I finished Elden Ring and I'm still playing Horizon Forbidden West so it's between those two. I don't like pitting them against each other again but nothing else comes close
Elden Ring got really repetitive by the end (lots of copy paste) but the beginning was absolutely magical and I understand why the casuals thought it was the best thing ever. I'm replaying Demons Souls Remake on PS+ and Elden Ring looks so outdated now. The sound is so cheap too.
Horizon is the best showcase game for the PS5. It's like playing a game from the future. I really want to take my time and explore everything so it's taking me way longer than it should. Everytime I play something else and then I come back to Horizon I can't believe it's real