Why is there always this ridiculous assumption that porting a game = brand diminishment?
Because it is. It's ridiculous to think it is not.
Why is there always this ridiculous assumption that porting a game = brand diminishment?
Because the Xbox is a dying platform, they'd spend money porting the game to two different consoles with different performance tiers and then the chances of recouping that money would be slim to none.
And the portion of Xbox owners that still haven't forgotten the console aren't buying titles, they're just subscribing to GamePass.
Okay mr. Phil, sure Xbox isn't dying, they're just porting all their games to the competing platform because their financials are just sooo good they needed to share with their top rival lmaoXbox isn't dying. Microsoft makes so much money from their gaming segment and isn't not going anywhere. People wanting it to die isn't the same as it actually dying. As long as Microsoft makes billions in revenue and profit, Xbox is going nowhere. Microsoft doesn't need to be #1 or even #2 to be massively successful.
As for people not buying games on Xbox, same can be said for PlayStation. People over hype sales on PlayStation when in reality 90% of the user install base pass on every game unless it's COD, GTA, live service or sports games. Look at Spider Man 2. As of April 2024, it was around 12m which is outstanding but with a user install base of almost 60m, what happened to the other 80% of the install base? They forgot to show up.
Also, Microsoft's direction is subscription, not sales which should be pretty obvious to everyone by now. Both Microsoft and Sony have different business strategies and whatnot which is great because that helps separate them from one another instead of just being exactly the same which is what I personally don't want.
As for Helldivers 2, if Sony believes/knows that they can make money on Xbox, they'll port the game because they'll have the numbers. All anyone ever posts is sales numbers from Europe and even worse, physical only numbers which is dead on Xbox because it's a platform that's basically 90% digital.
Xbox isn't dying. Microsoft makes so much money from their gaming segment and isn't not going anywhere.
Why is there always this ridiculous assumption that porting a game = brand diminishment?
Peter420 is a good dude, let him have his opinion without dog piling please.
One response of the same type of enough or we end up going in circles.
Xbox only by name, as a physical presence in your living room - it’s dying.Xbox isn't dying. Microsoft makes so much money from their gaming segment and isn't not going anywhere. People wanting it to die isn't the same as it actually dying. As long as Microsoft makes billions in revenue and profit, Xbox is going nowhere. Microsoft doesn't need to be #1 or even #2 to be massively successful.
As for people not buying games on Xbox, same can be said for PlayStation. People over hype sales on PlayStation when in reality 90% of the user install base pass on every game unless it's COD, GTA, live service or sports games. Look at Spider Man 2. As of April 2024, it was around 12m which is outstanding but with a user install base of almost 60m, what happened to the other 80% of the install base? They forgot to show up.
Also, Microsoft's direction is subscription, not sales which should be pretty obvious to everyone by now. Both Microsoft and Sony have different business strategies and whatnot which is great because that helps separate them from one another instead of just being exactly the same which is what I personally don't want.
As for Helldivers 2, if Sony believes/knows that they can make money on Xbox, they'll port the game because they'll have the numbers. All anyone ever posts is sales numbers from Europe and even worse, physical only numbers which is dead on Xbox because it's a platform that's basically 90% digital.
He made the post now he has deal with the responses to the flawed argument.
Only 2 people responded. Don’t tell me this forum babysits certain posters?
Xbox only by name, as a physical presence in your living room - it’s dying.
It’s as if Activision and Zenimax acquired Xbox, not the other way around.
Who’s going to care about Xbox as just a publisher? Maybe those that care for Ubisoft and Tencent, should they even exist outside of the shareholder class.
You're right to say that's how you see it personally. The actual wider audience, the one that matters to brand health is rejecting the console offered by MS, and this is what ultimately is the undoing of the living room for them. The subscription turns out is not a sufficient hook.As long as they're selling hardware, their physical presence in your living room isn't going anywhere. They're already working on new hardware, a console and a portable handheld which is a far better decision than Series X/S.
Let me preface the following with this - im a subscription guy first and foremost. I really don't want to buy anything unless I have to. If I do, I will but if I don't (ala Ubisoft's and Microsoft's published games), I won't because im not a collector and don't care about ownership.
Microsoft is a publisher but it's what they've always been since the 80's, the hardware is simply one of the ways to access their games and content. The benefit (at least for me) of having an Xbox console is Game Pass. Why would I want to buy their games for $70 when I can get them and a few third party games day one every year as part of my subscription which saves me a lot more money than if I would buy them all. And since I have gone all digital, there's no trading in like I used to do when buying certain games on disc.
