What's new
IconEra

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Forums  ›  Gaming
Playstation 
They had more people in their corner before, fighting for them... Not so sure now.

Yes, I disagree strongly with the idea that professional reviewers somehow docked the game's scores over drama surrounding Sony. But the fans on the outside definitely will feel less inclined to defend and spread positivity about PlayStation and its games following their recent actions. So in that sense it has affected the game's word of mouth.

The hate Yotei received was literally a fart in the wind compared to Wolverine. Trying to pretend both games faced the same level of coordinated outrage is completely bad faith. Wolverine got hit with a relentless smear campaign that went far beyond typical internet noise.

Yes because Ghost of Yotei was a much better game that reviewed substantially better which quickly ended the chances of any smear campaign succeeding. If Ghost of Yotei had been a 7/10 game as well it would've gone through exactly the same thing.

These days almost every game is targeted by grifters, there are literally no exceptions anymore. The difference is that many games are just good enough to drown out that noise and therefore walk out unscathed.
 
View attachment 9428

This game outright failed. It had a strong start, but then dropped like a rock, and it was not the actual reviews that ruined it, but a coordinated smear campaign. Everyone loves to dismiss social media outrage as just a vocal internet minority that does not matter in the real world. That is complete denial because this targeted hate clearly bleeds into real life sales and actively kills a game's momentum.

Social media is too damn big today not to matter. It's why the physical media backlash is important and trashing every post and YouTube video will have some type of outcome.

Sony is lucky God of War Laufey has that brand name associated with it.
 
Their Wolverine sales estimates are only the first two weeks of sales. I do think they are low balling it's little but the sales are definitely on the lower side.
 
With that said... remember these trackers also had Yōtei almost 800k below where it was selling before Sony put an end to that nonsense.
 
User review tracking. Gimme a fucking break. That’s how the Yurinka AI estimates 3 million for marathon still to this day

How about I point out the obvious? Console warriors will user submit whatever they can to bullshit the position of their first party branded games. Especially on home turf.

Not reliable data for sales.
 
Yes but that is not how inflation works in relation to game budgets. The development budget is not a lump sump that is paid out when the game releases, it's something that is paid over the course of development which starts years before it actually comes out. Much of Wolverine's budget was paid before 2026 when inflation was lower.

It doesn’t matter

If you add up the entire cost of development from year 0 to year 5 of development ending in 2018 dollars it should roughly equate to year 0 to year 5 in 2026 after you inflation adjust (assuming similar headcounts)
 
Makes zero sense based on review tracking

You can't be making this shit up. Professional firm that literally sells this data for money is wrong but "review tracking" is now an accurate measurement tool? Weren't you guys all shitting on Alinea for months because they base their estimates partially on reviews?

Wolverine likely received a healthy dose of reverse review bombing on the PS Store by people who felt like they had to "push back" against the negativity online. Basing sales numbers off of that by extrapolating from reviews on other games that launched in a neutral climate makes no sense.

It doesn’t matter

If you add up the entire cost of development from year 0 to year 5 of development ending in 2018 dollars it should roughly equate to year 0 to year 5 in 2026 after you inflation adjust (assuming similar headcounts)

No it doesn't because the inflation hasn't been going up in a linear fashion. Between 2021 and 2026 it inflation was like 4%+ per year.

If we assume the dev budget was equally spread out across 5 years of development prior to launch you get the following:

GoW2018 - $200m budget (was likely lower than that considering Spider-Man 1 was made for under $100m in the same year but w/e) so $40m between 2013-2017, becomes $281m when adjusted for inflation

Wolverine - $305m budget so $61m between 2021-2025, becomes $340m when adjusted for inflation

So the game was 20% more expensive to make even when you adjust for inflation. While likely already inflating the dev budget for GoW2018. And this is before even including the Marvel licensing royalty fees which means every copy sold is making them less money than it did for GoW2018. So yeah, I don't think it's unreasonable to assume Sony would expect at least GoW2018 performance or better considering it also has a 25% bigger install base to work with.

Leaks are leaks. They are a snapshot of a forecast that is subject to change. They do not represent actuals.

Budget and scope could have been cut due to shifting priorities

Either way, 200M in 2018 is close to 300M in 2026

Ah_Shit%2C_Here_We_Go_Again.jpg


Here we go again with the copium downplaying of the development budget much like you did with Marathon after launch results were underwhelming. And then we all found out that half of Bungie (300-400 developers) had in fact been working on the game when they laid off the half of the company that wasn't working on it.

Yes, the budget likely INCREASED if anything because the game was supposed to come out in 2025 according to those leaks. So they had a full year of development on top of it. And all the zones we ended up with in the game were already in the leaked draft for the game, nothing was cut out there. The only thing that was possibly cut were additional playable characters and more free roam gameplay. And as I already explained there is no "$300m in 2026", because developers got paid over the course of development and that number would also need to be adjusted for inflation.
 
Back
Top