Circana - Spider-Man 2 is October 2023 Top 20 Best-Selling Premium Games - U.S. (Dollar Sales, Excludes add-on content)

[Cool hand luke]

Series X/S are just ahead of the 360 but behind the xbox one.

The hardest thing is not the 36-month period, but to see where they will be at the end of their life.

The 360 made 43 million and the One still made 29 million.

I'm not sure the X/S will do as well.

That's right. The 360 got a second wind from Kinect. There is no such lifeline on the way for XSX. It'll land between the OG Xbox and 360, months aligned, very soon.

 

[ethomaz]

US LTD

PS2 : 46.40 million
PS4 : 34.76
PS1 : 30.40
PS3 : 27.10
PS5 : 16.15

360 : 43.60
XB1 : 29.00
XBX : 14.50
X/S : 11.86

After 36 months

PS2 : 18.91
PS5 : 16.15
PS4 : 14.82
PS1 : 10.18
PS3 : 9.05

XB1 : 13.33
X/S : 11.86
360 : 11.59
XBX : 9.94

360 will probably pull ahead both XB1 and X/S after the 4th year.
X/S will only beat original Xbox more because it had no time to grow in US... less than 5 years separate Xbox from 360.

 

[KiryuRealty]

Series X/S are just ahead of the 360 but behind the xbox one.

The hardest thing is not the 36-month period, but to see where they will be at the end of their life.

The 360 made 43 million and the One still made 29 million.

I'm not sure the X/S will do as well.

With the Series trending down year-over-year I think it is safe to conclude that it won't come close to the 360.

 

[Evilms]

With the Series trending down year-over-year I think it is safe to conclude that it won't come close to the 360.

The 360 is too high for her.
Not sure it'll catch up with the XB1.

 

[Cool hand luke]

The 360 is too high for her.
Not sure it'll catch up with the XB1.

Any chance of it falling behind the OG once all is said and done? How early do they have to pull the plug? Despite Welfare's laughable estimates, there's no way it's higher than 22m shipped atm with this kind of US performance.

 

[Darth Vader]

Any chance of it falling behind the OG once all is said and done? How early do they have to pull the plug? Despite Welfare's laughable estimates, there's no way it's higher than 22m shipped atm with this kind of US performance.

It's only 22M shipped because of supply shortages! And let's not forget that the Series Consoles are the only products ever that when in short supply (lol) and high demand (double lol) did not have consumers go for a bundle that was a 10% premium.

We should just pin this:

 

[Evilms]

Any chance of it falling behind the OG once all is said and done? How early do they have to pull the plug? Despite Welfare's laughable estimates, there's no way it's higher than 22m shipped atm with this kind of US performance.

For the US market, the original Xbox is within reach, 14.5 million is the easiest of the three.

The Xbox One, on the other hand, is complicated. And to beat the 360 would require a miracle.

 

[thicc_girls_are_teh_best]

Huh, did Nintendo release digital numbers anywhere? I'm curious to see.

Edit: I think you meant to say excluded, in whicase its not quite top 20 without it. Though it might be by this point, since we are halfway through November.

Neoxon asked Piscatella on Twitter if digital would've closed the gap between Wonder and SM2. Piscatella outright said "No".

I took that to mean Wonder with digital included, at least for NPD, would still have been behind SM2 for the month. It makes sense, considering for the year SM2 is already 4th and Wonder is 21st. Digital wouldn't get Wonder to suddenly leapfrog almost 20 spots in the blink of an eye.

Even jumping 10 spots would be extremely difficult. However, with digital it's prob at least in the Top 20 and after the holidays it'll prob either edge into Top 10, be just outside of Top 10 or somewhere between 10th and 15th for the year on NPD/Circana.

 

[Zzero]

Neoxon asked Piscatella on Twitter if digital would've closed the gap between Wonder and SM2. Piscatella outright said "No".

I took that to mean Wonder with digital included, at least for NPD, would still have been behind SM2 for the month. It makes sense, considering for the year SM2 is already 4th and Wonder is 21st. Digital wouldn't get Wonder to suddenly leapfrog almost 20 spots in the blink of an eye.

Even jumping 10 spots would be extremely difficult. However, with digital it's prob at least in the Top 20 and after the holidays it'll prob either edge into Top 10, be just outside of Top 10 or somewhere between 10th and 15th for the year on NPD/Circana.

I didn't mention Spiderman at all, just that Mario's numbers are artificially low. I don't think I've commented on comparisons of the two much, if at all (keeping my bragging to how much faster TotK has sold compared to it.)