It's not just about their published games or Game Pass though. On Xbox, I have access to Ubisoft+ which includes the best versions of their games day one which isn't available on PlayStation. I get free cloud saves, 6 refunds a year (try getting a legitimate refund on PlayStation, it's a fucking hassle) which is huge when you're now all digital like I am, backwards compatibility in which I was just able to play through all the Halo games for the first time ever and best of all, they were all remastered for Xbox One so I had a better experience playing them now as opposed to back in the day when they launched.
I have access to EA Play via Game Pass Ultimate which is also huge because I can play through the original Dead Space and Mass Effect games for the first time ever. Best of all, Mass Effect trilogy was completely remastered and again, I don't have to buy any of these games. Best of all for me, I can also use the Xbox One controller which is the best and my favorite controller of all time. No gimmicks, no over sized touch pad, 40+ hours of battery life on a single full charge and is what I want the most out of a controller - basic, standard and just freaking works with no issues.
To add to that, I get discounts on games because im a Game Pass Ultimate subscriber and the games aren't even in Game Pass which leads me to buying more games because im getting them cheaper.
Most of all, Microsoft is finally giving me what I want the most - GAMES. With all the studios they now have, this generation for me will blow away Xbox, Xbox 360 and Xbox One combined. I have already surpassed what I had with Xbox One which was only 5 games. I already 6. I will probably end up with 12-15 depending on if they release their next console in Fall 2026 which i do believe that they will because having your own space and time when launching new hardware is simply the best way to go.
If the trade off of me getting everything I listed in this post is Microsoft porting their games to Sony/Nintendo platforms, then so be it. Sony's published games are great for the most part and I enjoy the majority of them but in all honesty, that's all they give me as a hardware manufacturer/platform holder. If all im getting is bragging rights due to exclusivity but nothing else, then to be perfectly honest, im good giving that up which I already did six months ago by staying with Xbox despite throwing a temper tantrum because the benefits far outweigh the negatives.
In general, I do believe that Sony will eventually release their games day one on PC and if anything, this is a given to me and even more so if they startup their own PC store front. As for porting to Microsoft/Nintendo platforms, they've already started it years ago and while I don't believe that they will go at the pace of Microsoft any time soon, within a decade or so, Sony will be more or less the same as Microsoft.
The only company I see staying "old school" is Nintendo because they have their own fan base and market, they have a huge winner with having a hybrid console, they rarely if ever devalue any of their stuff as they're literally the Disney of video games, they never take a loss on anything, they always make a profit on everything and because they're not reliant or dependent on tech like Microsoft and Sony are, they simply don't spend the money.
That's how I look at it in general and for myself personally. Everyone will look at it their own way but of course, if you're not a fan of a certain company or brand, you're going to look down on them regardless of what they do. If anything, im more into Xbox and gaming on Xbox than I was before simply because I decided to "let it all go". Whatever Microsoft does, it doesn't matter because I can't do anything about any of it, good or bad. What I can do is enjoy gaming on Xbox which I have.
Same for Sony with PlayStation 5. While many here just want to constantly bitch about what they're doing with their company and their IP's, I have been enjoying their console, their exclusives every year and just like with Microsoft and Xbox, as long as they release a console, I will there day one to buy it because it's simply how I prefer to play games. I have zero interest in going to PC and until it's the only option which is probably 20+ years away from now, will never play a game via streaming until it's the only option.
One thing I have noticed between here and for example, XboxEra, is that despite everything Microsoft has done this year, those over there seem to be far happier and enjoying what they have on Xbox where as so many here are more negative than positive and barely if at all, enjoy what they have on PlayStation 5 which for the life of me, I don't get at all because I have enjoyed PlayStation 5 more than I did PlayStation 4 in the same time frame.
But to each their own. It all is what it is.
It's incredible how much the narrative has changed
It's incredible how much the narrative has changed
You're right to say that's how you see it personally. The actual wider audience, the one that matters to brand health is rejecting the console offered by MS, and this is what ultimately is the undoing of the living room for them. The subscription turns out is not a sufficient hook.
Any subscription model is pretty much moot without a thriving delivery mechanism of the physical appliance. I must be missing the bandwidth on how Gamepass will be sustainable when not enough are subscribing - well the answer is in front of us, it's not - hence the À la carte sales on competing platforms. Is netflix publishing their titles on Hulu?
Leaning on oh I love games so I don't care is a cop out in a Console oriented discussion. Why engage if it matters not?