What's new
IconEra

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Forums  ›  Gaming
Playstation 
The Skill Up Review is savage... but I don't think he's out of line with his criticism.

His takes are an absolute joke. He nitpicks over a bit of handholding

Meanwhile, he "STRONGLY RECOMMENDS!!" Indiana Jones and the Great Circle, which has by far some of the dopiest, dumbest gameplay I have EVER played in my life. Literally retarded AI wrapped around a completely fake and superficial "immersive sim", combined with awful combat and a completely forgetable story and set of locations. He called it one of his games of the year.

He's completely out of touch. If only he applied his same level of nitpicking autism to that game instead, but he's not consistent AT ALL.
 
I can't take skill up seriously after his nonsensical TLOU2 takes.

Reviews are borderline uselss in terms of knowing whether you're gonna like a game, but good to see what improvements need to be done.

In sony's case - their strengths are technical excellence, polish and accessibility.

But they need to really take a look at improving their game design. Asobi and ND excel at it, but the rest not so much.

It's imo; one of the reasons their GAAS games failed. The gaas audience doesn't care about storytelling, polish, or performance.
They will play the jankiest shit imaginable as long as the systems are unique/interesting.

Yep, and as I stated above. He absolutely PRAISED the shit out of indiana jones despite an enormous number of flaws.
 
HRS8m-YDXIAE62bl.jpg

"Insane Visuals" Insoymniac always puts out bangers :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO: :ROFLMAO:


Mnan9-Spolse-Om-Sfp.jpg
 
I went to check the scores of the reviews included at MetaCritic:
100: 5 reviews
91-94: 2 reviews
90: 15 reviews
85-89: 18 reviews

81-84: 2 reviews
80: 32 reviews
75-79: 10 reviews
71-74: 1 review
70: 15 reviews
61-69: 1 review
60: 10 reviews
51-59: 0 reviews
50: 1 review (Giant Bomb)
not scored: 3 reviews

Seems that the low MC score is because MC weighted more few reviewers who gave it a 5 or 6 (Giant Bomb, IGN, Eurogamer, VGC, GameRadar and others).
 
I went to check the scores of the reviews included at MetaCritic:
100: 5 reviews
91-94: 2 reviews
90: 15 reviews
85-89: 18 reviews

81-84: 2 reviews
80: 32 reviews
75-79: 10 reviews
71-74: 1 review
70: 15 reviews
61-69: 1 review
60: 10 reviews
51-59: 0 reviews
50: 1 review (Giant Bomb)
not scored: 3 reviews

Seems that the low MC score is because MC weighted more few reviewers who gave it a 5 or 6 (Giant Bomb, IGN, Eurogamer, VGC, GameRadar and others).

 
incredible week… the kool-aid drinkers had to show their true colors as corporate dick suckers. Whatever it is Sony does… they spread their cheeks and say thank you.

This is all an incredible dissster. Love to see it

Hubris is a bitch.
 
I went to check the scores of the reviews included at MetaCritic:
100: 5 reviews
91-94: 2 reviews
90: 15 reviews
85-89: 18 reviews

81-84: 2 reviews
80: 32 reviews
75-79: 10 reviews
71-74: 1 review
70: 15 reviews
61-69: 1 review
60: 10 reviews
51-59: 0 reviews
50: 1 review (Giant Bomb)
not scored: 3 reviews

Seems that the low MC score is because MC weighted more few reviewers who gave it a 5 or 6 (Giant Bomb, IGN, Eurogamer, VGC, GameRadar and others).

It makes sense to have weighted scores. Proper outlets are more important than iwanthulsttoplowmybum.com's review.
 
Game sort of looks like if you took Uncharted and replaced its gunplay with lukewarm melee combat. I think making this a (relatively speaking) realistic and cinematic game was a complete misfire. It would be much easier to make Wolverine work as a flashy and over the top "character action game" like DMC or Ninja Gaiden. Probably should have been handed to a different studio as well, as that's not Insomniac's expertise.
 
incredible week… the kool-aid drinkers had to show their true colors as corporate dick suckers. Whatever it is Sony does… they spread their cheeks and say thank you.

This is all an incredible dissster. Love to see it

Hubris is a bitch.

Look we know you are butthurt that Destiny 2 is dead and Destiny 3 is not happening.

All you are doing is projecting.

Rather than whining and calling other names, how about creating a thread and proving why Sony is wrong about dumping Destiny.

Can you do that?
 
Is Gears Of War EBay the next Xbox release? Equivalent big expectations on that one, Twitter and forums will be bloody.
 
A mid sony game is still much better than most xbox games :LOL:
Ryse is by no means a great game, but I think overtime the consensus on Wolverine might become even less favorable. Ryse gampley might be basic, but it's like 6 hours long, so unlike Wolverine it doesn't overstay its welcome. The graphics hold up great too and it helps that a lot of people are obsessed with the Roman empire. Currently it sits at 85% positive on Steam.

Is Gears Of War EBay the next Xbox release? Equivalent big expectations on that one, Twitter and forums will be bloody.
Outside of people who are already Gears fans, I feel like the interest in it is fairly low. The fact that it uses a well-established formula means it harder to completely fuck up as well.
 
Is Gears Of War EBay the next Xbox release? Equivalent big expectations on that one, Twitter and forums will be bloody.
The campaign will be the same sony type slop we get. At least that has multiplayer so you can somewhat make your own fun.

Overall its going to be a flop too, hopefully we get some layoffs to go along with it.
 
Gears will review better. It comes baked with a tuned gameplay engine and combat loop players are already familiar with and enjoy. Easier to make. They can blow it but people actually did enjoy gears 5 so who knows.

Shooters are inherently a bit more easier to make in some ways…

Insomniac was simply the wrong dev for melee combat this close. The zoning and ranged attacks of spider-man don’t work here. Should’ve been Santa Monica.

Wolverine just looks like a bad version of the two SMS god of war games tbh.
 
Ryse is by no means a great game, but I think overtime the consensus on Wolverine might become even less favorable. Ryse gampley might be basic, but it's like 6 hours long, so unlike Wolverine it doesn't overstay its welcome. The graphics hold up great too and it helps that a lot of people are obsessed with the Roman empire. Currently it sits at 85% positive on Steam.

Let's be real, Wolverine is gonna hold up much better than rise, it's gameplay has way more going on, and a lot of people are obsessed with Xmen, especially if this ends up linking up to the future xmen games.

But like rise, there's a good chance these lower reviewers tempers expectations and most people will just end up saying "hey it's actually pretty good".
 
Last edited:
Back
Top