Aside from the disingenuous interpretation where gamepass subscriptions are completely ignored in favor a sales metric which is mostly obsolete for games featured on that service day one… no one is using sales metrics when talking about Redfall or Starfield. Redfall is a pretty huge flop. Starfield is holding on well on console. Starfield on gamepass can bankrupt Bethesda. Microsoft fucked everyone with gamepass
For ff16 since sales are the only metric to go by. Its underwhelming sales performance.
Shockingly however in one month on retail while being sold for rental fees on gamepass, Starfield still managed to blow past ff16. Not surprising tho, as ff16 fell off a cliff.