What really is first party nowadays? Definition of first/second/third party games.

akira__

Well-known member
29 Sep 2024
315
316
Seriously, dudes be nice to eachother.
Let's disagree with each other but keep it nice.

Ontopic:
Xbox will become the first to have games in all those categories at the same time. First, second and third party titles.

Xbox keeps winning.
 
  • thisistheway
Reactions: DarkLordOtaku

arvfab

Slayer of Colossi
23 Jun 2022
3,298
4,550
A game is first party when it's published by the platform holder, independently if that platform holder owns the IP or not.

Stellar Blade, Helldivers 2, Death Stranding and Uncharted are PlayStation first party games because Sony published them. On PC they are third party because Sony doesn't own PC/Steam.

Demon's Souls, Bloodborne and Death Stranding were published and supported by the XDEV team of Japan Studio. So since they are published by Sony they are first party games.

The Last Guardian was a game internally developed and published by Japan Studio like Knack, Gravity Rush or Astro Bot. Even if around a dozen or so Japan Studio folks (out of over 500 people who worked in the game) left/were fired at the later part of the development and completed their job from GenDesign. It's published by Sony, so it's a first party game.

Hi-Fi Rush is first party on Xbox, third party on PlayStation. Because it's published by the platform holder in Xbox but not in PlayStation.

Another clueless one
 
  • they're_right_you_know
Reactions: Gediminas

Yurinka

Veteran
VIP
21 Jun 2022
7,773
6,658
First party games are those published by the platform holder, independently of how owns the IP.

Second party games are the first party games (so published by the platform holder) whose lead dev studio isn't owned by the platform holder, independently of who owns the IP.

Third party games are those published by someone who isn't the platform holder, independently of who owns the IP.

And a troll who should be banned is the one who constantly puts the laugh emoji to my explanations.
 
Last edited:

ethomaz

Rebolation!
21 Jun 2022
12,074
9,786
Brasil 🇧🇷
PSN ID
ethomaz
A game is first party when it's published by the platform holder, independently if that platform holder owns the IP or not.

Stellar Blade, Helldivers 2, Death Stranding and Uncharted are PlayStation first party games because Sony published them. On PC they are third party because Sony doesn't own PC/Steam.

Demon's Souls, Bloodborne and Death Stranding were published and supported by the XDEV team of Japan Studio. So since they are published by Sony they are first party games.

The Last Guardian was a game internally developed and published by Japan Studio like Knack, Gravity Rush or Astro Bot. Even if around a dozen or so Japan Studio folks (out of over 500 people who worked in the game) left/were fired at the later part of the development and completed their job from GenDesign. It's published by Sony, so it's a first party game.

Hi-Fi Rush is first party on Xbox, third party on PlayStation. Because it's published by the platform holder in Xbox but not in PlayStation.

Owning the IP isn't related to be first party or not. 2nd party games, which also are 1st party games, often use IPs not owned by the platform holder. And there are first party games like Spider-Man 2 or Wolverine, who use licensed IPs not owned by the platform holder.

Who owns the IP is the one who decides if they make ports, sequels, merchandising, adaptations etc. of that IP and who has the last word about it. And gets whatever revenue share generated by these products according to whatever they negogiate in each case.
Stellar Blade are 3rd-party exclusive on PlayStation.
 
  • haha
  • Like
Reactions: Ezekiel and arvfab

Gediminas

Boy...
Founder
21 Jun 2022
7,559
9,280
Stellar Blade are 3rd-party exclusive on PlayStation.
Stellar Blade is outlayer. It is more in gray area, as first party devs worked on it and Playstation invested money in it to become the game it is. But they don't own studio or ip.
 

arvfab

Slayer of Colossi
23 Jun 2022
3,298
4,550
Stellar Blade is outlayer. It is more in gray area, as first party devs worked on it and Playstation invested money in it to become the game it is. But they don't own studio or ip.
You are correct, but it's still 3rd party, no gray area. We have heard of Sony devs helping out other non-Sony devs in the past already, never was there anyone mentioning those games to be 1st party.

