Gamepass or PS Extra works for people who
- play lot of games
- have lot of time
if you are like myself who has wife and kids, work and friends then you have a very limited time and that makes me very picky when it comes to the games I play. big AAA games usually skip subscription services and also take lot of time for me to finish.
subscription services make sense for people who can sit and finish a 20h game in just one or two days.
another thing I don't understand when people say Gamepass will target mobile people: you won't find someone playing ES6 on a 6inch phone in a metro a 6AM commuting to work. these people will just play the easiest match 3 game possible and won't be paying 180$ per year to do that.