Stellar Blade’s uncensored release in Japan prompts criticism. Addresses censorship claims. |UP| Petition at 50,000.

Gamernyc78

MuscleMod
Moderating
28 Jun 2022
18,554
15,487

Shift Up’s Stellar Blade is scheduled to launch on April 26. With the release date approaching, the Stellar Blade official X account has announced that the game will be uncensored in all regions, including Japan. Stellar Blade will be released in Japan with a CERO D (17+) rating and no content restrictions – a decision that has raised questions among industry professionals about the CERO rating system’s consistency.

While Stellar Blade’s Japan release has earned a 17+ rating with content descriptors for Sexual Content and Violence, it appears the game will be released without any censorship. The game’s sexual aspects, such as the heroine’s carefully crafted rear view and provocative costumes, have been talked about ever since the game was announced, but Stellar Blade also includes some rather gory depictions (as far as the demo reveals). For example, one cutscene depicts the cross-section of a character’s severed arm, and mangled bodies of humanoid enemies can also be spotted.

20240422-29912-001.jpg


Post translation: What’s going on CERO? The Stellar Blade’s demo was really fun and absolutely action-packed. However, CERO, you denied our Dead Space a rating because it included cross-sections of severed body parts and internal organs, but here we have both cross-sections and insides on display passed off with a CERO D rating. I find this hard to accept…

The disparity between Stellar Blade’s gore and its CERO D rating has prompted a response from Electronic Arts Japan’s General Manager Shaun Noguchi. While Noguchi offers nothing but praise for Stellar Blade itself (even encouraging people to buy it), he questions the CERO rating system and its apparent inconsistency. He mentions that EA’s Dead Space (released in January 2023) was denied a CERO rating due to “depictions of cross-sections of severed body parts and internal organs.” As video games cannot be released on consoles (physically) in Japan without a CERO rating, the initially planned console releases of Dead Space were cancelled, and the game could only be released on PC in the country.

Noguchi’s words indicate that Dead Space was not even eligible for a CERO Z (18+) rating, while Stellar Blade received the lower CERO D rating even though it contains depictions similar to what Dead Space was rejected for. Again, Noguchi stresses that he has no intention to criticize Stellar Blade, but rather to express his dissatisfaction with Japan’s ambiguous rating process for console games.

As mentioned previously, console games in Japan can only be released after having been reviewed and assigned a rating by the appropriate organization. For physical releases, publishers are more or less obligated to request a review from the Japan-based CERO. For digital-only titles, publishers also have the option of requesting a rating from the overseas-based IARC, but there are exceptions.

20240422-290587-001.jpg



Starting March 2022, the Japanese PlayStation Store started accepting IARC ratings in addition to the existing CERO ratings for digital-only releases (Related article). On the other hand, titles intended for ages 18 and older still require a CERO rating. In other words, SIE still requires the acquisition of a CERO rating for physical and digital sales of games that are rated 18 or older under the IARC generic rating.

As was the case with the previously mentioned Dead Space, CERO rating-related troubles have led to publishers making big changes to their sales plans. One example is the 2022 sci-fi horror The Callisto Protocol, which had its Japanese release cancelled for failing to obtain a CERO rating (Related article). The title never made it to consoles or PC in Japan.

Under current circumstances, distributors can be forced to change their plans drastically or cancel a release entirely depending on CERO’s decision, especially if their game contains some form of explicit content. In his thread on X, Noguchi comments that many titles have been victims of CERO’s “vague” review process. He hopes for the introduction of a more transparent system and criteria, such as a checklist or point system.

20240422-290587-002.jpg



According to CERO’s official website, their reviewers are recruited from the general public and consist of men and women in their 20s to 60s from various occupations. After undergoing training by CERO, they examine content based on a list of 27 items subject to review. Each item on the list has its upper limit, and depictions that exceed the tolerated range are designated as “banned expressions.” Games found to contain banned expressions are denied a CERO rating. Based on what Noguchi is saying, it seems CERO does not communicate clearly to manufacturers about what exactly these upper limits are, resulting in an ambiguous rating process.

EA Japan exec criticises Japanese rating board for banning Dead Space, but passing Stellar Blade.​


 
Last edited:
  • Informative
Reactions: Zzero

Yurinka

Veteran
VIP
21 Jun 2022
5,830
5,032
Well, I think they may have played it smartly: regarding nudity, they can say that she isn't nude, but instead has a fully covered costume. And/or say she is a robot/cyborg instead of a human.

