Banana Developer Says Game Isn’t A Scam

Old Gamer

Veteran
Founder
5 Aug 2022
2,400
3,971
Idle games aren't a scam, no. But Banana is exposing actual exploits in Steam's digital items economy.

Far more immediately profitable than bitcoin mining, I would say.
 
  • brain
Reactions: The Icon

Gods&Monsters

Veteran
21 Jun 2022
5,607
11,468
An embarrassment that Valve allows this. Any other company would be under fire for this exploitation.

They probably made millions from gullible people buying "skins" for their banana 🤦‍♀️
 

Old Gamer

Veteran
Founder
5 Aug 2022
2,400
3,971
An embarrassment that Valve allows this. Any other company would be under fire for this exploitation.

They probably made millions from gullible people buying "skins" for their banana 🤦‍♀️
Haven't you heard, a Valve monopoly would actually be a good thing.
 

Zzero

Major Tom
9 Jan 2023
4,011
2,335
Utterly bizarre but how is people liking dumb shit a problem? And as to bots botting rare skins? Oh well, thats on the dev to account for, as long as humans are voluntarily buying them there's no moral issue there.
 

John Elden Ring

The Thread Maker
Content Creator
5 Jul 2022
6,464
7,950
United States
It technically isnt, but he's making tens of thousands of dollars a day, the $50 bananas are all made by the developer, bots can only farm the 3 cents banana which are worthless.
 
Last edited:

Zzero

Major Tom
9 Jan 2023
4,011
2,335
It technically isnt, but he's making tensd of thousands of dollars a day, the $50 bananas are all made by the developer, bots can only farm the 3 cents banana which are worthless.
I must have missed that in the article.
 

CrackmanNL

Veteran
4 Apr 2024
589
498
Scam, I mean games with marketplaces do this, hell what you think transaction fees irl are. But the point is to click for money and the actual game is trading banana skins. GG to the developers.
Hilarious but I expect no less of PC and especially Steam folks lmao
 
  • they're_right_you_know
Reactions: 2spooky5me

Zzero

Major Tom
9 Jan 2023
4,011
2,335
Here's a good breakdown, for every sale the developer makes 1 cent, if tens of thousand of people are selling bananas then he's making thousands of dollars a day, that's the scam.

But that's not a scam. The buyers are not bots, they are willingly paying for the bananas, there is no victim here, Steam pays nothing to the devs and the game is free, unless you consider someone buying an item that they "want" to be a scam. The video speculates that the creator is giving free bananas to his friends, but offers no proof to it, or even a way to do so- despite having "reverse engineered" the game.

I think its a much simpler explanation that the game is a meme game that people are running in the background. It hurts no-one and the only "point" to the game, seeing funny meme bananas, seems to be done.
 

anonpuffs

Veteran
Icon Extra
29 Nov 2022
10,515
11,955
But that's not a scam. The buyers are not bots, they are willingly paying for the bananas, there is no victim here, Steam pays nothing to the devs and the game is free, unless you consider someone buying an item that they "want" to be a scam. The video speculates that the creator is giving free bananas to his friends, but offers no proof to it, or even a way to do so- despite having "reverse engineered" the game.

I think its a much simpler explanation that the game is a meme game that people are running in the background. It hurts no-one and the only "point" to the game, seeing funny meme bananas, seems to be done.
It feels close to being a pyramid scheme where people are relying on getting new suckers in to hold the bag for them, and the only person who makes money is the guy at the top.

What takes it from being a game to being a scam or scam-like is the exchange of real money.
 

Zzero

Major Tom
9 Jan 2023
4,011
2,335
It feels close to being a pyramid scheme where people are relying on getting new suckers in to hold the bag for them, and the only person who makes money is the guy at the top.

What takes it from being a game to being a scam or scam-like is the exchange of real money.
Well then, every customizable Steam account decoration is a scam. Which, well, fair enough, but I think people would be pissed if you "banned the scammers" in that case.
 

anonpuffs

Veteran
Icon Extra
29 Nov 2022
10,515
11,955
Well then, every customizable Steam account decoration is a scam. Which, well, fair enough, but I think people would be pissed if you "banned the scammers" in that case.
people resell those?
 

2spooky5me

Veteran
12 May 2024
521
454
@anonpuffs

It's a WHOLE career/industry over on STEAM. That's why it's so popular.
People literally farm CS GO and similar games to get skins, avatars, background profiles, etc. and sell them for big bucks (sometimes). You can even see listings on eBay (which IS illegal, but I guess Valve can't stop them all).

People complained about Playstation Stars, but you cannot trade any of those digital trinkets, nor can you even use real money.
So, that's why it puzzled me so much, when folks compared it to a "rip-off" version of STEAM's.
 

anonpuffs

Veteran
Icon Extra
29 Nov 2022
10,515
11,955
@anonpuffs

It's a WHOLE career/industry over on STEAM. That's why it's so popular.
People literally farm CS GO and similar games to get skins, avatars, background profiles, etc. and sell them for big bucks (sometimes). You can even see listings on eBay (which IS illegal, but I guess Valve can't stop them all).

People complained about Playstation Stars, but you cannot trade any of those digital trinkets, nor can you even use real money.
So, that's why it puzzled me so much, when folks compared it to a "rip-off" version of STEAM's.
Huh. I never paid attention to that stuff so that's crazy. I thought artists made those things and sold them like in a marketplace, didn't think they were resellable or like... idk
 

John Elden Ring

The Thread Maker
Content Creator
5 Jul 2022
6,464
7,950
United States
But that's not a scam. The buyers are not bots, they are willingly paying for the bananas, there is no victim here, Steam pays nothing to the devs and the game is free, unless you consider someone buying an item that they "want" to be a scam. The video speculates that the creator is giving free bananas to his friends, but offers no proof to it, or even a way to do so- despite having "reverse engineered" the game.

I think its a much simpler explanation that the game is a meme game that people are running in the background. It hurts no-one and the only "point" to the game, seeing funny meme bananas, seems to be done.

The creator has his Steam inventory private, that's evidence