be disappearing from the charts already.
 
Yeah except like I said it won't be $270m anyway because GoW was in development years before 2018 just like Wolverine was in development years before 2026. Taking their release years, and then taking their budgets and running it through an inflation calculator makes no sense because that's not how these budgets are spent and how inflation works. There was a lot of inflation in recent years. If you're going to use inflation as an argument, Wolverine's budget is likely a lot higher than $300m too when adjusted for inflation.

As for why GoW2018 would be the expected outcome? Because if it wasn't they wouldn't be dropping such a high budget on it? Why do you think Ghost of Yotei was made for a much lower budget than Spider-Man or one of Naughty Dog's games? Because the sales expectations are lower. The higher the budget on a game, the higher the expectations. If you wanna follow your "inflation means these games cost almost the same" logic, which is wrong, you'd assume that expectations are going to be comparable too. Especially considering this game is backed by an IP that's more popular than GoW was in 2018, is launching on a higher install base, is launching in a quarter that traditionally sees higher sales, is coming off the back of 3 mega popular Spider-Man games by the same studio, needs to sell even more copies because Marvel is taking a % cut on each copy sold etc.

I never said Wolverine falls outside of the range of acceptable outcomes. I'm saying the expectations are obviously going to be higher than what it has achieved so far.



No one on this board is saying the game is a commercial failure. This is your own insecurity projecting. Not meeting expectations =/= commercial failure. I have repeatedly said the game will be profitable and sell enough to not end the Marvel contract.

And yeah, a fan of something is always going to be positive. This is such an illogical metric to use. The game wasn't only played by fans, and wasn't designed to only appeal to fans. It was designed to create fans and it doesn't look like it did a very good job at it because the word of mouth isn't very good and the game seems to be disappearing from the charts already.

We don’t know the budgets. I’m simply using 200M in 2018 and adjusting to 2026 dollars. It does not need to be more complicated than that if we’re just spit balling estimates without any known facts

You can drop $300M on a game, generate 330M in revenue, receive a 30M profit (10% margin) and be in line with industry estimates. Of course this ignores marvel profit sharing, which we don’t know about, but the threshold for Wolverine being an adequate success are going to be met, even if it’s not a mind blowing GoW style success

Would it be great to get more? Sure. That’s not what we’re arguing though
 
Screenshot_20261008-132952.webp


This game outright failed. It had a strong start, but then dropped like a rock, and it was not the actual reviews that ruined it, but a coordinated smear campaign. Everyone loves to dismiss social media outrage as just a vocal internet minority that does not matter in the real world. That is complete denial because this targeted hate clearly bleeds into real life sales and actively kills a game's momentum.
 
We don’t know the budgets. I’m simply using 200M in 2018 and adjusting to 2026 dollars. It does not need to be more complicated than that if we’re just spit balling estimates without any known facts

You can drop $300M on a game, generate 330M in revenue, receive a 30M profit (10% margin) and be in line with industry estimates. Of course this ignores marvel profit sharing, which we don’t know about, but the threshold for Wolverine being an adequate success are going to be met, even if it’s not a mind blowing GoW style success

Would it be great to get more? Sure. That’s not what we’re arguing though

Yes but that is not how inflation works in relation to game budgets. The development budget is not a lump sump that is paid out when the game releases, it's something that is paid over the course of development which starts years before it actually comes out. Much of Wolverine's budget was paid before 2026 when inflation was lower.

Also we do know about budgets, we know TLOU Part 2 and Horizon FW were around 200m. GoW2018 was probably slightly less than that. Either way nowhere near $305m, which is the budget for Wolverine based on the Insomniac leaks. Funnily enough according to that presentation they expected 10.5m lifetime sales on Spider-Man 2 and 10m on Wolverine, with Wolverine being the more profitable title. And the same slide also said they need to sell 5m copies of Wolverine to even break even, which I think is safe to say it hasn't achieved yet. Looks like they overestimated Wolverine and underestimated SM2 (I'm guessing those estimates were based on the fact that SM2 would be launching into an install base of 50m while Wolverine would be launching into one twice the size).

Also 10% margins are not "in line with industry estimates" lol. No one is going to gamble $300m on a video game to make 10% returns. Sony could just invest their money in the S&P500 instead and make more lmao. You are looking at a minimum of 30% or more before any game is considered an "adequate success".

View attachment 9428

This game outright failed. It had a strong start, but then dropped like a rock, and it was not the actual reviews that ruined it, but a coordinated smear campaign. Everyone loves to dismiss social media outrage as just a vocal internet minority that does not matter in the real world. That is complete denial because this targeted hate clearly bleeds into real life sales and actively kills a game's momentum.

Smear campaigns don't work on games that review well. Just look at Ghost of Yotei. Every problem this game is facing stems from the fact that it's just nothing special and nowhere near the level of quality people expect from AAA first party blockbuster titles.
 
View attachment 9428

This game outright failed. It had a strong start, but then dropped like a rock, and it was not the actual reviews that ruined it, but a coordinated smear campaign. Everyone loves to dismiss social media outrage as just a vocal internet minority that does not matter in the real world. That is complete denial because this targeted hate clearly bleeds into real life sales and actively kills a game's momentum.
Then Sony better be ready for this being a regular occurrence going forward….
 
View attachment 9428

This game outright failed. It had a strong start, but then dropped like a rock, and it was not the actual reviews that ruined it, but a coordinated smear campaign. Everyone loves to dismiss social media outrage as just a vocal internet minority that does not matter in the real world. That is complete denial because this targeted hate clearly bleeds into real life sales and actively kills a game's momentum.
They had more people in their corner before, fighting for them... Not so sure now.
 
Smear campaigns don't work on games that review well. Just look at Ghost of Yotei. Every problem this game is facing stems from the fact that it's just nothing special and nowhere near the level of quality people expect from AAA first party blockbuster titles.
The hate Yotei received was literally a fart in the wind compared to Wolverine. Trying to pretend both games faced the same level of coordinated outrage is completely bad faith. Wolverine got hit with a relentless smear campaign that went far beyond typical internet noise.
 
Back
Top