Regarding gory violence, for age rating systems of at least the ones I know it isn't the same violence against humans than against robots and monsters. In this case, they can say the "humans" that suffer it are robots or cyborgs, getting an easier pass.
 

ToTTenTranz

Well-known member
Icon Extra
4 Aug 2023
431
480
IMO Japan needs an urgent reform to their classification standards.

The Cero rating should apply for everything that is legal, be it nudity, sex or violence. Their law about censoring genitals doesn't make any sense if the content is rated for adults.
Their relationship with kiddie porn is also weird as fuck. Last year they (finally) raised the age of consent from 13 to 16 years old, but their whole market of sex toys and content around pedo/hebephilia is fucking scary IMO.
 
OP
OP
Gamernyc78

Gamernyc78

MuscleMod
Moderating
28 Jun 2022
18,554
15,487
IMO Japan needs an urgent reform to their classification standards.

The Cero rating should apply for everything that is legal, be it nudity, sex or violence. Their law about censoring genitals doesn't make any sense if the content is rated for adults.
Their relationship with kiddie porn is also weird as fuck. Last year they (finally) raised the age of consent from 13 to 16 years old, but their whole market of sex toys and content around pedo/hebephilia is fucking scary IMO.
Alot of wtf 🤔 moments.
 

Airbus

Veteran
30 Jun 2022
1,718
1,547
In Asia, what's considered good and bad in the west is flipped around.

East: Gore bad, Nudity good unless it's CERO C.

West: Nudity bad, Gore good unless it's M-rated.

That's neverminding to certain "moral panic" controversies that happened before ESRB and CERO's creations.
 

Zzero

Major Tom
9 Jan 2023
3,163
1,933
In Asia, what's considered good and bad in the west is flipped around.

East: Gore bad, Nudity good unless it's CERO C.

West: Nudity bad, Gore good unless it's M-rated.

That's neverminding to certain "moral panic" controversies that happened before ESRB and CERO's creations.
Japan has had a fair share of its own moral panics, they can get away with a lot less now than they did preY2K.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gamernyc78

John Elden Ring

The Thread Maker
Content Creator
5 Jul 2022
4,740
5,445
United States


Understandably we also recognize about this issue.
However the final costume we wanted to show you is indeed the costume in version 1.0.0.2.
I want to clarify that is our final product.
However I know this answer is not enough to convince our user.
There is an internal discussion ongoing regarding this so I think we'll have a chance to answer it soon.



Reported censorship for the day one patch include clothing and gore



zN7KkxC.png

stellar-patch-small.png


CKdBFiw.jpeg
4a4tLss.jpeg

 
Last edited:

Eternal_Wings

Dein Nomos
24 Jun 2022
2,136
2,780
Well, well. This is the genius of your so competent and brilliant western lords. 😭😂
 
Last edited:

anonpuffs

Veteran
Icon Extra
29 Nov 2022
8,115
9,315
I legit couldn't tell any difference in the reduction of gore pics until i looked at the amount of blood on her outfit

To me that's a non issue, reduction of gore would only be something i noticed if they made the attacks less bloody (doesn't look like it) or reduced/removed dismemberment type stuff
 
  • brain
Reactions: The Icon

Gods&Monsters

Veteran
Icon Extra
21 Jun 2022
4,414
9,003
Did Sony really censor the outfits? I thought it was just another version of the same suit.

This game can't catch a break from controversy like all the latest Sony exclusives. This is what happens when you're starving on other platforms 🙄
 

voke

Veteran
10 Jan 2023
841
1,214
Did Sony really censor the outfits? I thought it was just another version of the same suit.

This game can't catch a break from controversy like all the latest Sony exclusives. This is what happens when you're starving on other platforms 🙄
Yeah they gave her a Tshirt, and in another one they added leggings. Also reduced blood splatter.

Imma be honest, those who are getting mad about this really need to touch grass.
 

Gediminas

Boy...
Founder
21 Jun 2022
5,416
6,880
Yeah they gave her a Tshirt, and in another one they added leggings. Also reduced blood splatter.

Imma be honest, those who are getting mad about this really need to touch grass.
I am looking simple at this, if it was the version we got, it would be fine. But clearly it isn't. They censores 18+ game which is clearly moronic.
Just make a game and stand firm, no apologies, no bending knee.

It makes more damage then good.