Same as Microsoft devs going to help to make Baldurs Gate 3 work on their console.
 

Gediminas

Boy...
Founder
21 Jun 2022
7,559
9,280
You are correct, but it's still 3rd party, no gray area. We have heard of Sony devs helping out other non-Sony devs in the past already, never was there anyone mentioning those games to be 1st party.

Same as Microsoft devs going to help to make Baldurs Gate 3 work on their console.
one thing is to make game work on X system, the other to make a game. i am not conflicting the Two. if Playstation devs making a game, effectively, it is first party studio developing 3rd party game add money on top? = gray area as there are very few games which really match it.
this is how i see it at least, to lessen confusion in description.
 

ethomaz

Rebolation!
21 Jun 2022
12,074
9,786
Brasil 🇧🇷
PSN ID
ethomaz
Stellar Blade is outlayer. It is more in gray area, as first party devs worked on it and Playstation invested money in it to become the game it is. But they don't own studio or ip.
IMO I don’t think Sony helping the development or funding the game makes it 1st-party… Sony do that with a lot of 3rd-party games.

I just want to say that Sony publishing the game doesn’t make it 1st-party.

There are a lot of examples that prove that… it just time consuming to check all them but… I can give some examples from my mind:

Marvel’s Iron Man VR: 3rd-party game published by Sony.
Ghostbusters: 3rd-party game published by Sony (Europe).

These are Sony published games that are not 1st-party.
Same for Stellar Blade.

Unless Sony buys the IP or developer it will continue being a 3rd-party exclusive.
 
  • haha
  • Like
Reactions: Ezekiel and arvfab

Gediminas

Boy...
Founder
21 Jun 2022
7,559
9,280
IMO I don’t think Sony helping the development or funding the game makes it 1st-party… Sony do that with a lot of 3rd-party games.

I just want to say that Sony publishing the game doesn’t make it 1st-party.

There are a lot of examples that prove that… it just time consuming to check all them but… I can give some examples from my mind:

Marvel’s Iron Man VR: 3rd-party game published by Sony.
Ghostbusters: 3rd-party game published by Sony (Europe).

These are Sony published games that are not 1st-party.
Same for Stellar Blade.

Unless Sony buys the IP or developer it will continue being a 3rd-party exclusive.
i didn't say, it makes it 1st party. anywhere.

publishing rights, doesn't determine is it 1st, 2nd or 3rd party.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ethomaz and arvfab

Hezekiah

Veteran
23 Jul 2022
1,402
1,380
A game is first party when it's published by the platform holder, independently if that platform holder owns the IP or not.

Stellar Blade, Helldivers 2, Death Stranding and Uncharted are PlayStation first party games because Sony published them. On PC they are third party because Sony doesn't own PC/Steam.


Demon's Souls, Bloodborne and Death Stranding were published and supported by the XDEV team of Japan Studio. So since they are published by Sony they are first party games.

The Last Guardian was a game internally developed and published by Japan Studio like Knack, Gravity Rush or Astro Bot. Even if around a dozen or so Japan Studio folks (out of over 500 people who worked in the game) left/were fired at the later part of the development and completed their job from GenDesign. It's published by Sony, so it's a first party game.

Hi-Fi Rush is first party on Xbox, third party on PlayStation. Because it's published by the platform holder in Xbox but not in PlayStation.

Owning the IP isn't related to be first party or not. 2nd party games, which also are 1st party games, often use IPs not owned by the platform holder. And there are first party games like Spider-Man 2 or Wolverine, who use licensed IPs not owned by the platform holder.

Who owns the IP is the one who decides if they make ports, sequels, merchandising, adaptations etc. of that IP and who has the last word about it. And gets whatever revenue share generated by these products according to whatever they negogiate in each case.
I specifically refer to those as second-party but some people get triggered by the term 😄

But yeah if it's published by SIE it's Sony first-party.
 

