What are your 6 GOTY nominees ?

[JAHGamer]

Baldur Gate 3
Hogwarts Legends
Zelda: Tears of Kingdom

I think these are the only worth of GOTY for now.

If Hogwarts is one of the only GOTY worthy games, you should at least be able to get the name right

 

[JAHGamer]

What I think the keighley awards will nominate

BG3
Street Fighter 6
TotK
Cocoon
Re4 Remake
Spiderman 2

My personal list
BG3 (my goty)
ghost trick phantom detective
FF16
cyberpunk 2077
genshin
sakuna of rice and ruin (yes not from this year but it still deserves a nom)

Cyberpunk isn't from this year either but I did really like the 2.0 upgrade and Phantom Liberty DLC

 

[anonpuffs]

Cyberpunk isn't from this year either but I did really like the 2.0 upgrade and Phantom Liberty DLC

yeah but i didn't play it til this year, my personal list is just games that i played this year (haven't played re4 cuz i'm waiting for the psvr2 version to play it)

 

[JAHGamer]

yeah but i didn't play it til this year, my personal list is just games that i played this year (haven't played re4 cuz i'm waiting for the psvr2 version to play it)

Same here, RE4 remake and Bulletstorm on PVSR2 are 2 of my most anticipated games

 

[JAHGamer]

I think that Final Fantasy VII Part 2 will win next year. Bold prediction this far out.

I think FF7 Rebirth, as amazing as it looks, will be nominated but won’t win, it’ll be penalized for being a “remake/reimagining”.

 

[Calverz]

Starfield
Hi-Fi Rush
Forza Motorsport
Redfall
Lies of P
Age 2 on console

Most likely starfield will win but would be great to see any of those win.

 

[JAHGamer]

Starfield
Hi-Fi Rush
Forza Motorsport
Redfall
Lies of P
Age 2 on console

Most likely starfield will win but would be great to see any of those win.

Thank you, I needed a good laugh this morning

 

[anonpuffs]

Starfield
Hi-Fi Rush
Forza Motorsport
Redfall
Lies of P
Age 2 on console

Most likely starfield will win but would be great to see any of those win.

Cmon bro at least put some effort into your trolling, this just makes me feel bad for you

 

[Evilms]

Hogwarts Legacy
The Legend of Zelda Tears of The kingdom
Final Fantasy XVI
Diablo IV
Baldur's Gate 3
Marvel's Spider-Man 2

And maybe Armored Core 6 or Alan Wake 2

 

[Vertigo]

Only played Remnant, FF16 and Zelda so far…

My only pick is Remnant 2.


PS - selecting games that haven’t released already as goty picks is top tier fanboy garbage btw. I now doubt the Bg3 listing as I don’t buy some of you even bought it and just doing listing it because metacrtic says so.

 

[Dick Jones]

Baldur's Gate 3
Zelda:TotK
Resident Evil 4make
Final Fantasy XVI
xxxxxxxxxx
Sea of Stars




The last will likely be filled by Spider-Man 2 but since it isn't out yet, I'm not including it. I think it will end in the order above with Sea of Stars getting the Indie spot and the moral victory. The only way I see Sea of Stars not competing is if the new Mario game is godlike. Baldur's Gate 3 will smash it. Zelda is not my personal favourite Zelda style but it has an audience. I don't see it winning as the air is gone from it unlike how BotW was where it was spoken of years after. Final Fantasy needs to release a few constant great quality game releases in a row to be taken serious like how RE4make is running because RE2make crawled. I think that Final Fantasy VII Part 2 will win next year. Bold prediction this far out.

Actually if MS push Hi-Fi Rush and actually promote it I could see it take Sea of Stars spot. They would have to announce DLC (doesn’t need to be in production, judt announce it) or pay their shills promote it. The praise disappeared quickly but it never had a chance to get hype when it was thrown out to fend for itself. Fucking Redfall had more of the machine behind it. Redfall. Holy Moses.

 

[anonpuffs]

Hogwarts Legacy
The Legend of Zelda Tears of The kingdom
Final Fantasy XVI
Diablo IV
Baldur's Gate 3
Marvel's Spider-Man 2

And maybe Armored Core 6 or Alan Wake 2

Is this a list for Keighley's show? I think hogwarts is too controversial with the danger hairs that it won't be able to get a nom

 

[PropellerEar]

This better not be some obscure game of looking up women's panties stuff that @Dr Bass likes

 

[Gediminas]

Diablo 4
Star Wars Jedi Survivor
Hogwarts Legacy
FF16
Spider Man 2 (99.999999999999999999%)
Assassin's Creed Mirage
Wo Long : Fallen Dynasty

 

[arvfab]

Spider-Man 2 (probably)
FF16
Baldur's Gate 3
Pikmin 4

For indies:
Sea of Stars
Tchia

Honorable mention, but I don't think remakes should be considered:

RE4 Remake

 

[Heisenberg007]

1. Redfall (GOTY)
2. Forza Motorsport (runner-up)
3. Starfield (Game of the Generation!)

 

[ethomaz]

Add spiderman 2 to that list NOW.

I did not like the first game and don’t plan to but the second.

Probably won’t enter in my GOTY list.

 

[ethomaz]

Baldur Gate 3
Hogwarts Legends
Zelda: Tears of Kingdom

I think these are the only worth of GOTY for now.

After the new release I need to update my list.

Baldur's Gate 3
Hogwarts Legends
Zelda: Tears of Kingdom
Spider-man 2
Super Mario Wonder
Street Fighter 6
Remake 4

These are my final list.

Edit - I forgot SMW.

 

[Systemshock2023]

Lies of P has to be in the discussion. System shock remake is great but it's not popular enough to qualify.

Haven't played other 2023 games so far.

 

[Petekilla]

After the new release I need to update my list.

Baldur's Gate 3
Hogwarts Legends
Zelda: Tears of Kingdom
Spider-man 2
Street Fighter 2
Remake 4

These are my final list.

Super Mario Wonder will definitely be a nominee.