i gladly would have scores for every section of the game plus final score. fun factor, x factor is a thing, some things just clicks. but at least i would know, where all other things stands. especially, when loads of reviews have Final Note.
At the end of the day, I think everyone settled on "read the text of the review for details" as assigning a discrete number to various aspects of the game was hard even for an individual reviewer, and basically impossible to make consistent across different reviewers.