CrackmanNL

Veteran
4 Apr 2024
581
492
We've had Layden on record on WUPS explaining the differences. I've posted this before not going to bother with the discussion, timestamp @17:37

Shift Up has an official 2nd party contract with Sony.

Rip in peace playstation
1994 - 2024
We will have the Game Awards soon to confirm with PS domination that it's over as well.
 
  • brain
Reactions: The Icon

arvfab

Slayer of Colossi
23 Jun 2022
3,298
4,550
If you told me back in 2006 that PlayStation fans would be unironically using revenues & profits as a way to boast about the brand, I'd of laughed my ass off.

Yet here we are. LITERALLY people cheerleading for revenues & profits, as if that's all that matters to a gamer or hobbyist in the scene.

Gaming has regressed 🤣

And we are the "interesting" ones 😂😂😂
 

Gediminas

Boy...
Founder
21 Jun 2022
7,559
9,280
If you told me back in 2006 that PlayStation fans would be unironically using revenues & profits as a way to boast about the brand, I'd of laughed my ass off.

Yet here we are. LITERALLY people cheerleading for revenues & profits, as if that's all that matters to a gamer or hobbyist in the scene.

Gaming has regressed 🤣
that's the difference between real gamers, hobbyist and bean counters.
 

Yurinka

Veteran
VIP
21 Jun 2022
7,773
6,658
9-Month Profits in 2024 :
PlayStation - $2.03 billion
Nintendo - $1.22 billion
EA - $984 million
Konami - $475 million
Bandai Namco - $273 million
Capcom - $199 million
Ubisoft - -$89 million (loss)

Profits in the last quarter :
PlayStation - $908 million
Nintendo - $440 million
EA - $384 million
Konami - $149 million
Bandai Namco - $96 million
Capcom - $51 million
Ubisoft - -$294 million (loss

Rip in peace playstation
1994 - 2024
Yes, some people say PS is dead but the factual, objective numbers to measure its performance say the opposite.
 

CrackmanNL

Veteran
4 Apr 2024
581
492
IP belongs to Shift-Up. The moment the exclusivity agreement ends (unless PlayStation bought it permanently), they can port it where they want. Similar regarding sequels, spin-offs, etc.

Thus the game is 3rd party.
In public documents they have signed a 2nd party contract. Not my words, Sony's and Shift Up.
I agree IP ownership moves closer to 1st party line, none closer to 3rd party line if you get more intricate in the 2nd party discourse.

There's a grey area in the middle and variables in contractual obligations like IP ownership where people have discussions and there are definitions within, I am not here to argue about that cause it gets convoluted. For example Insomniac makes SM games. It's exclusive and by an owned studio, but Disney can potentially take the license away.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gediminas

ethomaz

Rebolation!
21 Jun 2022
12,074
9,786
Brasil 🇧🇷
PSN ID
ethomaz
I specifically refer to those as second-party but some people get triggered by the term 😄

But yeah if it's published by SIE it's Sony first-party.
That doesn’t even make sense.
Maybe you guys are well new to PlayStation but if you say games published by Sony is first-party then a lot of games for PS1 / PS2 were first-party… but they weren’t.

Destruction Derby was published by Sony and it was 3rd-party.
3D Lemmings was published by Sony and it was 3rd1party.

Even WipEout only become 1st party after Sony brought them… on PS1 it was a 3rd-party game published by Sony.

Singstar, Blood & Truth, etc all 3rd-party published by Sony.

Edit - These games where already part of Sony.
 
Last edited:

Hezekiah

Veteran
23 Jul 2022
1,402
1,380
That doesn’t even make sense.
Maybe you guys are well new to PlayStation but if you say games published by Sony is first-party then a lot of games for PS2 were first-party… but they weren’t.

Destruction Derby was published by Sony and it was 3rd-party.
3D Lemmings was published by Sony and it was 3rd1party.

Even WipEout only become 1st party after Sony brought them… on PS1 it was a 3rd-party game published by Sony.

Singstar, Blood & Truth, etc all 3rd-party published by Sony.
No I'm not new to Playstation I've owned every one...I'm just not a thicko 🤦