Microsoft's acquisition of Activison Blizzard

Gods&Monsters

Veteran
21 Jun 2022
5,581
11,388
Ryan did not furnish any responses Microsoft-friendly journalists can use against him, but I'm sure they'll try. Will be interesting to see how his testimony is received.

He even clarified his EU remarks. Ryan ultimately reached the conclusion the deal was anti-competitive and hoped regulators would straight-up block it.
The narrative is that Jim made a complete fool of himself. You can see all the usual suspects making these comments everywhere. They didn't even watch the trial.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PS_ROCKS and Nitro

Nhomnhom

Banned
25 Mar 2023
8,414
11,558
The narrative is that Jim made a complete fool of himself. You can see all the usual suspects making these comments everywhere. They didn't even watch the trial.
The narrative existed before he even said anything, just like the narrative that Phil nailed it, that the FTC is embarrassing itself, that all the documents are meaningless, it's all too predictable.
 

Nitro

Active member
10 Apr 2023
214
573
North Pole

AshHunter216

Banned
8 Jan 2023
4,556
7,628
IGN with the first clickbait headline, completely distorting the narrative


They make it sound like Jim Ryan was FORCED to make an admission. Complete bullshit.
We already know what these websites are about. This is nothing new.
 

Gediminas

Boy...
Founder
21 Jun 2022
7,465
9,188
So was there anything notable from Jim's testimony? Anything the usual suspects will try to weaponize?
not really. unless there was something with timeline of statements. because it is hard to know all what was said and what they speaking about.

apart from that. no. no ammo. but you clearly know, that they will weaponize nothingburger is needed.
ms lawyer tried hard to do that but is looked more like harassing him then actually making points.
 

Loy310

Veteran
14 Aug 2022
1,564
1,833
IGN with the first clickbait headline, completely distorting the narrative


They make it sound like Jim Ryan was FORCED to make an admission. Complete bullshit.
Did you listen to Jim? Jim Ryan literally said it's not anti competitive when asked, and i have no idea why he would have said that, he should have said yes and when asked why all he had to say was for the same reason keeping cod off PS would be anticompetitive cause it would shrink PS user base.
Disappointing to say but jim did not do that great today unfortunately, it was as if he no longer cares about the deal going thru, hopefully it's because SIE got something planned to counter this merger..

On top of that calling a handheld a console, cmon Jim....... Then to make matters worse when asked about cloud he basically answered the way MS would have wanted him to by saying that its additive to the console and not separate. FFS Jim.
 

Aidendelaney95

Well-known member
9 Jul 2022
348
449
29
Did you listen to Jim? Jim Ryan literally said it's not anti competitive when asked, and i have no idea why he would have said that, he should have said yes and when asked why all he had to say was for the same reason keeping cod off PS would be anticompetitive cause it would shrink PS user base.
Disappointing to say but jim did not do that great today unfortunately, it was as if he no longer cares about the deal going thru, hopefully it's because SIE got something planned to counter this merger..
...at least you tried?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nitro

Nhomnhom

Banned
25 Mar 2023
8,414
11,558
Why do they always frame everything around CoD and not ABK as a whole? ABK is not just CoD, it's also Warcraft, Diablo, Overwatch, THPS, etc.
 

Gediminas

Boy...
Founder
21 Jun 2022
7,465
9,188
Did you listen to Jim? Jim Ryan literally said it's not anti competitive when asked, and i have no idea why he would have said that, he should have said yes and when asked why all he had to say was for the same reason keeping cod off PS would be anticompetitive cause it would shrink PS user base.
Disappointing to say but jim did not do that great today unfortunately, it was as if he no longer cares about the deal going thru, hopefully it's because SIE got something planned to counter this merger..
that is nonsense completely. by agreeing that is anti-competitive, it would opened other doors wide open to eat Sony alive. it clearly was a huge bait.
 

FatKaz

Veteran
16 Jul 2022
2,256
4,252
Did you listen to Jim? Jim Ryan literally said it's not anti competitive when asked, and i have no idea why he would have said that, he should have said yes and when asked why all he had to say was for the same reason keeping cod off PS would be anticompetitive cause it would shrink PS user base.
Disappointing to say but jim did not do that great today unfortunately, it was as if he no longer cares about the deal going thru, hopefully it's because SIE got something planned to counter this merger..
It's probably because it will bite him in the ass in the future and in the cross examination.
 

Dr Bass

The doctor is in
Founder
20 Jun 2022
2,040
3,449
Did you listen to Jim? Jim Ryan literally said it's not anti competitive when asked, and i have no idea why he would have said that, he should have said yes and when asked why all he had to say was for the same reason keeping cod off PS would be anticompetitive cause it would shrink PS user base.
Disappointing to say but jim did not do that great today unfortunately, it was as if he no longer cares about the deal going thru, hopefully it's because SIE got something planned to counter this merger..

On top of that calling a handheld a console, cmon Jim....... Then to make matters worse when asked about cloud he basically answered the way MS would have wanted him to by saying that its additive to the console and not separate. FFS Jim.
Everything he said is true.

And on the Starfield thing, if he said it was anti competitive ... what do you think that would mean for Sony? I mean come on, think about this.
 
24 Jun 2022
3,956
6,899
So was there anything notable from Jim's testimony? Anything the usual suspects will try to weaponize?

He did allude to a predatory pricing strategy on MS's part by leveraging acquired content in Game Pass vs. a competitor like Sony needing to rely on B2P sales of those same games. MS are known for having a variety of means to get Game Pass for super cheap, even technically free via MS Reward points (if you have enough).So if people want, they can get access to the same ABK games Sony would have to sell at full B2P MSRP.

It's essentially a form of predatory pricing since MS can sustain money losses of such strategy for years, even decades, given gaming revenue is peanuts for them compared to their real breadwinners. Sony has other strong divisions but PlayStation on its own is easily the largest pillar at the company financially speaking. They can't engage in the same type of loss-leading strategy on software while already taking losses (in theory) on the hardware to make up for in B2P sales revenue of software.
 
D

Deleted member 223

Guest
Not a bad showing for Jim. No haymakers but no own-goals either. I think overall it's a MS success cause Sony will never get the same shake if put on the burner but that goes with the territory.

The behavior here did not lay any future mines on Sony's potential acquisition of mid-level pubs and devs while still sticking it to MS, albeit, not in the most bloody and optimal fashion that it could have possibly been. There is a trade-off.

Media is a disgrace. While I do not like excrement I do enjoy seeing it become more obvious for others who may have been under their spell. It's a liberating experience once the masks fall. It's not like they're very well at creating the masks for those with a trained brain but for your average Joe the masks do work - which is always the point of the mask (not who can seen through them but most importantly - who can't).
 
Last edited by a moderator:

BlueLyria

Well-known member
29 Apr 2023
397
379
Holy shit this model discussion is annonying, dude explained it's about gen 8 and the lawyer keeps going back to gen 9
 

Nhomnhom

Banned
25 Mar 2023
8,414
11,558
Bots always with the same lines, pathetic. Hive mind.
Dude refrains from commenting yet it's somehow watching this stuff live. Sure...

Anyone following this is either an Xbot or PlayStation fan that likelly hates Xbox. Nobody else cares anymore (it they ever did).