Nintendo is suing Palworld (Update: Palworld will fight back)

Neversummer

Veteran
27 Jun 2023
1,402
1,392
Welp, however this is resolved whether Palworld wins or they loose they will sell to Sony & build up the building blocks & making a Pokemon competitor with all the data.

The question still stands on whether the devs uses ai & are they actually talented to mimic the success.

More reason why PS shouldn’t be releasing there games on Nintendo. Your not gonna be able to buy Palworld devs & releases these small spin offs on Nintendo thinking it’s cool if anything if I was Nintendo I would block games like Lego Horizon & Freedom wars just so they either survive on PS or they die on PS & limits PS growth/profits. PS needs to build & double down on there console not do whatever there doing w the PS5 generation they’ve been making mistake over mistake & disaster announcements/investment after another
 

Zzero

Major Tom
9 Jan 2023
3,938
2,287
Nah they gonna win. Palworld devs literally ripped Pokemon character models/assets from official games, made like 1% changes, then slapped them into Palworld.

There was a Twitter thread that showed the shocking similarity in character model geometry for a few of the characters between both games. I imagine that's what's lead to this lawsuit.

Most likely, the two sides will settle out of court, but it does make Sony in particular look a bit foolish going into the joint partnership thing knowing this legal grey area was hanging in the background. Sure, the allure of their own Pokemon was too strong to resist, but there are safe ways to do it (Yu Gi Oh, Digimon etc.), and then there's...well there's how Palworld did it 🤣



Did either of those have games where they potentially ripped Pokemon models wholesale, changed a few polygons & textures, then called it a day? I don't remember that ever happening.
That isn't patent infringement, its trademark infringement. Nintendo clearly found something else.
 

Al Catone

Whiskers
Staff member
18 Jun 2024
132
152
That was the most obvious copy ever but they waited way too long. Pocketpair are billionaires at this point. They can fight whatever Nintendo throws at them.

Rumour is the PS5 version will be announced next week. What will happen to that. It's like Nintendo had no issues when the game was Xbox exclusive 😬

Because it takes mere weeks to compile a case like this.... But yes, I'm sure its because Xbox.
 

Gods&Monsters

Veteran
21 Jun 2022
5,525
11,241
Because it takes mere weeks to compile a case like this.... But yes, I'm sure its because Xbox.
Sorry Exanthus but sending an injunction takes 5 minutes. Anybody with eyes could tell Palword was a blatant ripoff. You don't need to build your whole case from A to Z for months before doing something.

The timing is fishy and that is that.

Nene Leakes GIF
 

Al Catone

Whiskers
Staff member
18 Jun 2024
132
152
Sorry Exanthus but sending an injunction takes 5 minutes. Anybody with eyes could tell Palword was a blatant ripoff. You don't need to build your whole case from A to Z for months before doing something.

The timing is fishy and that is that.

Nene Leakes GIF

And they released an official statement about it 7 months ago. Did you forget it was released on Steam too?
 
24 Jun 2022
3,922
6,792
That dude admitted he doctored the pictures btw

Oh, well then he's an idiot.

But that just means Nintendo's lawsuit must be on different grounds. Again, it's probably related to something in Palworld's codebase, that's an implementation of a system/mechanic that Nintendo patented, and that Palworld illegally utilized in some way without Nintendo's legal consent.

And yes there is precedent for patented code-based systems in gaming: Namco did it back in 1995 with the "mini-game loading screen" (like the Galaxian one in Ridge Racer).

Kind of like reverse-engineering a BIOS, but not doing a clean-room job with it so you're liable to a big lawsuit.
 

Yurinka

Veteran
VIP
21 Jun 2022
7,649
6,515
In this case then Bandai Namco should also sue Nintendo because Super Mario Bros and its sequels "plagiarized" many things from Pac-Land, and Sony/Media Molecule should also sue Nintendo because several more modern Mario/Yoshi/Kirby games plagiarized ideas from Little Big Planet or Tearaway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Systemshock2023
27 Jun 2023
5,354
4,247
29
United kingdom
That was the most obvious copy ever but they waited way too long. Pocketpair are billionaires at this point. They can fight whatever Nintendo throws at them.

Rumour is the PS5 version will be announced next week. What will happen to that. It's like Nintendo had no issues when the game was Xbox exclusive 😬
Exactly now we're getting closer to a playstation release they care 😂
 
  • they're_right_you_know
Reactions: Gods&Monsters
27 Jun 2023
5,354
4,247
29
United kingdom
And they released an official statement about it 7 months ago. Did you forget it was released on Steam too?
Well Nintendo is supposed to be best buds with Xbox so surely someone at Nintendo would've reached out to Phil Spencer & said 'hey dude wtf can you cancel that gamepass deal you have with this ripoff game, not cool man'
 

FatKaz

Veteran
16 Jul 2022
2,215
4,197
Most likely, the two sides will settle out of court, but it does make Sony in particular look a bit foolish going into the joint partnership thing knowing this legal grey area was hanging in the background.

Maybe Sony lawyers thought Nintendo had nothing so went into the partnership 🤷
 

Kokoloko

Veteran
Icon Extra
21 Jun 2022
5,745
4,511
Been a Nintendo fan since a kid. But I hope Palworld fuck them up, Nintendo’s arrogance needs a kick in the face. Stopping pirating games is one thing, the rest is stupid. You really arent that special…
 
Last edited: