6.5/10
The standout for me was Phantom Blade 0. Looks and feels like a legit next-gen game and was also the visual standout. The other standouts were AssCreed Mirage, Alan Wake 2, Dragon's Dogma 2, Helldivers 2 (strong Starship Troopers vibes) and (maybe) Spiderman 2. I am iffy on Spiderman 2 for two reasons: one being that overall the visuals aren't the jump up visually I expected of a PS5-only game (did you see those water effects?), the other being there was a part in the warehouse with Miles where he grabbed two enemies and yet...somehow...neither of the enemies just feet away from them noticed? Sus AI moment IMHO.
There were a few neat indie games, but in a showcase that was lacking some expected reveals such as this one, they would've been better served for a State of Play. What really surprised me (and not in a good way) was just how little 1P presence was here. Outside of Haven, Bungie, and Insomniac, they had no 1P. And the Haven & Bungie stuff were just live-action/GaaS and also CG trailers. And instead of some update for the actual GT7 game, we got a rehash of the movie trailer in the showcase!? Who thought that was a good idea!?
Right now, it wouldn't be that hard for Microsoft to outdo this with their June Showcase, and I'm hoping they actually do. Same with the SGF event. Some of the 3P reveals I expected at the PlayStation Showcase may probably show up at those two (particularly SGF). Also, very surprised there was no showing of Stellar Blade, and that's supposed to be coming out this year right?
Maybe Sony are playing 4D chess to look weak to the regulators, or lure Microsoft into a false sense of security so they say "hey guess we don't need ABK after all" and cancel the deal in July. Who knows at this point
.